Translation created with model: qwen3-14b-nothink-sbs-3step-fewshot
古今图书集成医部全录卷六十九
扁鹊难经
上经
【滑寿曰:此书固有类例,但当如《大学》,朱子分章以见记者之意则可,不当以己之立类统经之篇章也。今观一难至二十一难皆言脉,二十二难至二十九难论经络流注始终、长短度数,奇经之行,及病之吉凶也。其间有云:脉者非谓尺寸之脉,乃经隧之脉也。三十难至四十三难言荣卫、三焦、脏腑、肠胃之详。四十四、五难言七冲门乃人身资生之用,八会为热病在内之气穴也。四十六、七难言老幼寤寐以明气血之盛衰,言人面耐寒以见阴阳之走会。四十八难至六十一难,言诊候、病能、脏腑、积聚、泄利、伤寒、杂病之别,而继之望闻问切,医之能事毕矣。六十二难至八十一难言脏腑荣俞、用针补泻之法,又全体之学所不可无者。此记者以类相从始终之意备矣。】 【滑寿曰:右寸手太阴阳明金,生左尺足太阳少阴水;太阳少阴水,生左关足厥阴少阳木;厥阴少阳木,生左寸手太阳少阴火;太阳少阴火,通右尺手心主少阳火;手心主少阳火,生右关足太阴阳明土;足太阴阳明土,复生右寸手太阴阳明金。此皆五行子母更相生养者也。】
经脉始从中焦流注之图
见图
Explanation
Volume 69 of the Complete Medical Section of the Comprehensive System of Ancient and Modern Books
The Difficult Classic of Bian Que
Upper Canon
[Commentary by Hua Shou: This text indeed has categories, but it should be treated as the Great Learning, where Master Zhu divided it into chapters in order to reveal the original compiler’s intent. It should not be organized according to one’s own established categories that encompass the canonical passages. Now, observing the first to the twenty-first difficulty, all discuss the pulse; from the twenty-second to the twenty-ninth difficulty, they discuss the beginning and end, length and measurement of the meridians, the course of the extraordinary meridians, and the auspiciousness or inauspiciousness of diseases. Among these, it is stated: “The pulse does not refer to the cun and chi pulses, but to the pulses of the meridians.” From the thirtieth to the forty-third difficulty, they discuss in detail the nutritive and defensive qi, the Sanjiao (Triple Burner), the zang-fu organs, and the stomach and intestines. The forty-fourth and forty-fifth difficulties discuss the seven orifices, which are essential for nourishment and life, and the eight gatherings, which are the qi points for internal febrile diseases. The forty-sixth and forty-seventh difficulties discuss the waking and sleeping of the old and young in order to illustrate the strength and weakness of qi and blood, and the ability of the face to withstand cold in order to show the meeting of yin and yang. From the forty-eighth to the sixty-first difficulties, they discuss the distinctions of diagnosis, disease manifestations, zang-fu organs, accumulations, diarrhea, cold injury, and miscellaneous diseases, followed by the four diagnostic methods—inspection, listening and smelling, inquiry, and palpation—thus concluding the complete skill of a physician. From the sixty-second to the eighty-first difficulties, they discuss the meridians and points of the zang-fu organs, the methods of acupuncture for tonification and drainage, which are essential to the study of the whole body. Thus, the compiler’s intention of organizing by categories from beginning to end is fully explained.]
[Commentary by Hua Shou: The right cun pulse, associated with the hand taiyang and yangming (metal), generates the left chi pulse, associated with the foot taiyang and shaoyin (water); the foot taiyang and shaoyin (water) generate the left guan pulse, associated with the foot jueyin and shaoyang (wood); the foot jueyin and shaoyang (wood) generate the left cun pulse, associated with the hand taiyang and shaoyin (fire); the hand taiyang and shaoyin (fire) connect to the right chi pulse, associated with the hand jueyin and shaoyang (fire); the hand jueyin and shaoyang (fire) generate the right guan pulse, associated with the foot taiyang and yangming (earth); the foot taiyang and yangming (earth) in turn generate the right cun pulse, associated with the hand taiyang and yangming (metal). These are all the mutual generation and nourishment of the Five Elements in the parent-child relationship.]
The Diagram of the Meridians Beginning from the Middle Jiao and Flowing Throughout the Body
[See diagram]
关格覆溢之图
见图
男女生于寅申之图
见图
五行母子相生之图
见图
脏腑阴阳寒热之图
见图
色脉相胜相生之图
见图
【虞氏曰:经言男子生于寅,女子生于申,谓其父母之年会合于巳上,男左行十月,至寅而生;女右行十月,至申而生也。故推命家言,男一岁起丙寅,女一岁起壬申。《难经》不言起而言生,谓生下已为一岁矣。壬丙二干,水火也,水火为万物之父母;寅申二支,金木也,为生物成实之终始。木饱在申,金饱在寅,二气自饱相配,故用寅申也。金生于巳,巳与申合,故女子取申;木生于亥,亥与寅合,故男子取寅。所以男年十岁,顺行在亥;女年七岁,逆行在亥。男子十六天癸至,左行至巳,巳者申之生气;女年十四天癸至,右行亦在巳,与男子同在本宫生气之位。阴阳相配,成夫妇之道,故有男女也。上古天真论曰:男子二八而天癸至,精气溢泻,阴阳和,故能有子。女子二七天癸至,任脉通,太冲脉盛,故能有子。此之谓也。】
荣卫清浊升降之图
见图
Explanation
The Diagram of Guan Ge and Overflow
See the diagram.
The Diagram of the Birth of Men and Women in the Years of Yin and Shen
See the diagram.
The Diagram of the Generation of the Five Elements as Parent and Child
See the diagram.
The Diagram of the Zang-Fu Organs, Yin-Yang, Cold and Heat
See the diagram.
The Diagram of the Mutual Generation and Overcoming of Colors and Pulse
See the diagram.
【Suluo said: The classics state that men are born in the year of Yin and women in the year of Shen, meaning that the parents' years must have met in the year of Si or later. A man moves left for ten months and is born in Yin; a woman moves right for ten months and is born in Shen. Therefore, according to the system of fate and destiny, a boy's chart begins at the age of one with Bing Yin, and a girl's chart begins at the age of one with Ren Shen. The Nanjing does not say "begins" but says "is born," meaning that at birth, one is already considered one year old. The two heavenly stems Ren and Bing represent water and fire, which are the parents of all things. The two earthly branches Yin and Shen represent metal and wood, which are the beginning and end of the growth and maturation of life. Wood reaches its fullness in Shen, and metal reaches its fullness in Yin; the two qi naturally complement each other, hence the use of Yin and Shen. Metal is generated in Si, and Si is in harmony with Shen, hence women are associated with Shen; wood is generated in Hai, and Hai is in harmony with Yin, hence men are associated with Yin. Therefore, at the age of ten, a boy moves forward to Hai; at the age of seven, a girl moves backward to Hai. At sixteen, a man reaches the emergence of Tian Kui, moving left to Si, which is the生气 (vital energy) of Shen; at fourteen, a woman reaches the emergence of Tian Kui, moving right to Si, and thus shares the same position of vital energy as the man. Yin and Yang are thus paired, forming the way of husband and wife, and so men and women come into being. The Shanggu Tianzhen Lun says: At the age of two eights (sixteen), a man reaches Tian Kui, and his essence and qi overflow and are discharged, and Yin and Yang harmonize, so he can have children. At the age of two sevens (fourteen), a woman reaches Tian Kui, the Ren Meridian becomes unobstructed, and the Tai Chong pulse becomes strong, so she can have children. This is what is meant.】
The Diagram of the Ascending and Descending of the Clear and Turbid Aspects of Ying and Wei
See the diagram.
肝肺色象浮沉之图
见图
五脏声色臭味液之图
见图
五行举心为例之图
见图
七传间脏之图
见图
Explanation
Diagram of the Color Manifestations and Floating/Sinking Qualities of the Liver and Lungs
See illustration
Diagram of the Sounds, Colors, Odors, Tastes, and Bodily Fluids of the Five Zang Organs
See illustration
Diagram Illustrating the Five Elements with the Heart as an Example
See illustration
Diagram of the Seven Transmissions and Intercalated Organs
See illustration
手足阴阳荥俞刚柔流注之图
见图
【按《难经图绘》旧本浮冗,亥豕甚多,其十二经流注之图舛漏尤甚,以讹承讹,已非一日,是使轩岐之道欲彰而弥晦也,其可乎?兹编稍为正误补遗,亦以尽厥所知而已。】
一难曰:十二经皆有动脉,独取寸口,以决五脏六腑死生吉凶之法,何谓也?
【滑寿曰:十二经谓手足三阴三阳,合为十二经也。手经则太阴肺、阳明大肠、少阴心、太阳小肠、厥阴心包、少阳三焦也;足经则太阴脾、阳明胃、少阴肾、太阳膀胱、厥阴肝、少阳胆也。皆有动脉者,如手太阴脉动中府、云门、天府、侠白,手阳明脉动合谷、阳溪,手少阴脉动极泉,手太阳脉动天窻,手厥阴脉动劳宫,手少阳脉动禾髎,足太阴脉动箕门、冲门,足阳明脉动冲阳、大迎、人迎、气冲,足少阴脉动大溪、阴谷,足太阳脉动委中,足厥阴脉动太冲、五里、阴廉,足少阳脉动下关、听会之类也。谓之经者,以荣卫之流行经常不息者而言。谓之脉者,以血理之分袤行体者而言也。故经者径也,脉者陌也。越人之意,盖谓凡此十二经皆有动脉,如上云云,今置不取,乃独取寸口以决脏腑死生吉凶何耶?】
然。寸口者,脉之大会,手太阴之脉动也。 【滑寿曰:此篇之大旨,下文详言之。寸口,气口也。居手太阴鱼际却行一寸之分,气口之下曰关曰尺云者,皆手太阴所历之处,而手太阴又为百脉流注朝会之始也。五脏别论,帝曰:气口何以独为五脏主?岐伯曰:胃者水谷之海,六腑之大源也。五味入口,藏于胃,以养五脏气而变见于气口也。
Explanation
The Diagram of Yin and Yang Meridians,荥 and俞 Points, and the Flow of Qi in the Hands and Feet
See the diagram.
[According to the old edition of Nanjing Tu Hui, it is verbose and riddled with errors; in particular, the diagram illustrating the flow of the twelve meridians is especially full of mistakes and omissions. Errors have been passed down for many years, causing the teachings of Xuan and Qi to be obscured rather than clarified. How can this be allowed? This compilation makes only minor corrections and supplements, in order to express what I know.]
The First Question Says: Although all twelve meridians have arteries, why is it that only the cun-kou pulse is taken to determine the life or death and fortune or misfortune of the five zang and six fu organs? What is the meaning of this?
[Shua Shou said: The twelve meridians refer to the three yin and three yang meridians of the hands and feet, together making up the twelve meridians. The hand meridians are Taiyin Lung, Yangming Large Intestine, Shaoyin Heart, Taiyang Small Intestine, Jueyin Pericardium, and Shaoyang Triple Burner. The foot meridians are Taiyin Spleen, Yangming Stomach, Shaoyin Kidney, Taiyang Bladder, Jueyin Liver, and Shaoyang Gallbladder. All have arteries, such as the Taiyin hand meridian which pulses at Zhongfu, Yunmen, Tianfu, and Jia Bai; the Yangming hand meridian at He Gu and Yang Xi; the Shaoyin hand meridian at Ji Quan; the Taiyang hand meridian at Tian Kong; the Jueyin hand meridian at Laogong; the Shaoyang hand meridian at He Liao; the Taiyin foot meridian at Ji Men and Chong Men; the Yangming foot meridian at Chong Yang, Da Ying, Ren Ying, and Qi Chong; the Shaoyin foot meridian at Da Xi and Yin Gu; the Taiyang foot meridian at Wei Zhong; the Jueyin foot meridian at Tai Chong, Wu Li, and Yin Lian; and the Shaoyang foot meridian at Xia Guan and Ting Hui, among others.
To call them "meridians" is to refer to the continuous and unceasing flow of Ying and Wei Qi. To call them "pulse" is to refer to the blood vessels that run through the body. Therefore, a "meridian" is like a road, and a "pulse" is like a path through the fields. The intention of Yue Ren is that all these twelve meridians have arteries, as mentioned above, yet now they are not taken into consideration, while the cun-kou pulse alone is used to determine the life or death of the internal organs—why is this so?]
Indeed. The cun-kou is the great convergence of the pulse, and it is the pulsation of the hand Taiyin meridian.
[Shua Shou said: The main idea of this passage is explained in the following text. The cun-kou is also called the qi-kou. It is located one cun behind the Yu Ji point of the hand Taiyin meridian. The area below the cun-kou is called the "Guan" and the "Chi," both of which are locations along the hand Taiyin meridian. Moreover, the hand Taiyin meridian is the beginning point where all the meridians converge and flow. In the Five Zang Differentiation chapter, the Yellow Emperor asked: "Why is the cun-kou pulse the main indicator of the five zang organs?" Qi Bo replied: "The stomach is the ocean of water and grain, the great source of the six fu organs. When the five flavors enter the mouth, they are stored in the stomach, nourish the qi of the five zang organs, and are reflected in the cun-kou pulse."]
《灵枢》第一篇云:脉会太渊。玉版论云:行奇恒之法,自太阴始。注谓先以气口太阴之脉,定四时之正气,然后度量奇恒之气也。经脉别论云:肺朝百脉;又云气口成寸,以决死生。合数论而观之,信知寸口当手太阴之部而为脉之大会明矣。此越人立问之意,所以独取夫寸口,而后世宗之为不易之法。着之篇首,乃开卷第一义也,学者详之。】
人一呼脉行三寸,一吸脉行三寸,呼吸定息,脉行六寸。人一日一夜,凡一万三千五百息,脉行五十度,周于身,漏水下百刻。荣卫行阳二十五度,行阴亦二十五度,为一周也。故五十度复会于手太阴寸口者,五脏六腑之所终始,故法取于寸口也。 【滑寿曰:承上言平人不病而息数匀者也。呼者气之出,阳也;吸者气之入,阴也。《内经》平人气象论云:人一呼脉再动,一吸脉再动,呼吸定息,脉五动。闰以太息,命曰平人。故平人一呼脉行三寸,一吸脉行三寸,呼吸定息,脉行六寸。以呼吸之数言之,一日一夜,凡一万三千五百息;以脉行之数言之,则五十度周于身。而荣卫之行于阳者二十五度,行于阴者亦二十五度。出入阴阳,参考互注,无少间断,五十度毕,适当漏下百刻,为一晬时,又明日之平旦矣,乃复会于手太阴。此寸口所以为五脏六腑之所终始,而法有取于是焉。盖以荣卫始于中焦,注手太阴阳明,阳明注足阳明太阴,太阴注手少阴太阳,太阳注足太阳少阴,少阴注手心主少阳,少阳注足少阳厥阴。计呼吸二百七十息,脉行一十六丈二尺,漏下二刻为一周身。
Explanation
The first chapter of Ling Shu states: "The convergence of the pulses is at Taiyuan." The Yu Ban Lun says: "The method of the extraordinary begins with Taiyin." The commentary explains that one first uses the Taiyin pulse at the qi kou to determine the normal qi of the four seasons, and then measures the extraordinary qi. The Jing Mai Bie Lun states: "The lung governs all the vessels"; it also says: "The qi kou forms the cun, by which life and death can be determined." Considering these several theories together, one clearly understands that the cun kou is located within the territory of the Hand Taiyin and is the great convergence of the pulses. This is the intent of Yueren in establishing the question, hence the unique reliance on the cun kou, which later generations have followed as an unchangeable method. Placing this at the beginning of the chapter is the first principle of the text; scholars should study it carefully.
When a person exhales, the pulse moves three cun; when they inhale, the pulse also moves three cun. At one complete breath, the pulse moves six cun. In one day and night, there are a total of 13,500 breaths, and the pulse moves fifty times around the body, corresponding to the 100 ke of the water clock. The ying wei move through the yang meridians twenty-five times and through the yin meridians twenty-five times, making one full cycle. Therefore, after fifty cycles, the pulse returns to the cun kou of the Hand Taiyin—the starting and ending point of the five zang and six fu organs—hence the method is derived from the cun kou.
Hua Shou says: This follows the previous statement about the normal person who is not ill and has even breathing. Exhalation is the outflow of qi, yang; inhalation is the inflow of qi, yin. The Ping Ren Xiang Fa Lun of the Nei Jing says: "One breath moves the pulse twice; one exhalation moves the pulse twice; at one complete breath, the pulse moves five times." With an extra deep breath, this is called the ping ren. Hence, for the ping ren, one breath moves the pulse three cun, one exhalation moves the pulse three cun, and at one complete breath, the pulse moves six cun. Considering the number of breaths, in one day and night there are 13,500 breaths; considering the movement of the pulse, it moves fifty times around the body. The ying wei move through the yang meridians twenty-five times and through the yin meridians twenty-five times. The movement between yin and yang is continuous and unbroken, with mutual reference and annotation. After fifty cycles, it coincides with the 100 ke of the water clock, marking one zui shi, and the next day's ping dan. Then the pulse returns to the Hand Taiyin. This is why the cun kou is the starting and ending point of the five zang and six fu, and the method is derived from it. It is because the ying wei originate in the middle jiao, flow to the Hand Taiyin and Yangming, the Yangming to the Foot Yangming and Taiyin, the Taiyin to the Hand Shaoyin and Taiyang, the Taiyang to the Foot Taiyang and Shaoyin, the Shaoyin to the Hand Jueyin and Shaoyang, and the Shaoyang to the Foot Shaoyang and Jueyin. Counting 270 breaths, the pulse moves 16 zhang 2 chi, corresponding to two ke of the water clock, marking one full circulation of the body.
于是复还注手太阴,积而盈之。人一呼一吸为一息,每刻一百三十五息,每时八刻计一千八十息,十二时九十六刻计一万二千九百六十息,刻之余分得五百四十息,合一万三千五百息也。一息脉行六寸,每二刻二百七十息,脉行一十六丈二尺,每时八刻,脉行六十四丈八尺,荣卫四周于身。十二时计九十六刻,脉行七百七十七丈六尺,为四十八周身。刻之余分行二周身,得三十二丈四尺。总之为五十度周身,脉得八百一十丈也。此呼吸之息,脉行之数,周身之度,合昼夜百刻之详也。行阳行阴,谓行昼行夜也。】
二难曰:脉有尺寸,何谓也?然。尺寸者,脉之大要会也。 【滑寿曰:《说文》云,尺,度名,十寸也。人手却十分动脉为寸口,十寸为尺,规矩事也。古者尺、寸、只、寻、常、仞诸度量,皆以人体为法,故从尸从一,象布指之状。寸,十分也。人手却一寸动脉谓寸口,从又从一,按如《说文》所纪,尤可见人体中脉之尺寸也。尺阴分,寸阳分也。人之一身经络荣卫、五脏六腑,莫不由于阴阳,而或过与不及,于尺寸见焉,故为脉之大要会也。一难言寸口为脉之大会,以肺朝百脉而言也。此言尺寸为脉之大要会,以阴阳对待而言也。大抵手太阴之脉,由中焦出行,一路直至两手大指之端。其鱼际却行一寸九分,通谓之寸口。于一寸九分之中,曰尺曰寸,而关在其中矣。】
从关至尺,是尺内,阴之所治也;从关至鱼际,是寸口内,阳之所治也。 【滑寿曰:关者,掌后高骨之分,寸后尺前,两境间阴阳之界限也。
Explanation
Thus, it returns and focuses on the Hand Taiyin meridian, accumulating and filling it fully. One inhalation and exhalation constitute one breath. In each ke there are one hundred thirty-five breaths; in each hour, with eight ke, there are one thousand eighty breaths. In twelve hours, with ninety-six ke, there are twelve thousand nine hundred sixty breaths. The remainder of the ke amounts to five hundred forty breaths, totaling thirteen thousand five hundred breaths. In one breath, the pulse travels six cun. In two ke, with two hundred seventy breaths, the pulse travels sixteen zhang two chi. In each hour, with eight ke, the pulse travels sixty-four zhang eight chi, completing a full circulation of ying and wei around the body. In twelve hours, totaling ninety-six ke, the pulse travels seven hundred seventy-seven zhang six chi, completing forty-eight full circulations of the body. The remainder of the ke accounts for two full circulations of the body, amounting to thirty-two zhang four chi. In total, the pulse completes fifty full circulations of the body, traveling eight hundred ten zhang. This is the detailed calculation of the number of breaths, the distance the pulse travels, and the measure of the entire body, combined with the hundred ke of day and night. To move in yang and yin is to move in day and night.
The Second Difficulty Says: What is meant by the cun and chi in the pulse? Indeed, the cun and chi are the major meeting points of the pulse.
[Hua Shou says: According to Shuowen Jiezi, chi is a unit of measurement, equal to ten cun. The cun kou (inch mouth) is located at the radial artery, one-tenth of the distance from the wrist, and ten cun make one chi—this is a standard measurement. In ancient times, units such as chi, cun, zhi, xun, chang, and ren were all based on the human body, hence the character for chi and cun includes the radical for the body (shi) and the numeral (yi), representing the gesture of spreading one's fingers. Cun means one-tenth. The cun kou is the location of the radial artery one cun from the wrist, hence the character for cun includes the radical for the hand (you) and the numeral (yi). As recorded in Shuowen Jiezi, this clearly shows the cun and chi measurements within the human body. The chi belongs to yin, and the cun belongs to yang. All the meridians, ying and wei qi, the five zang and six fu organs of the human body depend on yin and yang, and any excess or deficiency manifests in the cun and chi, hence they are the major meeting points of the pulse. The First Difficulty refers to the cun kou as the great meeting point of the pulse, in reference to the lung gathering all the vessels. This passage refers to the cun and chi as the major meeting points of the pulse, in reference to the relationship between yin and yang. Generally, the Hand Taiyin meridian originates from the middle jiao and proceeds along a path until the tips of both hands. The yuji (fish际) is located one cun and nine fen behind the cun kou, and this is commonly referred to as the cun kou. Within this span of one cun and nine fen, the chi and cun are designated, with the guan located between them.]
From the guan to the chi is the chi region, the domain of yin; from the guan to the yuji is the cun kou region, the domain of yang.
[Hua Shou says: The guan refers to the high bone at the back of the palm, situated between the cun and the chi, marking the boundary between yin and yang.
从关至尺泽谓尺,尺之内,阴所治也。从关至鱼际是寸口,寸口之内,阳所治也。故孙思邈云:从肘腕中横文至掌鱼际后文却而十分之,而入取九分是为尺, 〔 此九分者自肘腕入至鱼际为一尺,十分之为十寸,取第九分之一寸中为脉之尺位。〕 从鱼际后文却还度取十分之一则是寸, 〔 此寸字非寸关尺之寸,乃从肘腕横文至鱼际却而取十分中之一,是一寸也。以此一寸之中取九分为脉之寸口,故下文云:〕 寸十分之,而入取九分之中,则寸口也。】
故分寸为尺,分尺为寸。
【滑寿曰:寸为阳,尺为阴,阳上而阴下。寸之下尺也,尺之上寸也,关居其中以为限也。分寸为尺,分尺为寸,此之谓欤? 【自鱼际穴起一寸之后分为尺,自尺泽穴一尺之前分为寸也。】
故阴得尺内一寸,阳得寸内九分。
【滑寿曰:老阴之数终于十,故阴得尺内之一寸;〔此尺字指鱼际至尺泽,通计十寸者而言。〕 老阳之数极于九,故阳得寸内之九分。 〔 此寸字指人手却寸而言。〕 】
尺寸终始一寸九分,故曰尺寸也。
【滑寿曰:寸为尺之始,尺者寸之终。云尺寸者,以终始对待而言其实贮。寸得九分,尺得一寸,皆阴阳之盈数也。庞安常云:越人取手太阴之行度鱼际后一寸九分,以配阴阳之数。盖谓此也。】
三难曰:脉有太过有不及,有阴阳相乘,有复有溢,有关有格,何谓也? 【滑寿曰:太过不及,病脉也;关格复溢,死脉也。
Explanation
From the guan to shizhe is called chi; within the chi, the Yin governs. From the guan to yujì is the cunkou; within the cunkou, the Yang governs. Thus, Sun Simiao said: From the transverse line at the elbow and wrist to the back of the yujì, measure and divide into ten parts, then take nine parts inward as the chi. [These nine parts, from the elbow and wrist to the yujì, make up one chi; dividing this into ten parts gives ten cun, and taking the ninth part of one cun is the position of the chi in the pulse.] From the back of the yujì, measure backward and take one-tenth as the cun. [This cun is not the cun of the cun-guan-chi system, but rather, from the transverse line at the elbow and wrist to the yujì, measure backward and take one-tenth, which is one cun. From this one cun, taking nine parts is the cunkou; hence the next passage says:] Divide the cun into ten parts, and take nine parts within it, and this is the cunkou.
Thus, the cun is divided into chi, and the chi is divided into cun.
[Commentary by Hua Shou: The cun belongs to Yang, and the chi belongs to Yin; Yang rises and Yin descends. The chi is below the cun, and the cun is above the chi; the guan is situated between them as the boundary. To divide the cun into chi, and the chi into cun—is this what is meant? [From the yujì acupoint, one cun onward is divided into chi; from the shizhe acupoint, one chi before is divided into cun.]
Thus, Yin receives one cun within the chi, and Yang receives nine parts within the cun.
[Commentary by Hua Shou: The number of old Yin ends at ten, hence Yin receives one cun within the chi; [this chi refers to the distance from yujì to shizhe, totaling ten cun.] The number of old Yang reaches its peak at nine, hence Yang receives nine parts within the cun; [this cun refers to the measurement backward from the wrist.]
The beginning and end of cun and chi total one cun and nine parts, hence they are called cun and chi.
[Commentary by Hua Shou: The cun is the beginning of the chi, and the chi is the end of the cun. To speak of cun and chi is to speak of their relationship in terms of beginning and end. The cun receives nine parts, and the chi receives one cun; both are the full numbers of Yin and Yang. Pang Anchang said: The physician Hua Tuo measured the course of the hand Taiyin meridian, one cun and nine parts behind the yujì, to correspond with the numbers of Yin and Yang. This is what is meant.]
The Third Difficulty says: The pulse may be excessive, deficient, or have Yin and Yang multiplying each other; it may have fu (repetition) or yi (overflow), or guan (obstruction) or ge (blockage). What is this referring to?
[Commentary by Hua Shou: Excess and deficiency are disease pulses; guan and ge with fu and yi are death pulses.]
关格之说,《素问》六节脏象论,及《灵枢》第九篇、第四十九篇,皆主气口人迎,以阳经取决于人迎,阴经取决于气口也。今越人乃以关前关后言者,以寸为阳而尺为阴也。】
然。关之前者,阳之动也,脉当见九分而浮。过者法曰太过,减者法曰不及。 【滑寿曰:关前为阳寸脉所动之位,脉见九分而浮。九,阳数。寸之位,浮阳脉,是其常。过,谓过于本位,过于常脉。不及,谓不及本位,不及常脉,皆病脉也。】
遂上鱼为溢,为外关内格,此阴乘之脉也。 【滑寿曰:遂者,隧也,径行而直前也。谢氏谓遂者直上直下,殊无回旋之生意,有旨哉!经曰:阴气太盛,则阳气不得相营也,以阳气不得营于阴,阴遂上出而溢于鱼际之分为外关内格也。外关内格,谓阳外闭而不下,阴从而内出以格拒之,此阴乘阳位之脉也。】
关以后者,阴之动也,脉当见一寸而沉。过者法曰太过,减者法曰不及。 【滑寿曰:关后为阴尺脉所动之位,脉见一寸而沉。一寸,阴数。尺之位,沉阴脉,是其常。过,谓过于本位,过于常脉。不及,谓不及本位,不及常脉,皆病脉也。】
遂入尺为覆,为内关外格,此阳乘之脉也。 【滑寿曰:经云阳气太盛,则阴气不得相营也。以阴气不得营于阳,阳遂下陷而复于尺之分,为内关外格也。内关外格,谓阴内闭而不上,阳从而外入以格拒之,此阳乘阴位之脉也。】
故曰:覆溢。
【滑寿曰:覆如物之覆,由上而倾于下也;溢如水之溢,由内而出乎外也。】
是其真脏之脉,人不病而死也。
Explanation
The Theory of Guan Ge is discussed in the Liu Jie Zang Xiang Lun chapter of Suwen, as well as in chapters 9 and 49 of Ling Shu, all of which emphasize the qi kou and ren ying pulse positions, with the pulse of yang meridians being determined by ren ying and that of yin meridians by qi kou. Now, Yue Ren refers to the positions before and after the guan pulse, taking the cun as yang and the chi as yin.
Indeed, the area before the guan is where yang is active; the pulse should be visible to the ninth division and floating. If it exceeds this, it is termed taiguo (excess); if it is less, it is termed bují (deficiency).
[As Hua Shou said: The area before the guan is the location where the yang cun pulse moves. The pulse should be visible to the ninth division and floating. Nine is the yang number. At the cun position, a floating pulse is the norm. "Over" means exceeding its proper position and surpassing the normal pulse. "Deficient" means falling short of its proper position and falling below the normal pulse; both are pathological pulses.]
When the pulse proceeds upward to the yuji (fish际), it becomes yi (overflow), known as wai guan nei ge (external closure, internal obstruction), and is a pulse pattern caused by yin excess.
[Hua Shou said: "Suí" means a passage or channel, a straight path proceeding directly forward. Xie said that "suí" means going straight up and down, lacking any turning or change — a profound insight indeed! The classics state: when yin qi is excessively strong, yang qi cannot circulate properly. Since yang qi cannot circulate to yin, yin thus rises and overflows into the yuji region, resulting in wai guan nei ge. Wai guan nei ge refers to yang being externally closed and not descending, while yin rises internally to resist it — this is a pulse pattern where yin dominates the yang position.]
The area after the guan is where yin is active; the pulse should be one cun in length and deep. If it exceeds this, it is termed taiguo (excess); if it is less, it is termed bují (deficiency).
[Hua Shou said: The area after the guan is the location where the yin chi pulse moves. The pulse should be one cun in length and deep. One cun is the yin number. At the chi position, a deep pulse is the norm. "Over" means exceeding its proper position and surpassing the normal pulse. "Deficient" means falling short of its proper position and falling below the normal pulse; both are pathological pulses.]
When the pulse proceeds downward into the chi, it becomes fu (covering), known as nei guan wai ge (internal closure, external obstruction), and is a pulse pattern caused by yang excess.
[Hua Shou said: The classics state that when yang qi is excessively strong, yin qi cannot circulate properly. Since yin qi cannot circulate to yang, yang thus sinks downward and returns to the chi region, resulting in nei guan wai ge. Nei guan wai ge refers to yin being internally closed and not rising, while yang enters externally to resist it — this is a pulse pattern where yang dominates the yin position.]
Thus it is called fu yi (covering and overflowing).
[Hua Shou said: Fu is like an object covering, descending from above; yi is like water overflowing, emerging from within to the outside.]
This is the pulse of the true organs; it indicates death without illness.
【滑寿曰:覆溢之脉,乃孤阴独阳,上下相离之诊,故曰真脏之脉,谓无胃气以和之也。凡人得此脉,虽不病,犹死也。此篇言阴阳之太过不及,虽为病脉,犹未至危殆,若遂上鱼入尺而为覆溢,则死脉也。此遂字最为切紧,盖承上起下之要言。不然则太过不及,阴阳相乘,关格覆溢,浑为一意,漫无轻重矣。或间此篇之阴阳相乘,与二十篇之说同异。曰:此篇乃阴阳相乘之极,而为覆溢。二十篇则阴阳更相乘而伏匿也。更之一字,与此篇遂字,大有径庭。更者更互之更,遂者直遂之遂,而覆溢与伏匿,又不能无辨。盖覆溢为死脉,伏匿为病脉,故不可同日语也。此书首三篇,乃越人开卷第一义也。一难言寸口,统阴阳关尺而言。二难言尺寸,以阴阳始终对待而言,关亦在其中矣。三难之覆溢,以阴阳关格而言,尤见关为津要之所。合而观之,三部之义备矣。一二难言阴阳之常,三难言阴阳之变。】
四难曰:脉有阴阳之法何谓也?然。呼出心与肺,吸入肾与肝。呼吸之间,脾受谷味也,其脉在中。 【滑寿曰:呼出为阳,吸入为阴,心肺为阳,肾肝为阴,各以部位之高下而应之也。一呼再动心肺主之,一吸再动,肾肝主之,呼吸定息脉五动,闰以太息,脾之候也。故曰呼吸之间,脾受谷味也,其脉在中。在中者,在阴阳呼吸之中。何则?以脾受谷味,灌溉诸脏,诸脏皆受气于脾土,主中宫之义也。】
浮者阳也,沉者阴也,故曰阴阳也。 【滑寿曰:浮为阳,沉为阴,此承上文起下文之义。】
心肺俱浮,何以别之?然。
Explanation
Hua Shou said: The pulse of overflow (fuyi) is a condition of isolated yin and isolated yang, where the upper and lower parts are separated, hence it is called the pulse of the true zang organs, meaning it lacks wei qi to harmonize it. If a person has this pulse, even if they are not ill, they will still die. This chapter discusses the excess and deficiency of yin and yang; although such a pulse indicates illness, it has not yet reached the point of extreme danger. However, if it proceeds upward to the fish (yu) and downward to the chi (chi), becoming overflow, then it is a death pulse. The character "sui" (遂) here is particularly crucial, as it serves as the key phrase that links the previous and following ideas. Otherwise, excess and deficiency, yin and yang multiplying upon each other, and the conditions of guange and fuyi would all be treated as one idea, without distinction of importance. Someone may ask whether the discussion of yin and yang multiplying upon each other in this chapter is the same as in the twentieth chapter. It is said: This chapter describes the extreme case of yin and yang multiplying upon each other, resulting in overflow. In the twentieth chapter, yin and yang alternate in multiplying upon each other, resulting in concealment (fuben). The character "geng" (更) in the twentieth chapter is vastly different from the character "sui" (遂) in this chapter. "Geng" means alternating or mutual succession, while "sui" means direct progression. Likewise, overflow and concealment are not the same. Overflow is a death pulse, while concealment is a disease pulse; thus, they cannot be spoken of on the same day. The first three chapters of this book represent the first fundamental principle introduced by Yueren at the beginning of the text. The first difficulty discusses the cun Kou, speaking generally of yin and yang, the guan and chi. The second difficulty discusses the cun and chi, speaking of yin and yang in terms of beginning and end, with the guan also included within this. The third difficulty's discussion of overflow is based on yin and yang's obstruction (guange), especially highlighting the guan as a crucial location. When viewed together, the meanings of the three sections are fully explained. The first and second difficulties discuss the normal state of yin and yang, while the third discusses their changes.
Fourth difficulty: What is meant by the principle of yin and yang in the pulse? Answer: When one exhales, the heart and lungs are involved; when one inhales, the kidneys and liver are involved. Between the breaths, the spleen receives the essence of food, and its pulse is located in the middle. Hua Shou said: Exhaling is yang, inhaling is yin; the heart and lungs are yang, the kidneys and liver are yin, each corresponding to their positions of high and low. One exhalation moves twice, with the heart and lungs being in charge; one inhalation moves twice, with the kidneys and liver being in charge. When the breath is steady, the pulse moves five times, and with an additional sigh, it is the sign of the spleen. Therefore, it is said that between the breaths, the spleen receives the essence of food, and its pulse is located in the middle. "In the middle" refers to being in the middle of yin and yang breathing. Why? Because the spleen receives the essence of food, nourishing all the organs, and all the organs receive qi from the earth element of the spleen, which is the meaning of the central palace.
A floating pulse is yang, a deep pulse is yin, hence it is called yin and yang. Hua Shou said: Floating is yang, deep is yin; this is the meaning of continuing from the previous text to introduce the following text.
Both the heart and lungs have a floating pulse; how can they be distinguished? Answer.
浮而大散者心也,浮而短濇者肺也。肾肝俱沉,何以别之?然,牢而长者肝也;按之濡、举指来实者肾也。脾者中州,故其脉在中,是阴阳之法也。 【滑寿曰:心肺俱浮而有别也,心为阳中之阳,故其脉浮而大散;肺为阳中之阴,其脉浮而短濇。肝肾俱沉而有别也,肝为阴中之阳,其脉牢而长;肾为阴中之阴,其脉按之濡,举指来实。古益袁氏谓肾属水脉,按之濡、举指来实,外柔内刚,水之象也。脾说见前。】
脉有一阴一阳、一阴二阳、一阴三阳,有一阳一阴、一阳二阴、一阳三阴,如此之言,寸口有六脉俱动邪?然,此言者,非有六脉俱动,谓浮、沉、长、短、滑、濇也。浮者阳也,滑者阳也,长者阳也;沉者阴也,短者阴也,濇者阴也。所谓一阴一阳者,谓脉来沉而滑也;一阴二阳者,谓脉来沉滑而长也;一阴三阳者,谓脉来浮滑而长,时一沉也。所言一阳一阴者,谓脉来浮而濇也;一阳二阴者,谓脉来长而沉濇也;一阳三阴者,谓脉来沉濇而短,时一浮也。各以其经所在,名病逆顺也。 【滑寿曰:设问答以明阴阳脉见于三部者,不单至也。惟其不单至,故有此六脉相兼,而见浮者轻手得之,长者过度本位,滑者往来流利,皆阳脉也;沉者重手得之,短者不及本位,濇者往来凝滞,皆阴脉也。惟其相兼,故有一阴一阳,又一阳一阴,如是之不一也。夫脉之所至,病之所在也,以脉与病及经络脏腑参之,某为宜,某为不宜,四时相应不相应,以名病之逆顺也。】
五难曰:脉有轻重,何谓也?然。
Explanation
Floating, large, and diffused pulse indicates the heart; floating, short, and涩 (rough) pulse indicates the lung. When both kidney and liver pulses are deep, how can they be distinguished? Indeed, a firm and long pulse indicates the liver; a pulse that is soft when pressed, but solid when the finger is lifted, indicates the kidney. The spleen, being the central region of the body, thus has its pulse located in the center, in accordance with the principles of yin and yang.
【Hua Shou said: The heart and lung both have floating pulses, but they differ. The heart is yang within yang, hence its pulse is floating, large, and diffused; the lung is yin within yang, hence its pulse is floating, short, and涩. The liver and kidney both have deep pulses, but they differ. The liver is yang within yin, hence its pulse is firm and long; the kidney is yin within yin, hence its pulse is soft when pressed, but solid when the finger is lifted. The ancient physician Yuan of Gu Yi said that the kidney belongs to the water element, and its pulse, which is soft when pressed but solid when the finger is lifted, reflects the nature of water—soft on the outside, strong within. The discussion on the spleen is given above.】
The pulse may present as one yin and one yang, one yin and two yangs, one yin and three yangs; or as one yang and one yin, one yang and two yins, one yang and three yins. In this sense, does the cun-kou (radial artery) have all six pulses active? No, this does not mean that all six pulses are active at once, but refers to the six qualities: floating, deep, long, short, slippery, and涩. Floating, slippery, and long are all yang qualities; deep, short, and涩 are all yin qualities. What is meant by "one yin and one yang" is a pulse that is deep and slippery; "one yin and two yangs" is a pulse that is deep, slippery, and long; "one yin and three yangs" is a pulse that is floating, slippery, and long, with occasional depth. What is meant by "one yang and one yin" is a pulse that is floating and涩; "one yang and two yins" is a pulse that is long, deep, and涩; "one yang and three yins" is a pulse that is deep,涩, and short, with occasional floating. Each pulse is named according to the meridian it belongs to, and this determines whether the disease is in accord with or contrary to the normal pattern.
【Hua Shou said: The question-and-answer format is used to clarify that yin and yang pulses do not appear singly in the three sections (cun, guan, chi). Because they do not appear singly, these six pulse qualities may appear in combination. A floating pulse is felt with light pressure, a long pulse extends beyond its normal position, and a slippery pulse flows smoothly—these are all yang pulses. A deep pulse is felt with heavy pressure, a short pulse is shorter than its normal position, and a涩 pulse is sluggish in movement—these are all yin pulses. Because these qualities may appear together, there may be one yin and one yang, or one yang and one yin, and so on, resulting in many variations. The place where the pulse appears is where the disease is located. By examining the pulse together with the disease, the meridians, and the internal organs, we can determine which conditions are appropriate and which are not, and whether they correspond to or differ from the four seasons. This determines the nature of the disease as either in accord or contrary to normal.】
Fifth Difficulty: The pulse has variations of lightness and heaviness—what does this mean? Indeed.
初持脉如三菽之重,与皮毛相得者,肺部也;如六菽之重,与血脉相得者,心部也;如九菽之重,与肌肉相得者,脾部也;如十二菽之重,与筋平者,肝部也;按之至骨,举指来疾者,肾部也。故曰轻重也。 【滑寿曰:肺最居上,主候皮毛,故其脉如三菽之重。心在肺下,主血脉,故其脉如六菽之重。脾在心下,主肌肉,故其脉如九菽之重。肝在脾下,主筋,故其脉如十二菽之重。肾在肝下主骨,故其脉按之至骨举指来实。肾不言菽,以类推之,当如十五菽之重。今按此法以轻重言之,即浮中沉之意也,然于《枢》、《素》无所见,将古脉法而有所授受耶?抑越人自得之见耶?】 【庐陵谢氏曰:此寸关尺所主脏腑各有分位,而一部之中脉又自有轻重。因举陵阳虞氏说云:假令左手寸口如三菽之重得之,乃知肺气之至;如六菽之重得之,知本经之至,余以类求之。夫如是乃知五脏之气更相灌溉,六脉因兹亦有准绳,可以定吉凶言疾病矣。关尺皆然,如十难中十变脉例而消息之也。】
六难曰:脉有阴盛阳虚,阳盛阴虚,何谓也?然。浮之损小,沉之实大,故曰阴盛阳虚;沉之损小,浮之实大,故曰阳盛阴虚。是阴阳虚实之意也。 【滑寿曰:浮沉以下指轻重言,盛虚以阴阳盈亏言,轻手取之而见减少,重手取之而见实大,知其为阴盛阳虚也;重手取之而见损小,轻手取之而见实大,知其为阳盛阴虚也。大抵轻手取之阳之分,重手取之阴之分,不拘何部,率以是推之。】
七难曰:经言少阳之至,乍大乍小,乍短乍长;
Explanation
Initially, when taking the pulse, if it feels as light as three beans and is in harmony with the skin and hair, it belongs to the Lung; if it feels as heavy as six beans and is in harmony with the blood vessels, it belongs to the Heart; if it feels as heavy as nine beans and is in harmony with the muscles, it belongs to the Spleen; if it feels as heavy as twelve beans and is level with the tendons, it belongs to the Liver; if pressing down reaches the bone and the finger returns quickly when lifted, it belongs to the Kidney. Hence it is called the lightness and heaviness of the pulse.
[Shua Shou said: The Lung is situated highest and governs the skin and hair, hence its pulse feels as light as three beans. The Heart is below the Lung and governs the blood vessels, hence its pulse feels as heavy as six beans. The Spleen is below the Heart and governs the muscles, hence its pulse feels as heavy as nine beans. The Liver is below the Spleen and governs the tendons, hence its pulse feels as heavy as twelve beans. The Kidney is below the Liver and governs the bones, hence its pulse reaches the bone and returns solidly when the finger is lifted. The Kidney is not mentioned in terms of beans, but by analogy, it should be as heavy as fifteen beans. Now, according to this method, describing the pulse in terms of lightness and heaviness corresponds to the meaning of floating, middle, and deep. However, this is not found in the Shu or Su texts. Was this an ancient pulse method passed down, or was it a personal insight of Yuèrén?]
[Lúlíng Xiè said: Each of the Cun, Guan, and Chi positions corresponds to specific internal organs, and within each section, the pulse also has its own degree of lightness and heaviness. Referring to the statement by Língyáng Yú: Suppose the pulse at the left Cun position is felt as light as three beans, then one knows the Qi of the Lung has arrived; if it is felt as heavy as six beans, one knows the Qi of the main meridian has arrived; the rest can be understood by analogy. In this way, one understands that the Qi of the five zang organs mutually nourish and irrigate each other, and thus the six pulses also have a standard by which to determine auspiciousness or misfortune and to speak of illness. This applies equally to the Guan and Chi positions, just as in the Ten Difficulties, the Ten Variations of the Pulse are interpreted.]
The Sixth Difficulty says: The pulse may have excess Yin and deficient Yang, or excess Yang and deficient Yin. What does this mean? It means that when lightly palpated, the pulse is diminished and small, and when deeply palpated, it is full and large, hence it is called excess Yin and deficient Yang; when deeply palpated, it is diminished and small, and when lightly palpated, it is full and large, hence it is called excess Yang and deficient Yin. This is the meaning of Yin and Yang deficiency and excess.
[Shua Shou said: Floating and deep refer to the lightness and heaviness of the fingers, while excess and deficiency refer to the surplus and deficiency of Yin and Yang. When lightly palpated, the pulse appears reduced, and when deeply palpated, it appears full and large, indicating excess Yin and deficient Yang; when deeply palpated, it appears reduced and small, and when lightly palpated, it appears full and large, indicating excess Yang and deficient Yin. Generally, light palpation corresponds to the Yang aspect, and deep palpation corresponds to the Yin aspect. Regardless of which section is being examined, this principle is consistently applied.]
The Seventh Difficulty says: The classics state that when the Shao Yang pulse arrives, it alternates between large and small, short and long;
阳明之至,浮大而短;太阳之至,洪大而长;太阴之至,紧大而长;少阴之至,紧细而微;厥阴之至,沉短而敦。此六者是平脉邪?将病脉邪?然。皆王脉也。 【滑寿曰:六者之王,说见下文。】
其气以何月,各王几日?然。冬至之后,得甲子少阳王,复得甲子阳明王,复得甲子太阳王,复得甲子太阴王,复得甲子少阴王,复得甲子厥阴王。王各六十日,六六三百六十日,以成一岁,此三阳三阴之王时日大要也。 【滑寿曰:上文言三阳三阴之王脉,此言三阳三阴之王时,当其时则见其脉也。历家之说,以上古十一月甲子合朔,冬至为历元,盖取夫气朔之分齐也。然天度之运,与日月之行,迟速不一,岁各有差,越人所谓冬至之后得甲子,亦以此欤?是故气朔之不齐,节候之早晚,不能常也。故丁氏注谓冬至之后得甲子,或在小寒之初,或在大寒之后,少阳之至始于此,余经各以次继之。纪氏亦谓自冬至之日一阳始生,于冬至之后得甲子,少阳脉王也。若原其本始,以十一月甲子合朔冬至常例推之,则少阳之王便当从此日始,至正月中,余经各以次继之。少阳之至,阳气尚微,故其脉乍大乍小,乍短乍长。阳明之至,犹有阴也,故其脉浮大而短。太阳之至,阳盛而极也,故其脉洪大而长。阳盛极则变而之阴矣,故夏至后为三阴用事之始。而太阴之至。阴气上微,故其脉紧大而长。少阴之至,阴渐盛也,故其脉紧细而微,厥阴之至,阴盛而极也,故其脉沉短以敦。阴盛极则变而之阳,仍三阳用事之始也。
Explanation
When the qi of Yangming arrives, the pulse is floating, large, and short; when the qi of Taiyang arrives, the pulse is full, large, and long; when the qi of Taoyin arrives, the pulse is tense, large, and long; when the qi of Shaoyin arrives, the pulse is tense, fine, and faint; when the qi of Jueyin arrives, the pulse is deep, short, and firm. Are these six pulse patterns normal or pathological? Yes—they are all the dominant (ruling) pulses. [Hua Shou said: The dominance of these six qi is explained in the following text.]
In which month does each qi begin to dominate, and for how many days? The answer is: After the winter solstice, the qi of Shaoyang begins to dominate on the day of Jiazi; then the qi of Yangming, then Taiyang, then Taoyin, then Shaoyin, then Jueyin. Each qi dominates for sixty days; six times sixty is three hundred and sixty days, making up a full year. This is the fundamental principle of the time periods when the Three Yangs and Three Yins dominate. [Hua Shou said: The previous passage spoke of the dominant pulses of the Three Yangs and Three Yins, while this passage speaks of their respective time periods. At the time of each qi’s dominance, its corresponding pulse is observed. According to the calendar scholars, in ancient times, the conjunction of the sun and moon on the day of Jiazi in the eleventh month marked the winter solstice as the beginning of the calendar era, aiming to align the qi and lunar phases. However, the movement of the heavens and the motion of the sun and moon vary in speed from year to year, and each year differs slightly. This is likely what Yueren meant when he said that after the winter solstice, the day of Jiazi is reached. Therefore, the mismatch between qi and lunar phases, and the irregularity of seasonal transitions, cannot be fixed. Hence, Ding’s commentary states that after the winter solstice, the day of Jiazi may fall at the beginning of the Minor Cold or after the Major Cold, marking the beginning of Shaoyang’s dominance, with the other qi following in turn. Ji also said that from the day of the winter solstice, yang begins to rise, and after the winter solstice, on the day of Jiazi, the pulse of Shaoyang becomes dominant. If we trace back to the original, following the conventional rule that the conjunction of the sun and moon on the day of Jiazi in the eleventh month marks the winter solstice, then the dominance of Shaoyang would begin from that day, and the other qi would follow in turn by the middle of the lunar month. When Shaoyang’s qi arrives, yang is still weak, so its pulse fluctuates, sometimes large, sometimes small, sometimes short, sometimes long. When Yangming’s qi arrives, yin still lingers, hence its pulse is floating, large, and short. When Taiyang’s qi arrives, yang is at its peak, hence its pulse is full, large, and long. When yang reaches its peak, it begins to transform into yin, hence after the summer solstice marks the beginning of the dominance of the Three Yins. When Taoyin’s qi arrives, yin is just beginning to rise, hence its pulse is tense, large, and long. When Shaoyin’s qi arrives, yin gradually becomes stronger, hence its pulse is tense, fine, and faint. When Jueyin’s qi arrives, yin reaches its peak, hence its pulse is deep, short, and firm. When yin reaches its peak, it begins to transform back into yang, marking the beginning of the dominance of the Three Yangs once more.
此则三阳三阴之王脉,所以经六甲而循四时,率皆从微以至乎着,自渐而趋于极,各有其序也。】 【袁氏曰:春温而夏暑,秋凉而冬寒,故人六经之脉,亦随四时阴阳消长迭运而至也。】 【刘温舒曰:至真要论云,厥阴之至其脉弦,少阴之至其脉钩,太阴之至其脉沉,少阳之至大而浮,阳明之至短而濇,太阳之至大而长,亦随天地之气卷舒也。如春弦、夏洪、秋毛、冬石之类,则五运六气,四时亦皆应之,而见于脉尔。若平人气象论太阳脉至洪大而长,少阳脉至乍数乍疏,乍短乍长,阳明脉至浮大而短,《难经》引之以论三阴三阳之脉者,以阴阳始生之浅深而言之也。】 【篇首称经言二字,考之《枢》、《素》无所见。平人气象论虽略有其说而不详,岂越人之时别有所谓上古文字耶?将《内经》有之,而后世脱简耶?是不可知也。后凡言经言而无所考者,义皆仿此。】
八难曰:寸口脉平而死者,何谓也?然。诸十二经脉者,皆系于生气之原。所谓生气之原者,谓十二经之根本也,谓肾间动气也。此五脏六腑之本,十二经脉之根,吸呼之门,三焦之原,一名守邪之神。故气者人之根本也,根绝则茎叶枯矣。寸口脉平而死者,生气独绝于内也。 【滑寿曰:肾间动气,人所得于天以生之气也。肾为子水,位乎坎,北方卦也。乃天一之数而火木金土之先也,所以为生气之原,诸经之根本,又为守邪之神也。原气胜,则邪不能侵。原气绝,则死如木,根绝而茎叶枯矣。故寸口脉平而死者,以生气独绝于内也。
Explanation
This is the sovereign pulse of the Three Yang and Three Yin channels, which thus traverses the cycle of the Six Jia and follows the four seasons. Generally, they all progress from subtle to manifest, from gradual to extreme, each following its own sequence.
[Comment by Yuan: In spring there is warmth, in summer heat, in autumn coolness, and in winter cold. Therefore, the pulses of the Six Channels also follow the waxing and waning of Yin and Yang through the four seasons.]
[Comment by Liu Wenshu: The Zhenzhi Yao Lun (Essence of the True and Essential) states: when Jueyin arrives, its pulse is taut; when Shaoyin arrives, its pulse is deep; when Taiyin arrives, its pulse is sinking; when Shaoyang arrives, its pulse is large and floating; when Yangming arrives, its pulse is short and rough; when Taiyang arrives, its pulse is large and long. These also follow the expansion and contraction of the qi of heaven and earth. Forms such as taut in spring, full in summer, floating in autumn, and firm in winter correspond to the Five Movements and Six Qi, and thus are also reflected in the pulse. For example, in the Pingren Qiangxiang Lun (On the Pulse of the Healthy Person), the pulse of Taiyang is full, large, and long; the pulse of Shaoyang is now rapid, now sparse, now short, now long; the pulse of Yangming is floating, large, and short. The Nan Jing (Difficult Classic) cites these to discuss the pulses of the Three Yin and Three Yang channels, speaking of them in terms of the depth and shallowness of the initial generation of Yin and Yang.]
[At the beginning of the chapter, the term "Jingyan" (what the classics say) is used. However, upon examination of the Lingshu and Suwen, this phrase is not found. The Pingren Qiangxiang Lun mentions this briefly but not in detail. Could this have been a different text from the ancient past in the time of Yue Ren? Or was it originally present in the Neijing but later lost? We cannot know. Henceforth, whenever the term "Jingyan" is used without reference, the meaning shall follow this pattern.]
The Eighth Difficulty says: When the pulse at the Cun Kou is normal yet the person dies, what does this mean? The answer is: All twelve meridians are connected to the source of vital energy. What is meant by the source of vital energy? It refers to the root of the twelve meridians, and also to the dynamic energy within the kidneys. This is the foundation of the five zang and six fu organs, the root of the twelve meridians, the gate of respiration, the source of the Sanjiao, and is also known as the guardian spirit against evil. Therefore, qi is the fundamental essence of a person; if the root is severed, the stem and leaves wither. Thus, when the pulse at the Cun Kou is normal yet the person dies, it is because the vital energy has been uniquely severed from within.
[Comment by Hua Shou: The dynamic energy within the kidneys is the qi that a person receives from heaven to sustain life. The kidney is the water element, located in the position of the坎 (Kan) trigram, which corresponds to the north. It is the first number of heaven, preceding the elements of fire, wood, metal, and earth. Therefore, it is the source of vital energy, the root of all meridians, and also the guardian spirit against evil. When the original qi is strong, evil cannot invade; when the original qi is lost, death is like that of a tree, with the root cut and the leaves withered. Therefore, when the pulse at the Cun Kou is normal yet the person dies, it is because the vital energy has been uniquely severed from within.
】 【此篇与第一难之说,义若相悖,然各有所指也。一难以寸口决生死者,谓寸口为脉之大会,而谷气之变见也。此篇以原气言也,人之原气盛则生,原气绝,则寸口脉虽平犹死也。原气言其体,谷气言其用也。】
九难曰:何以别知脏腑之病耶?然。数者腑也,迟者脏也。数则为热,迟则为寒。诸阳为热,诸阴为寒。故以别知脏腑之病也。 【滑寿曰:凡人之脉,一呼一吸为一息,一息之间脉四至,闰以太息,脉五至,命曰平人。平人者,不病之脉也,其有增减,则为病焉。故一息三至曰迟,不足之脉也;一息六至曰数,太过之脉也。脏为阴,腑为阳。脉数者,属腑,为阳、为热;脉迟者,属脏,为阴、为寒。不特是也,诸阳脉皆为热,诸阴脉皆为寒。脏腑之病,由是别之。】
十难曰:一脉为十变者,何谓也?然。五邪刚柔,相逢之意也。假令心脉急甚者,肝邪干心也;心脉微急者,胆邪干小肠也。心脉大甚者,心邪自干心也;心脉微大者,小肠邪自干小肠也。心脉缓甚者,脾邪干心也;心脉微缓者,胃邪干小肠也。心脉濇甚者,肺邪干心也;心脉微濇者,大肠邪干小肠也。心脉沉甚者,肾邪干心也;心脉微沉者,膀胱邪干小肠也。五脏各有刚柔邪,故令一脉辄变为十也。 【滑寿曰:五邪者,谓五脏五腑之气,失其正而为邪者也。刚柔者,阳为刚,阴为柔也。刚柔相逢,谓脏逢脏,腑逢腑也。五脏五腑,各有五邪,以脉之来甚者属脏,微者属腑,特以心脏发其例,余可类推,故云一脉辄变为十也。】
Explanation
【This chapter's discussion appears to contradict that of the first difficulty, yet each addresses a different aspect. The first difficulty asserts that the pulse at the cun kou can determine life and death, as it is the confluence of the pulse and reveals variations in grain qi. This chapter, however, speaks of primordial qi: when a person's primordial qi is strong, they live; when it is extinguished, even a normal pulse at the cun kou cannot prevent death. Primordial qi refers to the essence, while grain qi refers to function.】
Nine Difficulties: How can one distinguish the diseases of the zang and fu organs? Answer: A rapid pulse indicates a fu organ, a slow pulse indicates a zang organ. A rapid pulse signifies heat, a slow pulse signifies cold. All yang conditions are hot, all yin conditions are cold. Thus, one can distinguish the diseases of the zang and fu organs. 【Hua Shou said: In general, a person's pulse is measured by one inhalation and one exhalation, making one breath. In the span of one breath, the pulse beats four times; with a deep sigh, it beats five times, and this is called the pulse of a healthy person. The pulse of a healthy person is one that does not indicate illness. When there is an increase or decrease in the number of beats, it indicates disease. Therefore, a pulse that beats three times per breath is called chi (slow), a pulse of deficiency; a pulse that beats six times per breath is called shu (rapid), a pulse of excess. The zang organs are yin, the fu organs are yang. A rapid pulse belongs to the fu organs, is yang, and signifies heat; a slow pulse belongs to the zang organs, is yin, and signifies cold. Not only this, but all yang pulses are hot, and all yin pulses are cold. Thus, the diseases of the zang and fu organs can be distinguished in this way.】
Ten Difficulties: What is meant by the phrase "one pulse can give rise to ten variations"? Answer: It refers to the meeting of the five evils in terms of their hardness and softness. For example, if the heart pulse is greatly tense, it indicates that the liver's pathogenic factor is affecting the heart; if the heart pulse is slightly tense, it indicates that the gallbladder's pathogenic factor is affecting the small intestine. If the heart pulse is greatly large, it indicates that the heart's own pathogenic factor is affecting the heart; if the heart pulse is slightly large, it indicates that the small intestine's pathogenic factor is affecting the small intestine. If the heart pulse is greatly slow, it indicates that the spleen's pathogenic factor is affecting the heart; if the heart pulse is slightly slow, it indicates that the stomach's pathogenic factor is affecting the small intestine. If the heart pulse is greatly涩 (constricted), it indicates that the lung's pathogenic factor is affecting the heart; if the heart pulse is slightly涩, it indicates that the large intestine's pathogenic factor is affecting the small intestine. If the heart pulse is greatly deep, it indicates that the kidney's pathogenic factor is affecting the heart; if the heart pulse is slightly deep, it indicates that the bladder's pathogenic factor is affecting the small intestine. Each of the five zang organs has both hard and soft pathogenic factors, hence one pulse can readily give rise to ten variations. 【Hua Shou said: The five evils refer to the qi of the five zang and five fu organs that have lost their proper nature and have become pathogenic. Hardness and softness refer to yang as hard and yin as soft. When hard and soft meet, it means a zang meets a zang or a fu meets a fu. Each of the five zang and five fu has five evils. The pulse that is greatly strong belongs to the zang, and the one that is slightly strong belongs to the fu. Taking the heart as an example, the rest can be inferred similarly, hence the saying that one pulse can readily give rise to ten variations.】
十一难曰:经言脉不满五十动而一止,一脏无气者,何脏也?然。人吸者随阴入,呼者因阳出,今吸不能至肾,至肝而还,故知一脏无气者,肾气先尽也。 【滑寿曰:《灵枢》第五篇云,人一日一夜五十营,以营五脏之精,不应数者,名曰狂生。所谓五十营者,五脏皆受气,持其脉口数其至也。五十动不一代者,五脏皆受气;四十动一代者,一脏无气;三十动一代者,二脏无气;二十动一代者。三脏无气;十动一代者,四脏无气;不满十动一代者,五脏无气,予之短期。按五脏肾最在下,吸气最远,若五十动不满而一止者,知肾无所资,气当先尽,尽犹衰竭也,衰竭则不能随诸脏气而上矣。】
十二难曰:经言五脏脉已绝于内,用针者反实其外;五脏脉已绝于外,用针者反实其内。内外之绝,何以别之?然。五脏脉已绝于内者,肾肝气已绝于内也,而医反补其心肺;五脏脉已绝于外者,其心肺脉已绝于外也,而医反补其肾肝。阳绝补阴,阴绝补阳,是谓实实虚虚,损不足益有余。如此死者,医杀之耳。 【滑寿曰:《灵枢》第一篇云,凡将用针,必先诊脉,视气之剧易乃可以治也。第三篇曰:所谓五脏之气已绝于内者,脉口气内绝不至,反取其外之病处,与阳经之合,有留针以致阳气,阳气至则内重竭,重竭则死矣,其死也无气以动,故静。所谓五脏之气已绝于外者,脉口气外绝不至,反取其四末之输,有留针以致其阴气,阴气至则阳气反入,入则逆,逆则死矣,其死也阴气有余,故躁。此以脉口内外言阴阳也。
Explanation
The Eleventh Difficulty Says: It is said in the classics that when the pulse does not reach fifty beats before stopping once, and one of the five zang organs is without qi, which organ is it? The answer is: When a person inhales, it follows yin inward; when they exhale, it follows yang outward. Now, if the inhalation does not reach the kidney, but instead stops at the liver and returns, it is known that the organ without qi is the kidney, which exhausts first.
[Hua Shou said: The fifth chapter of Ling Shu states that in one day and night, a person undergoes fifty circulations of qi, which nourish the essence of the five zang organs. If the count does not match, it is called kuangsheng (a state of madness or delirium). What is meant by fifty circulations? It refers to the condition where all five zang organs receive qi, as measured by counting the pulse at the mouth of the pulse. If fifty beats occur without a pause, all five organs receive qi; if forty beats occur with one pause, one organ lacks qi; if thirty beats occur with one pause, two organs lack qi; if twenty beats occur with one pause, three organs lack qi; if ten beats occur with one pause, four organs lack qi; if fewer than ten beats occur with one pause, all five organs lack qi, and a short life expectancy is given. Considering that among the five zang organs, the kidney is the lowest and the inhalation reaches the farthest, if the pulse does not reach fifty beats and stops once, it is known that the kidney receives no nourishment, and its qi will deplete first. When the qi is depleted, it cannot follow the qi of the other organs upward.]
The Twelfth Difficulty Says: It is said in the classics that when the pulse of the five zang organs has already failed internally, the practitioner instead strengthens the exterior; when the pulse of the five zang organs has already failed externally, the practitioner instead strengthens the interior. How can one distinguish between internal and external failure? The answer is: When the pulse of the five zang organs has failed internally, it is the qi of the kidney and liver that has failed internally, yet the physician instead supplements the heart and lungs. When the pulse of the five zang organs has failed externally, it is the pulse of the heart and lungs that has failed externally, yet the physician instead supplements the kidney and liver. To supplement yin when yang is exhausted, and to supplement yang when yin is exhausted, is called "strengthening what is already strong and weakening what is already weak," or "damaging what is insufficient and adding to what is already in excess." Those who die in such circumstances are killed by the physician.
[Hua Shou said: The first chapter of Ling Shu states that whenever one is about to use needles, one must first diagnose the pulse and observe the intensity and ease of the qi before treatment can proceed. The third chapter says: What is meant by the qi of the five zang organs having already failed internally? It means that the qi within the mouth of the pulse does not reach inward, yet the physician takes the diseased area on the exterior and the meeting points of the yang meridians, leaving the needle in place to draw in yang qi. When yang qi arrives, the internal condition becomes even more exhausted, and when it is completely exhausted, death occurs. In such a case, there is no qi left to move, hence the body remains still. What is meant by the qi of the five zang organs having already failed externally? It means that the qi at the mouth of the pulse does not reach outward, yet the physician takes the points at the extremities, leaving the needle in place to draw in yin qi. When yin qi arrives, yang qi is driven inward, and when it is driven inward, it becomes reversed. When it is reversed, death occurs. In such a case, yin qi is excessive, hence the body is agitated. This distinction between internal and external at the mouth of the pulse is how yin and yang are spoken of.]
越人以心肺肾肝内外别阴阳,其理亦由是也。纪氏谓此篇言针法,冯玠谓此篇合入用针补泻之类,当在六十难之后,以例相从也。】
十三难曰:经言见其色而不得其脉,反得相胜之脉者,即死;得相生之脉者,病即自已。色之与脉,当参相应,为之奈何? 【滑寿曰:《灵枢》第四篇云,见其色,知其病,命曰明;按其脉,知其病,命曰神;问其病,知其处,命曰工。色脉形肉,不得相失也。色青者其脉弦,赤者其脉钩,黄者其脉代,白者其脉毛,黑者其脉石,见其色而不得其脉,谓色脉之不相得也。色脉既不相得,看得何脉?得相胜之脉即死,得相生之脉病即自已。已,愈也,参合也。】
然。五脏有五色,皆见于面,亦当与寸口尺内相应。假令色青其脉当弦而急,色赤其脉浮大而散,色黄其脉中缓而大,色白其脉浮濇而短,色黑其脉沉濡而滑,此所谓五色之与脉当参相应也。 【滑寿曰:色脉当参相应如是,则见其色得其脉矣。】
脉数,尺之皮肤亦数;脉急,尺之皮肤亦急;脉缓,尺之皮肤亦缓;脉濇,尺之皮肤亦濇;脉滑,尺之皮肤亦滑。 【滑寿曰:《灵枢》第四篇黄帝曰,色脉已定,别之奈何?岐伯曰:调其脉之缓急大小滑濇,肉之坚脆,而病变定矣。黄帝曰:调之奈何?岐伯答曰:脉急,尺之皮肤亦急;脉缓,尺之皮肤亦缓;脉小,尺之皮肤亦减而少气;脉大,尺之皮肤亦贲而起;脉滑,尺之皮肤亦滑;脉濇,尺之皮肤亦濇。凡此变者,有微有甚,故善调尺者不待于寸,善调脉者不待于色。
Explanation
The physician known as "Yueren" distinguishes yin and yang based on the internal and external aspects of the heart, lungs, kidneys, and liver; this principle is also grounded in this reasoning. Ji said that this chapter discusses acupuncture techniques, while Feng Jie said that this chapter should be grouped with those discussing the use of acupuncture for tonification and drainage, and should be placed after the Sixtieth Difficulty, in accordance with the category.
Thirteenth Difficulty: It is said in the classics that when one observes the color on the face but does not find the corresponding pulse, instead finding a pulse in the overcoming relationship, then death will occur; if one finds a pulse in the generating relationship, the disease will resolve by itself. The color and pulse should mutually correspond—what should be done in such a case?
[Shua Shou said: The Fourth Chapter of the Ling Shu states: "Observing the color and knowing the disease is called 'clear'; feeling the pulse and knowing the disease is called 'divine'; asking about the disease and knowing its location is called 'skilled.' Color, pulse, form, and flesh must not be discordant. When the color is green, the pulse is taut; when red, the pulse is hooked; when yellow, the pulse is intermittent; when white, the pulse is floating and thin; when black, the pulse is deep and moist. To see the color but not find the corresponding pulse is to say that the color and pulse are not in harmony. If the color and pulse are not in harmony, what pulse can be seen? If one finds a pulse in the overcoming relationship, death follows; if one finds a pulse in the generating relationship, the disease will resolve by itself. 'Already' here means 'healed,' and also means 'to combine or cross-reference.'"]
Indeed. The five organs correspond to five colors, all of which are visible on the face, and they should also correspond with the pulse at the cun and chi positions. For example, if the color is green, the pulse should be taut and tight; if the color is red, the pulse should be floating, large, and diffused; if the color is yellow, the pulse should be moderate and large; if the color is white, the pulse should be floating, rough, and short; if the color is black, the pulse should be deep, moist, and slippery. This is what is meant by the saying that the five colors should correspond with the pulse.
[Shua Shou said: If the color and pulse correspond in this way, then by seeing the color one can find the pulse.]
When the pulse is rapid, the skin at the chi position is also rapid; when the pulse is taut, the skin is taut; when the pulse is slow, the skin is slow; when the pulse is rough, the skin is rough; when the pulse is slippery, the skin is slippery.
[Shua Shou said: In the Fourth Chapter of the Ling Shu, the Yellow Emperor asked: "If the color and pulse are already determined, how should one distinguish the condition?" Qi Bo replied: "Adjust the pulse's tension, speed, size, and smoothness, as well as the firmness or softness of the flesh, and thus the nature of the disease will be determined." The Yellow Emperor asked: "How should one adjust them?" Qi Bo replied: "When the pulse is taut, the skin at the chi position is also taut; when the pulse is slow, the skin is also slow; when the pulse is small, the skin is also reduced and lacks qi; when the pulse is large, the skin is also swollen and raised; when the pulse is slippery, the skin is also slippery; when the pulse is rough, the skin is also rough. All these changes may be slight or severe; therefore, those skilled in adjusting the chi position do not need to rely on the cun position, and those skilled in adjusting the pulse do not need to rely on the color."
能参合而行之者,可以为上工,上工十全九;行二者为中工,中工十全八;行一者为下工,下工十全六。】 【此通上文所谓色脉形肉不相失也。】
五脏各有声色臭味,当与寸口尺内相应,其不应者病也。假令色青其脉浮濇而短,若大而缓为相胜;浮大而散,若小而滑为相生也。 【滑寿曰:若之为言或也。举色青为例,以明相胜相生也。青者肝之色,浮濇而短,肺脉也,为金克木,大而缓,脾脉也,为木克土,此相胜也。浮大而散,心脉也,为木生火,小而滑,肾脉也,为水生木,此相生也。所谓得相胜之脉即死,得相生之脉病即自已也。】
经言知一为下工,知二为中工,知三为上工。上工者十全九,中工者十全八,下工者十全六,此之谓也。 【滑寿曰:说见前。三谓色、脉、皮肤三者也。】 【此篇问答凡五节:第一为问辞,第二第三节言色脉形肉不得相失,第四节言五脏各有声色臭味,当与寸尺相应。然假令以下,但言色脉相参不言声臭味,殆阙文欤?抑色之着于外者,将切于参验欤?第五节则以所知之多寡为工之上下也。】
十四难曰:脉有损、至,何谓也?然。至之脉一呼再至曰平,三至曰离经,四至曰夺精,五至曰死,六至曰命绝,此至之脉也。何谓损?一呼一至曰离经,再呼一至曰夺精,三呼一至曰死,四呼一至曰命绝,此损之脉也。至脉从下上,损脉从上下也。 【滑寿曰:平人之脉,一呼再至,一吸再至,呼吸定息脉四至。加之则为过,减之则不及。过与不及,所以为至为损焉。
Explanation
Those who can integrate and apply these principles in practice may be called superior physicians; such physicians cure nine out of ten cases. Those who apply two of these principles are middle physicians, curing eight out of ten cases. Those who apply only one are inferior physicians, curing six out of ten cases. [This connects with the earlier statement that color, pulse, form, and flesh must not be inconsistent.]
Each of the five organs has its own corresponding sound, color, odor, and taste, and these should correspond to the pulse at the cun kou and chi ne. When they do not correspond, illness is present. For example, if the color is green and the pulse is floating, thready, and short, or large and slow, this indicates a condition of mutual overcoming; if the pulse is floating, large, and scattered, or small and slippery, this indicates a condition of mutual generation. [As Hua Shou said: "If" here means "sometimes" or "in some cases." Taking the color green as an example, this clarifies the concepts of mutual overcoming and mutual generation. Green is the color of the liver; a floating, thready, and short pulse is the pulse of the lung, indicating that metal overcomes wood; a large and slow pulse is the pulse of the spleen, indicating that wood overcomes earth, which is mutual overcoming. A floating, large, and scattered pulse is the pulse of the heart, indicating that wood generates fire; a small and slippery pulse is the pulse of the kidney, indicating that water generates wood, which is mutual generation. Therefore, when a pulse of mutual overcoming is found, death follows; when a pulse of mutual generation is found, the illness resolves on its own.]
The classics state: those who know only one aspect are inferior physicians; those who know two are middle physicians; those who know three are superior physicians. Superior physicians cure nine out of ten cases; middle physicians cure eight out of ten cases; inferior physicians cure six out of ten cases—this is what is meant. [As Hua Shou said: this was explained earlier. Here, "three" refers to the three aspects of color, pulse, and skin.]
[This passage consists of five sections: the first is the question; the second and third sections discuss how color, pulse, form, and flesh must not be inconsistent; the fourth section explains that each of the five organs has its own sound, color, odor, and taste, which should correspond to the pulse at the cun and chi positions. However, from the phrase "for example," onward, only color and pulse are discussed, and not sound, odor, or taste—was this a missing passage? Or is it because the visible signs, such as color, are more directly relevant to diagnosis? The fifth section then discusses how the level of a physician is determined by how many diagnostic aspects they understand.]
The Fourteenth Difficulty says: What are the "damaged" and "full" pulses? The answer is: A "full" pulse that appears twice per breath is considered normal; one that appears three times is called "departing from the norm"; four times is called "essence being depleted"; five times is called "death"; six times is called "life extinguished"—these are the characteristics of a "full" pulse. What is a "damaged" pulse? A pulse that appears once per breath is called "departing from the norm"; once every two breaths is called "essence being depleted"; once every three breaths is called "death"; once every four breaths is called "life extinguished"—these are the characteristics of a "damaged" pulse. A "full" pulse increases from below upward, while a "damaged" pulse decreases from above downward. [As Hua Shou said: in a normal person, the pulse appears twice per breath during inhalation and twice per breath during exhalation, totaling four beats per full breath. When this number increases, it is considered excessive; when it decreases, it is considered insufficient. Excess and insufficiency are thus the basis for distinguishing between "full" and "damaged" pulses.]
离经者,离其经常之度也。夺精,精气衰夺也。至脉从下而逆上,由肾而之肺也;损脉从上而行下,由肺而之肾也。】 【谢氏曰:平人一呼再至,脉行三寸,今一呼三至,则脉行四寸半,一息之间行九寸,二十息之间行一百八十丈,比平人行速过六十丈,此至脉之离经也。平人一呼脉再至,行三寸,今一呼一至只得一寸半,二十息之间脉迟行六十丈,此损脉之离经也。若夫至脉之夺精,一呼四至,则一息之间行一尺二寸,损脉之夺精,二呼一至,则一息之间行三寸,其病又甚矣。过此者,死而命绝也。】
损脉之为病奈何?然。一损损于皮毛,皮聚而毛落;二损损于血脉,血脉虚少不能荣于五脏六腑;三损损于肌肉,肌肉消瘦,饮食不能为肌肤;四损损于筋,筋缓不能自收持;五损损于骨,骨痿不能起于床。反此者至于收病也。从上下者,骨痿不能起于床者死;从下上者,皮聚而毛落者死。 【滑寿曰:至于收病也,当作至脉之病也,于收二字误。肺主皮毛,心主血脉,脾主肌肉,肝主筋,肾主骨,各以所主而见其所损也,反此为至脉之病者,损脉从上下,至脉则从下上也。】
治损之法奈何?然。损其肺者益其气;损其心者调其荣卫;损其脾者调其饮食,适其寒温;损其肝者缓其中;损其肾者益其精。此治损之法也。 【滑寿曰:肺主气,心主血脉,肾主精,各以其所损而调治之。荣卫者,血脉之所资也。脾主受谷味,故损其脾者调其饮食,适其寒温。如春夏食凉食冷,秋冬食温食热,及衣服起居各当其时是也。
Explanation
To deviate from the norm is to go beyond the usual measure. To deplete the essence is to drain the vital essence and qi. The excessive pulse rises upward against its usual direction, moving from the kidney to the lung; the deficient pulse descends downward, moving from the lung to the kidney.
Xie said: In a healthy person, with each breath, the pulse beats twice and moves three cun. Now, if the pulse beats three times per breath, it moves four and a half cun, traveling nine cun in one breath, and one hundred and eighty zhang in twenty breaths, which is sixty zhang faster than in a healthy person—this is the excessive pulse deviating from the norm. In a healthy person, with each breath the pulse beats twice, moving three cun. Now, if it beats only once per breath, it moves only one and a half cun, traveling sixty zhang in twenty breaths—this is the deficient pulse deviating from the norm. As for the excessive pulse depleting the essence, if it beats four times per breath, it moves twelve cun in one breath; for the deficient pulse depleting the essence, if it beats once every two breaths, it moves three cun in one breath—the condition is even more severe. Beyond this, death occurs and life is extinguished.
What is the condition caused by the deficient pulse? It is as follows. The first stage of damage affects the skin and hair, causing the skin to tighten and the hair to fall out; the second stage affects the blood vessels, where the blood is deficient and cannot nourish the five zang and six fu organs; the third stage affects the muscles, causing them to atrophy and the body to be unable to transform food into muscle; the fourth stage affects the tendons, making them loose and unable to hold the body in place; the fifth stage affects the bones, causing bone atrophy and the inability to rise from the bed. The opposite of this leads to the condition known as "shou bing." Those whose pulse moves from above to below, who cannot rise from the bed due to bone atrophy, will die; those whose pulse moves from below to above, who have tightened skin and falling hair, will also die.
Hua Shou said: As for "shou bing," it should be "the condition of the excessive pulse," with the two characters "shou" being an error. The lung governs the skin and hair, the heart governs the blood vessels, the spleen governs the muscles, the liver governs the tendons, and the kidney governs the bones. Each organ, according to what it governs, shows the damage it sustains. The opposite of this is the condition of the excessive pulse: the deficient pulse moves from above to below, while the excessive pulse moves from below to above.
What is the method for treating deficiency? It is as follows. If the lung is damaged, strengthen its qi; if the heart is damaged, regulate its nutritive and defensive qi; if the spleen is damaged, regulate the diet and adjust to cold and heat; if the liver is damaged, ease its function; if the kidney is damaged, replenish its essence. This is the method for treating deficiency.
Hua Shou said: The lung governs qi, the heart governs the blood vessels, and the kidney governs essence. Each is treated according to the damage it sustains. The nutritive and defensive qi are the basis of the blood vessels. The spleen receives the essence of food, so if the spleen is damaged, regulate the diet and adjust to cold and heat. For example, in spring and summer, eat cool and cold foods; in autumn and winter, eat warm and hot foods. Clothing and daily activities should also be adjusted according to the season.
肝主血,血虚则中不足,一云肝主怒,怒能伤肝,故损其肝者缓其中。经曰肝苦急,急食甘以缓之,缓者,和也。】
脉有一呼再至,一吸再至;有一呼三至,一吸三至;有一呼四至,一吸四至;有一呼五至,一吸五至;有一呼六至,一吸六至;有一呼一至,一吸一至;有再呼一至,再吸一至;有呼吸再至。脉来如此,何以别知其病也? 【滑寿曰:此再举损至之脉为问答也。盖前之损、至,以五脏自病得之于内者而言,此则与经络血气为邪所中之微甚自外得之者而言也。其曰呼吸再至,即一呼一至一吸一至之谓,疑衍文也。】
然。脉来一呼再至,一吸再至,不大不小,曰平。一呼三至,一吸三至,为适得病。前大后小,即头痛,目眩;前小后大,即胸满短气。一呼四至,一吸四至,病欲甚。脉洪大者苦烦满,沉细者腹中痛,滑者伤热,濇者中雾露。一呼五至,一吸五至,其人当困,沉细夜加,浮大昼加。不大不小,虽困可治。其有小大者为难治。一呼六至,一吸六至,为死脉也,沉细夜死,浮大昼死。一呼一至,一吸一至,名曰损,人虽能行,犹当着床。所以然者,血气皆不足故也。再呼一至,再吸一至,呼吸再至【此四字即前衍文】 ,名曰无魂,无魂者,当死也。人虽能行,名曰行尸。 【滑寿曰:一息四至,是为平脉。一呼三至,一吸三至,是一息之间脉六至,比之平人多二至,故曰适得病,未甚也。然又以前大后小,前小后大而言病能也。前后非言寸尺,犹十五难前曲后居之前后,以始末言也。
Explanation
The liver governs blood; when blood is deficient, the middle (i.e., the spleen and digestive system) is also insufficient. It is also said that the liver governs anger, and that anger can injure the liver. Therefore, those who injure the liver should regulate the middle. The Classic says: "The liver dislikes urgency; when it is urgent, one should eat sweet to relieve it." To relieve is to harmonize.
The pulse may have one beat for each breath in, and one beat for each breath out; or one beat for each breath in, and two beats for each breath out; or one beat for each breath in, and three beats for each breath out; or one beat for each breath in, and four beats for each breath out; or one beat for each breath in, and five beats for each breath out; or one beat for each breath in, and six beats for each breath out; or one beat for two breaths in, and one beat for two breaths out; or two beats for one breath in and out. When the pulse comes like this, how can one distinguish the illness?
[Commentary by Hua Shou: This is a second instance of raising the question of "loss" and "arrival" pulses in a question-and-answer format. Previously, the terms "loss" and "arrival" referred to conditions arising from internal disease of the five organs; here, they refer to the mild or severe effects of external pathogenic influences on meridians, blood, and qi. The phrase "two breaths in and two beats," i.e., "one beat for each breath in and out," is likely a textual addition.]
Indeed. When the pulse comes one beat for each breath in and one beat for each breath out, and is neither too large nor too small, it is called "balanced." When it comes three beats for each breath in and three beats for each breath out, it indicates that the person has just contracted a disease. If the pulse is strong at the beginning and weak at the end, it indicates headache and dizziness; if it is weak at the beginning and strong at the end, it indicates chest fullness and shortness of breath. When it comes four beats for each breath in and four beats for each breath out, the illness is about to become severe. A pulse that is full and large indicates discomfort and fullness; a deep and fine pulse indicates abdominal pain; a slippery pulse indicates heat injury; a rough pulse indicates exposure to dampness or moisture.
When the pulse comes five beats for each breath in and five beats for each breath out, the person will feel exhausted. A deep and fine pulse increases at night; a floating and large pulse increases during the day. If the pulse is neither too large nor too small, even when exhausted, it can still be treated. However, if the pulse is abnormally large or small, it is difficult to treat.
When the pulse comes six beats for each breath in and six beats for each breath out, it is called a "death pulse." A deep and fine pulse indicates death at night; a floating and large pulse indicates death during the day. When the pulse comes one beat for each breath in and one beat for each breath out, it is called "loss." Although the person can still walk, they should remain in bed. This is because both blood and qi are insufficient. When the pulse comes one beat for two breaths in and one beat for two breaths out, or two beats for one breath in and out, it is called "no soul." One with "no soul" will die. Although the person may still be able to walk, they are called a "walking corpse."
[Commentary by Hua Shou: A pulse of four beats per breath is considered balanced. A pulse of three beats per breath in and three beats per breath out is six beats per breath cycle, which is two beats more than the balanced pulse, hence it is said to indicate that the person has just contracted a disease, though it is not yet severe. However, the terms "strong at the beginning and weak at the end" and "weak at the beginning and strong at the end" refer to the condition of the pulse, not the cun or chi positions, as in the fifteenth difficulty of the Nan Jing ("Classic of Difficult Issues"), where "before" and "after" refer to the beginning and end of the pulse cycle.]
一呼四至,一吸四至,病欲甚矣。故脉洪大者苦烦满,病在高也。沉细者腹中痛,病在下也。各以其脉言之,滑为伤热者,热伤气而不伤血,血自有余,故脉滑也。濇为中雾露者,雾露之寒伤人荣血,血受寒,故脉濇也。一呼五至,一吸五至,其人困矣。若脉更见浮大沉细,则各随昼夜而加剧,以浮大顺昼阳也,沉细顺夜阴也。若不见二者之脉,人虽困犹可治。小大即沉细浮大也。一呼六至,一吸六至,增之极也,故为死脉。沉细夜死,浮大昼死,阴遇阴阳遇阳也,一呼一至,一吸一至,名曰损,以血气皆不足也。再呼一至,再吸一至,谓两息之间脉再动,减之极也,故曰形气有余,脉气不足者死,故曰无魂而当死也。】
上部有脉,下部无脉,其人当吐,不吐者死。上部无脉,下部有脉,虽困无能为害。所以然者,譬如人之有尺,树之有根,枝叶虽枯槁,根本将自生。脉有根本,人有元气,故知不死。 【滑寿曰:譬如二字,当在人之有尺下,此又以脉之有无明上下部之病也。 纪氏曰:上部有脉,下部无脉,是邪实并于上,即当吐也;若无吐证,为上无邪而下气竭,故云当死。】 【东垣李氏曰:下部无脉,此木郁也。饮食过饱,填塞于胸中太阴之分,而春阳之令不得上行故也,是为木郁。木郁则达之,谓吐之是也。】 【谢氏曰:上部无脉,下部有脉者,阴气盛而阳气微,故虽困无能为害。上部无脉,如树枝之槁;下部有脉,如树之有根。惟其有根,可以望其生也。】 【四明陈氏曰:至,进也,阳独盛而至数多也;
Explanation
During one inhalation, the pulse beats four times; during one exhalation, the pulse beats four times—this indicates that the disease is about to become severe. Thus, a pulse that is full and large causes the patient to suffer from fullness and distension, indicating the disease is located in the upper part of the body. A deep and fine pulse causes abdominal pain, indicating the disease is located in the lower part of the body. Each condition can be discussed in terms of its pulse: a slippery pulse indicates injury from heat, for heat injures the qi but not the blood; the blood remains in excess, hence the pulse becomes slippery. A tight pulse indicates exposure to mist and dew, for the cold of mist and dew injures the nutritive blood; when the blood is affected by cold, the pulse becomes tight. During one inhalation, the pulse beats five times; during one exhalation, the pulse beats five times—the person is greatly weakened. If the pulse also shows floating and large or deep and fine characteristics, then each condition worsens according to day or night, for floating and large pulses correspond to the yang of the day, and deep and fine pulses correspond to the yin of the night. If neither of these two pulse conditions is present, the person may still be treated even though they are weak. "Small" and "large" refer to the same as "deep and fine" and "floating and large." During one inhalation, the pulse beats six times; during one exhalation, the pulse beats six times—this is the extreme of excess, hence it is a death pulse. A deep and fine pulse leads to death at night; a floating and large pulse leads to death during the day. This is when yin meets yin and yang meets yang. During one inhalation, the pulse beats once; during one exhalation, the pulse beats once—this is called "loss," for both blood and qi are insufficient. During two inhalations, the pulse beats once; during two exhalations, the pulse beats once—this means that in the span of two breaths, the pulse only beats twice, which is the extreme of deficiency. Therefore, it is said that when the body's qi is abundant but the pulse qi is deficient, death occurs; hence, it is said that the person is devoid of spirit and should die.
If there is a pulse in the upper part but none in the lower part, the person should vomit; if they do not vomit, they will die. If there is no pulse in the upper part but a pulse in the lower part, even though the person is weak, they cannot be harmed. This is because, like a person having the "chi" (measure) of the foot, a tree having roots, although the branches and leaves may wither, the root will naturally regenerate. The pulse has its root, and the person has their primordial qi; thus, we know they will not die.
[Guo Shou said: The words "like" should be placed after "a person has the chi of the foot," for this is another way to clarify the illness of the upper and lower parts by the presence or absence of the pulse.]
[Ji said: If there is a pulse in the upper part but none in the lower part, it indicates that the pathogenic factors are concentrated in the upper part, so vomiting is necessary. If there is no evidence of vomiting, it means there is no pathogenic factor in the upper part but the qi in the lower part has been exhausted; hence, it is said that death is inevitable.]
[Li Dongyuan said: If there is no pulse in the lower part, this is a case of wood stagnation. Excessive food intake fills the chest area in the yin of the spleen, preventing the spring yang energy from ascending, hence it is called wood stagnation. When wood is stagnant, it should be relieved—this refers to vomiting.]
[Xie said: If there is no pulse in the upper part but a pulse in the lower part, it indicates that yin is strong and yang is weak, so even though the person is weak, they cannot be harmed. The absence of a pulse in the upper part is like withered branches; the presence of a pulse in the lower part is like a tree having roots. Because there is a root, there is hope for life.]
[Chen of Siming said: "To" means "to advance," indicating that yang is strong and the number of beats is frequent.
损,减也,阴独盛而至数少也。至脉从下上,谓无阴而阳独行,至于上则阳亦绝而死矣;损脉从上下,谓无阳而阴独行,至于下则阴亦尽而死矣。】 【一难言寸口以决脏腑死生吉凶,谓气口为五脏主也。四难言脾受谷味,其脉在中,是五脏皆以胃为主,其脉则主关上也。此难言人之有尺,譬如树之有根,脉有根本,人有元气,故知不死,则以尺为主也。此越人所以错综其义,散见诸篇,以见寸关尺各有所归重云。】
十五难曰:经言春脉弦,夏脉钩,秋脉毛,冬脉石,是王脉耶?将病脉也?然。弦、钩、毛、石者,四时之脉也。春脉弦者,肝东方木也,万物始生,未有枝叶,故其脉之来濡弱而长,故曰弦。夏脉钩者,心南方火也,万物之所茂,垂枝布叶,皆下曲如钩,故其脉之来疾去迟,故曰钩。秋脉毛者,肺西方金也,万物之所终,草木华叶,皆秋而落,其枝独在,若毫毛也,故其脉之来轻虚以浮,故曰毛。冬脉石者,肾北方水也,万物之所藏也,盛冬之时,水凝如石,故其脉之来沉濡而滑,故曰石。此四时之脉也。 【滑寿曰:此《内经》平人气象、玉机真脏论参错其文而为篇也。春脉弦者,肝主筋,应筋之象。夏脉钩者,心主血脉,应血脉来去之象。秋脉毛者,肺主皮毛。冬脉石者,肾主骨。各应其象,兼以时物之象取义也。来疾去迟,刘立之曰:来者自骨肉之分而出于皮肤之际,气之升而上也;去者自皮肤之际而还于骨肉之分,气之降而下也。】
如有变奈何?
【滑寿曰:脉逆四时之谓变。】
Explanation
Loss, meaning reduction, occurs when yin alone is excessive and the pulse frequency is low. When the pulse rises from below to above, it signifies the absence of yin and the sole movement of yang; when yang reaches the upper part, it also ceases and death ensues. When the pulse descends from above to below, it signifies the absence of yang and the sole movement of yin; when yin reaches the lower part, it is also exhausted and death ensues. The first difficulty discusses the use of the cun Kou pulse to determine the life or death, fortune or misfortune of the internal organs, stating that the qi Kou is the master of the five organs. The fourth difficulty states that the spleen receives the essence of grain, and its pulse is located in the middle; thus, the five organs all depend on the stomach, and its pulse is mainly located at the guan position. This difficulty explains that the presence of the shen pulse in a person is like the root of a tree; the pulse has a root, and a person has yuan qi, so if the shen pulse is present, one knows that death will not occur, and the shen pulse is therefore the main focus. This is how Yue Ren interwove these meanings, scattering them across various chapters to show that the cun, guan, and shen pulse positions each have their own emphasis.
The fifteenth difficulty says: The classics state that the spring pulse is taut, the summer pulse is hook-like, the autumn pulse is fine, and the winter pulse is stone-like. Are these the dominant pulses of the seasons or the pulses of disease? Yes. The taut, hook-like, fine, and stone-like pulses are the four seasonal pulses. The spring pulse is taut because the liver corresponds to the East and the element wood; all things begin to grow, and no branches or leaves have yet appeared, so the pulse comes in a soft, weak, and long manner, hence it is called taut. The summer pulse is hook-like because the heart corresponds to the South and the element fire; all things flourish, their branches hang and leaves spread, all bending downward like hooks, so the pulse comes quickly and goes slowly, hence it is called hook-like. The autumn pulse is fine because the lung corresponds to the West and the element metal; all things come to an end, and the flowers and leaves of grass and trees fall in autumn, leaving only the branches, which are like fine hairs, so the pulse is light, hollow, and floating, hence it is called fine. The winter pulse is stone-like because the kidney corresponds to the North and the element water; it is the place where all things are stored, and in the depth of winter, water solidifies like stone, so the pulse comes deep, moist, and slippery, hence it is called stone-like. These are the four seasonal pulses.
[Shua Shou said: This passage is composed by interweaving the texts from the Ping Ren Qi Xiang and Yu Ji Zhen Zhang Lun chapters of the Nei Jing. The taut spring pulse corresponds to the liver, which governs tendons, reflecting the nature of tendons. The hook-like summer pulse corresponds to the heart, which governs the blood vessels, reflecting the movement of blood. The fine autumn pulse corresponds to the lung, which governs the skin and hair. The stone-like winter pulse corresponds to the kidney, which governs the bones. Each pulse corresponds to its respective organ, and also draws meaning from the imagery of seasonal things. The coming quickly and going slowly, Liu Li Zhi said: the pulse comes from the junction of bone and flesh to the skin, representing the rising of qi upward; it returns from the skin back to the junction of bone and flesh, representing the descending of qi downward.]
What if there is a change?
[Shua Shou said: A pulse that contradicts the four seasons is called a change.]
然。春脉弦,反者为病。何谓反?然。其气来实强,是为太过,病在外;气来虚微,是为不及,病在内。气来厌厌聂聂,如循榆叶,曰平;益实而滑,如循长竿,曰病;急而劲益强,如新张弓弦,曰死。春脉微弦曰平,弦多胃气少曰病,但弦无胃气曰死,春以胃气为本。夏脉钩,反者为病。何谓反?然。其气来实强,是谓太过,病在外;气来虚微,是谓不及,病在内。其脉来累累如环,如循琅玕,曰平;来而益数,如鸡举足者曰病;前曲后居,如操带钩曰死。夏脉微钩曰平,钩多胃气少曰病;但钩无胃气曰死,夏以胃气为本。秋脉毛,反者为病。何谓反?然。其气来实强,是谓太过,病在外;气来虚微,是谓不及,病在内。其脉来蔼蔼如车盖,按之益大,曰平;不上不下,如循鸡羽,曰病;按之萧索,如风吹毛,曰死。秋脉微毛曰平,毛多胃气少曰病,但毛无胃气曰死,秋以胃气为本。冬脉石,反者为病。何谓反?然。其气来实强,是谓太过,病在外;气来虚微,是谓不及,病在内。脉来上大下兑,濡滑如雀之啄,曰平;啄啄连属,其中微曲,曰病;来如解索,去如弹石,曰死。冬脉微石曰平,石多胃气少曰病,但石无胃气曰死,冬以胃气为本。 【滑寿曰:春脉太过,则令人善忘,忽忽眩冒巅疾;不及,则令人胸痛引背下则两胁胠满。夏脉太过,则令人身热而肤痛,为浸淫;不及,则令人烦心上见咳唾,下为气泄。秋脉太过,则令人逆气而背痛,愠愠然不及,则令人喘,呼吸少气而咳,上气见血,下闻病音。
Explanation
Yes. In spring, the pulse is taut (string-like). If it is the opposite, it indicates disease. What is meant by "the opposite"? Yes. If the pulse comes strong and solid, this is termed "excess," and the disease resides on the exterior; if the pulse comes weak and faint, this is termed "deficiency," and the disease resides on the interior. If the pulse comes soft and subtle, like tracing an elm leaf, it is considered normal; if it becomes even more solid and slippery, like tracing a long bamboo pole, it is considered diseased; if it is urgent and forceful, even stronger, like a newly stretched bowstring, it is considered death. A spring pulse slightly taut is normal; a taut pulse with little stomach qi is diseased; a taut pulse without stomach qi is death. In spring, stomach qi is the foundation.
In summer, the pulse is hooked. If it is the opposite, it indicates disease. What is meant by "the opposite"? Yes. If the pulse comes strong and solid, this is termed "excess," and the disease resides on the exterior; if the pulse comes weak and faint, this is termed "deficiency," and the disease resides on the interior. If the pulse comes continuously like a ring, like tracing a precious stone, it is considered normal; if it comes more rapidly, like a chicken lifting its foot, it is considered diseased; if it bends forward and then settles backward, like holding a belt hook, it is considered death. A summer pulse slightly hooked is normal; a hooked pulse with little stomach qi is diseased; a hooked pulse without stomach qi is death. In summer, stomach qi is the foundation.
In autumn, the pulse is feather-like. If it is the opposite, it indicates disease. What is meant by "the opposite"? Yes. If the pulse comes strong and solid, this is termed "excess," and the disease resides on the exterior; if the pulse comes weak and faint, this is termed "deficiency," and the disease resides on the interior. If the pulse comes soft and expansive, like a carriage canopy, and becomes even larger when pressed, it is considered normal; if it neither rises nor falls, like tracing a chicken's feather, it is considered diseased; if it becomes sparse and thin when pressed, like the wind blowing over hair, it is considered death. An autumn pulse slightly feather-like is normal; a feather-like pulse with little stomach qi is diseased; a feather-like pulse without stomach qi is death. In autumn, stomach qi is the foundation.
In winter, the pulse is stone-like. If it is the opposite, it indicates disease. What is meant by "the opposite"? Yes. If the pulse comes strong and solid, this is termed "excess," and the disease resides on the exterior; if the pulse comes weak and faint, this is termed "deficiency," and the disease resides on the interior. If the pulse comes large at the top and pointed at the bottom, soft and slippery like a sparrow pecking, it is considered normal; if it pecks continuously, with a slight curve in the middle, it is considered diseased; if it comes like a rope being untied and goes away like a stone being struck, it is considered death. A winter pulse slightly stone-like is normal; a stone-like pulse with little stomach qi is diseased; a stone-like pulse without stomach qi is death. In winter, stomach qi is the foundation.
[滑寿 said: If the spring pulse is excessive, it causes forgetfulness, dizziness, and head diseases; if it is deficient, it causes chest pain radiating to the back, with fullness in the flanks. If the summer pulse is excessive, it causes body heat and skin pain, leading to spreading eruptions; if it is deficient, it causes restlessness in the heart, coughing and spitting above, and gas leakage below. If the autumn pulse is excessive, it causes upward qi reversal and back pain, with a feeling of oppression; if it is deficient, it causes shortness of breath, coughing, blood in the upper airway, and audible illness in the lower body.]
冬脉太过,则令人解(亻亦),脊脉痛而少气不欲言;不及则令人心悬如饥,(月少)中清脊中痛,少腹满,小便变。此岐伯之言也。越人之意,盖本诸此。变脉言气者,脉不自动,气使之然,且主胃气而言也。春脉厌厌聂聂,如循榆叶,弦而和也;益实而滑,如循长竿,弦多也;急而劲益强,如新张弓弦,但弦也。夏脉累累如环,如循琅玕,钩而和也;如鸡举足,钩多而有力也;前曲后居,谓按之坚而搏,寻之实而居,但钩也。秋脉蔼蔼如车盖,按之益大,微毛也;不上不下,如循鸡羽,毛多也;按之萧索,如风吹毛,但毛也。冬脉上大下兑,大小适均,石而和也,上下与来去同义,见前篇;啄啄连属,其中微曲,石多也;来如解索,去如弹石,但石也。大抵四时之脉,皆以胃气为本,故有胃气则生,胃气少则病,无胃气则死。于弦、钩、毛、石中,每有和缓之体为胃气也。此篇与《内经》中互有异同。】 【冯氏曰:越人欲使脉之易晓,重立其义尔。按《内经》第五卷平人气象论篇云:平肝脉来软弱,招招如揭长竿末梢。平肺脉来厌厌聂聂,如落榆荚。平肾脉来,喘喘累累,如钩,按之而坚,病肾脉来如引葛之益坚,死肾脉如发夺索,辟辟如弹石,此为异也。】
胃者水谷之海,主禀四时,皆以胃气为本,是谓四时之变病,死生之要会也。 【滑寿曰:胃属土,土之数五也,万物归之,故云水谷之海。而水、火、金、木,无不待是以生,故云主禀四时。禀,供也,给也。】
脾者,中州也,其平和不可得见,衰乃见耳。
Explanation
If the winter pulse is excessive, it causes a person to feel limp and weak, with pain along the spine, shortness of breath, and a reluctance to speak; if it is insufficient, it causes the heart to feel suspended as if hungry, with clear pain in the region of the navel and spine, fullness in the lower abdomen, and changes in urination. This is what Qi Bo said. Yueren's meaning is based upon this. When discussing the changing pulse in terms of Qi, the pulse does not move on its own, but is caused by Qi, and it primarily refers to the stomach Qi.
The spring pulse is soft and gentle, like tracing a willow leaf, and is stringy yet harmonious; when it becomes more full and smooth, it is like tracing a long pole, with more stringiness; when it becomes tense and strong, it is like the string of a newly drawn bow, but it is only stringy.
The summer pulse is like a series of rings, like tracing a precious stone, and is hook-shaped yet harmonious; when it rises suddenly, it is like a chicken lifting its foot, with more hooking and force; when pressed, it is bent forward and firm behind, meaning it feels solid and stable when pressed, and it is only hook-shaped.
The autumn pulse is like a carriage canopy, and when pressed, it becomes even larger, with a slightly feathery quality; it neither rises nor falls, like tracing a chicken's feather, with more feathery qualities; when pressed, it becomes sparse and thin, like wind blowing through feathers, but it is only feathery.
The winter pulse is large at the top and sharp at the bottom, with a balanced size, and is stony yet harmonious; the top and bottom are synonymous with the coming and going, as explained in the previous chapter; it is ticking and connected, with a slight curve in the middle, with more stoniness; it comes like a loosening rope and goes like a stone being struck, but it is only stony.
Generally speaking, the pulses of the four seasons are all based on the stomach Qi. Therefore, if there is stomach Qi, life is sustained; if stomach Qi is weak, illness occurs; if there is no stomach Qi, death results. Among the stringy, hook-shaped, feathery, and stony pulses, each has a harmonious and gentle quality, which is the stomach Qi. This passage differs from and agrees with the Neijing in some respects.
[Feng said:] Yueren wished to make the pulse easier to understand, so he reestablished its meaning. According to the fifth volume of the Neijing, the chapter on the "Meteorological Patterns of the Healthy Person," the healthy liver pulse comes soft and weak, like lifting the end of a long pole. The healthy lung pulse comes soft and gentle, like a falling榆 leaf. The healthy kidney pulse comes with a wheezing and continuous quality, like a hook, and is firm when pressed; the diseased kidney pulse comes like pulling a vine and becomes even firmer; the pulse of a dying person is like a rope being pulled apart, with a sharp, stone-like quality, which is the difference.
The stomach is the sea of water and grain, and it governs the four seasons, all based on the stomach Qi. This is why changes in the four seasons' diseases are the critical point between life and death.
[Shua Shou said:] The stomach belongs to earth, and the number of earth is five; all things return to it, hence it is called the sea of water and grain. Water, fire, metal, and wood all depend on it to be born, hence it is said to govern the four seasons. "Bing" means to supply and provide.
The spleen is the central region of the body; its state of harmony cannot be seen until it declines.
来如雀之啄,如水之下漏,是脾衰见也。 【滑寿曰:脾者中州,谓呼吸之间,脾受谷味,其脉在中也,其平和不得见。盖脾寄王于四时,不得独主于四时,四脏之脉平和,则脾脉在中矣。衰乃见者,雀啄屋漏,异乎常也。雀啄者,脉至坚锐而断续不定也,屋漏者,脉至缓散动而复止也。】
十六难曰:脉有三部九候,有阴阳,有轻重,有六十首,一脉变为四时,离圣久远,各自是其法,何以别之? 【谢氏曰:此篇问三部九候以下共六件,而本经并不答所问,似有阙文。今详三部九候,则十八难中第三章言之,当属此篇错简在彼。阴阳见四难;轻重见五难;一脉变为四时,即十五难春弦、夏钩、秋毛、冬石也。六十首,按《内经》方盛衰篇曰:圣人持诊之道,先后阴阳而持之,奇恒之势,乃六十首。王注谓奇恒六十首,今世不存,则失其传者由来远矣。】
然。是其病,有内外证。
【滑寿曰:此盖答辞,与前问不相蒙,当别有问辞也。】
其病为之奈何?
【滑寿曰:问内外证之详也。】
Explanation
The pulse comes like a sparrow pecking, like water dripping through a hole—this is a sign of spleen deficiency.
【Hua Shou said: The spleen is the central region of the body; during the interval of breathing, the spleen receives the essence of food, and its pulse resides in the center. In a state of balance, it is not seen. The spleen is associated with the four seasons, but it does not exclusively govern them. When the pulses of the four organs are balanced, the spleen's pulse is present in the center. When it becomes visible, it is because of the abnormal patterns of sparrow pecking and house leakage. The sparrow pecking pattern is one in which the pulse arrives firm and sharp but is irregular and intermittent; the house leakage pattern is one in which the pulse arrives slow, diffused, and then stops.】
The Sixteenth Difficulty says: The pulse has three sections and nine points, has yin and yang, has light and heavy, has sixty patterns. A single pulse can change according to the four seasons. Having been separated from the teachings of the sages for a long time, each school has developed its own method—how can one distinguish them?
【Xie said: This section raises six questions beginning with the three sections and nine points, yet the original text does not answer them, suggesting a missing passage. Upon examination, the three sections and nine points are discussed in the third chapter of the Eighteenth Difficulty, which likely belongs to this section and was misplaced there. The concept of yin and yang is found in the Fourth Difficulty; the concept of light and heavy is found in the Fifth Difficulty; the idea that a single pulse changes with the four seasons corresponds to the Fifteenth Difficulty, which describes the spring-string, summer-hook, autumn-feather, and winter-stone pulse patterns. As for the sixty patterns, according to the Neijing, Fang Sheng Shuai chapter: The sage’s method of diagnosis involves handling yin and yang in sequence, and the sixty patterns of odd and constant conditions are thus established. Wang’s commentary refers to these sixty odd and constant patterns, which are no longer extant today; thus, the loss of this tradition has been long in coming.】
Indeed. This disease has both internal and external symptoms.
【Hua Shou said: This is likely a response, yet it does not correspond to the preceding question—there must be a separate question that precedes it.】
What can be done about this disease?
【Hua Shou said: This is a question asking for a detailed explanation of internal and external symptoms.】
然。假令得肝脉,其外证,善洁,面青,善怒;其内证,脐左有动气,按之牢若痛;其病四肢满闭,淋溲便难,转筋。有是者肝也,无是者非也。 【滑寿曰:得肝脉,诊得弦脉也。肝与胆合为清净之腑,故善洁。肝为将军之官,故善怒。喜,犹善、好也。面青肝之色也,此外证之色脉情好也。脐左,肝之部也,按之牢者,若谓其动气按之坚牢而不移或痛也。冯氏曰:肝气(月真)郁,则四肢满闭。《左传》曰:风淫末疾是也。厥阴脉循阴器,肝病故溲便难。转筋者,肝主筋也。此内证之部属及所主病也。】
假令得心脉,其外证,面赤,口干,喜笑;其内证,脐上有动气,按之牢若痛;其病烦心,心痛,掌中热而啘。有是者心也,无是者非也。 【滑寿曰:掌中,手心主脉所过之处。盖真心不受邪,受邪者手心主尔。啘,干呕也。心病则火盛,故啘。经曰:诸逆冲上,皆属于火;诸呕吐酸,皆属于热。】
假令得脾脉,其外证,面黄,善噫,善思,善味;其内证,当脐有动气,按之牢若痛;其病腹胀满食不消,体重节痛,怠惰嗜卧,四肢不收。有是者脾也,无是者非也。 【滑寿曰:《灵枢》口问篇云,噫者寒气客于胃,厥逆从下上散,复出于胃,故为噫。经曰:脾主四肢。】
假令得肺脉,其外证,面白,善嚏,悲愁不乐欲哭;其内证,脐右有动气,按之牢若痛;其病喘咳,洒淅寒热。有是者肺也,无是者非也。 【滑寿曰:岐伯云:阳气和利满于心,出于鼻,故为嚏。洒淅寒热,肺主皮毛也。】
Explanation
Yes. Suppose one has the liver pulse, the external symptoms include a tendency for cleanliness, a blueish complexion, and a tendency to anger; the internal symptoms include a palpable movement on the left side of the navel, which feels firm or painful upon palpation; the disease manifests as swelling or blockage in the limbs, difficulty in urination and defecation, and cramping of the sinews. If these symptoms are present, it is the liver; if not, it is not. 【Hua Shou said: To have the liver pulse is to detect a taut pulse. The liver and gallbladder together form the "pure and clear" organs, hence a tendency for cleanliness. The liver is called the "general's office," hence a tendency to anger. "Happy" here means "good" or "inclined to." A blue complexion is the color of the liver, this is the color, pulse, and disposition of the external symptoms. The left side of the navel is the region of the liver; when pressed, if it feels firm and unyielding or painful, this is what is meant. Feng said: When liver qi is stagnant, then the limbs become swollen or blocked. The Zuo Zhuan says: "Wind excess affects the extremities," this is the case. The jueyin meridian runs along the genitalia; hence, when the liver is diseased, urination and defecation become difficult. Cramping of the sinews occurs because the liver governs the sinews. These are the internal symptoms and the diseases they signify.】
Suppose one has the heart pulse, the external symptoms include a red complexion, dry mouth, and a tendency to laugh; the internal symptoms include a palpable movement above the navel, which feels firm or painful upon palpation; the disease manifests as a troubled mind, heart pain, heat in the palm, and dry vomiting. If these symptoms are present, it is the heart; if not, it is not. 【Hua Shou said: The palm is the location where the hand-yangming meridian passes. The true heart does not receive pathogenic factors; the one that does is the hand-yangming. "Dry vomiting" refers to retching. When the heart is diseased, fire becomes excessive, hence dry vomiting. The classics say: "All upward rebellious conditions belong to fire; all vomiting with sour regurgitation belong to heat."】
Suppose one has the spleen pulse, the external symptoms include a yellow complexion, a tendency to belch, a tendency to think, and a tendency to savor flavors; the internal symptoms include a palpable movement at the navel, which feels firm or painful upon palpation; the disease manifests as abdominal distension, indigestion, heaviness in the body and joint pain, laziness and excessive sleeping, and an inability to control the limbs. If these symptoms are present, it is the spleen; if not, it is not. 【Hua Shou said: The Lingshu says in the "Questioning the Mouth" chapter: "Belching occurs when cold pathogenic factors dwell in the stomach, causing reverse flow from below to above, and then returning to the stomach, hence belching." The classics say: "The spleen governs the four limbs."】
Suppose one has the lung pulse, the external symptoms include a pale complexion, a tendency to sneeze, sadness, unhappiness, and a desire to weep; the internal symptoms include a palpable movement on the right side of the navel, which feels firm or painful upon palpation; the disease manifests as wheezing, coughing, chills, and fever. If these symptoms are present, it is the lung; if not, it is not. 【Hua Shou said: Qi Bo said: "When yang qi is smooth and full, it fills the heart and exits through the nose, hence a sneeze." Chills and fever occur because the lungs govern the skin and hair.】
假令得肾脉,其外证,面黑,善恐欠;其内证,脐下有动气,按之牢若痛;其病逆气,小腹急痛,泄如下重,足胫寒而逆。有是者肾也,无是者非也。 【如,读作而。】 【滑寿曰:肾气不足则为恐,阴阳相引则为欠。泄而下重,少阴泄也。】
十七难曰:经言病或有死,或有不治自愈,或连年月不已。其死生存亡,可切脉而知之耶?然。可尽知也。 【滑寿曰:此篇所问者三,答云可尽知也而止,答病之死证,余无所见,当有阙漏。】
诊病若闭目不欲见人者,脉当得肝脉,强急而长,而反得肺脉浮短而濇者,死也。 【滑寿曰:肝开窍于目,闭目不欲见人,肝病也。肝病见肺脉,金克木也。】
病若开目而渴,心下牢者,脉当得紧实而数,反得沉濇而微者,死也。 【滑寿曰:病实而脉虚也。】
Explanation
If one obtains the kidney pulse, the external symptoms include a dark complexion, a tendency to fear and yawn; the internal symptoms include a moving qi below the navel, which feels firm and painful upon palpation. The condition manifests as upward rushing qi, acute pain in the lower abdomen, diarrhea with a sensation of heaviness, and coldness in the shins with upward flow. If these symptoms are present, it is a kidney condition; if not, it is not. 【As noted, the character “如” is to be read as “而” in this context.】 【Hua Shou said: Kidney qi deficiency leads to fear; the interaction of yin and yang leads to yawning. Diarrhea with a sensation of heaviness is a case of deficiency in the Shaoyin.】
The Seventeenth Difficulty says: The classics state that some diseases are fatal, some heal without treatment, and some persist for years without resolution. Can one determine whether a patient will live or die through pulse diagnosis? Yes. It is possible to know all of this completely. 【Hua Shou said: This passage raises three questions, and the response is that one can know all of this completely. However, the response only addresses the signs of death, and the rest is not mentioned, indicating that there may be omissions.】
In diagnosing a patient who closes their eyes and does not wish to see people, the pulse should be strong, tense, and long (indicative of the liver pulse), but if instead a floating, short, and dry pulse (indicative of the lung) is found, the patient will die. 【Hua Shou said: The liver opens to the eyes; closing the eyes and not wanting to see people indicates liver disease. The presence of a lung pulse in liver disease is an example of metal overcoming wood.】
In diagnosing a patient who opens their eyes and is thirsty, with a firm sensation in the chest, the pulse should be tense, solid, and rapid, but if instead a deep, dry, and weak pulse is found, the patient will die. 【Hua Shou said: The disease is real, but the pulse is weak.】
病若吐血复鼽衂血者,脉当沉细,而反浮大而牢者,死也。 【滑寿曰:脱血脉实,相反也。】
Explanation
A patient who coughs up blood and experiences repeated nosebleeds should have a deep and fine pulse; if instead the pulse is floating, large, and firm, death will follow.
【Hua Shou said: Deficient blood with a strong pulse—this is contradictory.】
病若谵言妄语,身当有热,脉当洪大,而反手足厥逆,脉沉细而微者,死也。 【滑寿曰:阳病见阴脉,相反也。】
病若大腹而泄者,脉当微细而濇,反紧大而滑者,死也。 【滑寿曰:泄而脉大,相反也。大腹,腹胀也。】
十八难曰:脉有三部,部有四经。手有太阴阳明,足有太阳少阴,为上下部,何谓也? 【滑寿曰:此篇立问之意,谓人十二经脉凡有三部,每部之中有四经,今手有太阴阳明,足有太阳少阴,为上下部,何也?盖三部者,以寸、关、尺分上、中、下也;四经者,寸、关、尺,两两相比,则每部各有四经矣。手之太阴阳明,足之太阳少阴,为上下部者,肺居右寸,肾居左尺,循环相资,肺高肾下,母子之相望也。经云脏真高于肺,脏真下于肾是也。】
然。手太阴阳明金也,足少阴太阳水也,金生水,水流下行而不能上,故在下部也。足厥阴少阳木也,生手太阳少阴火,火炎上行而不能下,故为上部。手心主少阳火,生足太阴阳明土,土主中宫,故在中部也。此皆五行子母更相生养者也。 【滑寿曰:手太阴阳明金,下生足太阳少阴水,水性下,故居下部。足少阴太阳水,生足厥阴少阳木,木生手少阴太阳火及手心主火,火炎上行,是为上部。火生足太阴阳明土,土居中部,复生肺金,此五行子母更相生养者也。此盖因手太阴阳明、足太阳少阴为上下部,道推广五行相生之大,越人亦以五脏生成之后,其部分之高下而推言之,非谓未生之前必待如是而后生成也。
Explanation
If a disease presents with delirious speech and incoherent talk, the body should be hot, and the pulse should be full and large; yet if instead the hands and feet are cold and the pulse is deep, fine, and weak, this is a sign of death. 【Hua Shou said: A yang disease presenting with a yin pulse is contradictory.】
If a disease presents with abdominal distension and diarrhea, the pulse should be fine, weak, and涩 (rough or sticky); yet if instead it is tight, large, and slippery, this is a sign of death. 【Hua Shou said: Diarrhea with a large pulse is contradictory. Da Fu refers to abdominal distension.】
The Eighteenth Difficulty says: The pulse has three sections, and each section has four meridians. The hands have Taiyin and Yangming, the feet have Taiyang and Shaoyin, which are called the upper and lower sections—what does this mean? 【Hua Shou said: The purpose of this passage is to raise a question: the twelve meridians are divided into three sections, and each section contains four meridians. Now, the hands have Taiyin and Yangming, and the feet have Taiyang and Shaoyin, which are called the upper and lower sections—why is this so? The three sections are divided according to the cun, guan, and chi positions, which represent upper, middle, and lower. The four meridians refer to the cun, guan, and chi positions, each paired with another, so each section contains four meridians. The hands’ Taiyin and Yangming, and the feet’s Taiyang and Shaoyin, are called upper and lower sections because the lung is located at the right cun, and the kidney is located at the left chi. They support each other cyclically; the lung is high, the kidney is low, like mother and child facing each other. As the classics say, the true essence of the zang organs is higher than the lung and lower than the kidney.】
Indeed. The hand Taiyin and Yangming belong to the element Metal, and the foot Shaoyin and Taiyang belong to the element Water. Metal generates Water, and Water flows downward and cannot ascend, hence it resides in the lower section. The foot Jueyin and Shaoyang belong to the element Wood, which generates the fire of the hand Taiyang and Shaoyin. Fire ascends and cannot descend, hence it belongs to the upper section. The fire of the hand Jueyin (Heart-Pericardium) and Shaoyang generates the earth of the foot Taiyin and Yangming, and earth governs the central palace, hence it resides in the middle section. These are all examples of the mutual generation of the Five Elements’ parent and child. 【Hua Shou said: The hand Taiyin and Yangming (Metal) generate the foot Taiyang and Shaoyin (Water), and since Water flows downward, it resides in the lower section. The foot Shaoyin and Taiyang (Water) generate the foot Jueyin and Shaoyang (Wood), which in turn generates the fire of the hand Shaoyin and Taiyang, as well as the fire of the hand Jueyin. Fire ascends, hence it belongs to the upper section. Fire generates the earth of the foot Taiyin and Yangming, which resides in the middle section and in turn generates the Metal of the lung. This is the mutual generation of the Five Elements’ parent and child. This explanation arises from the fact that the hand Taiyin and Yangming and the foot Taiyang and Shaoyin are designated as the upper and lower sections, and it expands upon the great principle of the Five Elements’ mutual generation. Hua Tuo also discussed the high and low positions of the five zang organs after their formation, not implying that they must be in this order before being generated.】
而又演为三部之说,即四难所谓心肺俱浮,肾肝俱沉,脾者中州之意。但彼直以脏言,此以经言而脏腑兼之。以上问答明经,此下二节俱不相蒙,疑他经错简。】
脉有三部九候,各何主之?然。三部者,寸关尺也。九候者,浮中沉也。上部法天,主胸以上至头之有疾也;中部法人,主鬲以下至脐之有疾也;下部法地,主脐以下至足之有疾也,审而刺之者也。 【谢氏曰:此一节当是十六难中答辞,错简在此,而剩出脉有三部九候各何主之十字。审而刺之,纪氏曰:欲诊脉动而中病,不可不审,故曰审而刺之。刺者言其动而中也。陈万年传曰:刺候谓中其候与此义同,或曰:刺,针刺也,谓审其部而针刺之。】
人病有沉滞久积聚,可切脉而知之耶? 【滑寿曰:此下问答亦未详所属,或曰当是十七难中,或连年月不已答辞。】
然。诊在右胁有积气,得肺脉结脉,结甚则积甚;结微则气微。 【滑寿曰:结为积聚之脉,肺脉见结,知右胁有积气。右胁,肺部也。积气有微甚,脉从而应之。】
诊不得肺脉而右胁有积气者,何也?然,肺脉虽不见,右手脉当沉伏。 【滑寿曰:肺脉虽不见结,右手脉当见沉伏,沉伏亦积聚脉,右手所以候里也。】
其外痼疾同法耶?将异也?
【滑寿曰:此复问外之痼疾,与内之积聚法将同异。】
然。结者,脉来去时一止无常数,名曰结也;伏者脉行筋下也;浮者脉在肉上行也。左右表里,法皆如此。 【滑寿曰:结为积聚。伏脉行筋下,主里;浮脉行肉上,主表。所以异也。
Explanation
Further elaborated into the theory of the three parts, as stated in the Fourth Difficulty: the heart and lungs both present a floating pulse, the kidneys and liver both present a deep pulse, and the spleen corresponds to the middle region. However, that text refers only to the zang (viscera), whereas this refers to the meridians and includes both zang and fu (hollow organs). The above question and answer clarify the meridians, but the next two sections are disjointed and do not follow logically, suggesting they may be misplaced from another section.
What are the three parts and nine pulses, and what do they each govern? The three parts are cun (inch), guan (gate), and chi (foot). The nine pulses are the superficial, middle, and deep pulses. The upper part corresponds to heaven and governs diseases above the chest up to the head; the middle part corresponds to human beings and governs diseases from the diaphragm down to the navel; the lower part corresponds to earth and governs diseases below the navel down to the feet. This is the method of examining and then needling accordingly.
【Xie said: This section should belong to the Sixteenth Difficulty, but it has been misplaced here, with the phrase “What are the three parts and nine pulses, and what do they each govern?” left over. As for “examine and then needling,” Ji said: To diagnose the pulse and strike the disease, one must be thorough, hence the saying “examine and then needling.” The term “needling” here refers to striking the disease in motion. The Biography of Chen Wannian says: “Needling the pulse” means striking the condition in accordance with the pulse, which is the same meaning. Some say: “Needling” refers to acupuncture, meaning to examine the region and then needle it.】
Can one determine from pulse diagnosis whether a person has long-standing stagnation or accumulation?
【Hua Shou said: The following question and answer are not clearly attributable to any particular section, though some say they belong to the Seventeenth Difficulty, or are part of a response about time and duration.】
Yes. If a patient has accumulation in the right hypochondriac region and presents a lung pulse with a jie (tight) pulse, then the more pronounced the jie pulse, the more severe the accumulation; the milder the jie pulse, the milder the condition.
【Hua Shou said: A jie pulse is characteristic of accumulation. When the lung pulse shows a jie pattern, it indicates there is accumulation in the right hypochondriac region. The right hypochondriac region corresponds to the lung. The severity of the accumulation is reflected in the pulse.】
If a patient has accumulation in the right hypochondriac region but does not show a lung pulse, why is this so? The lung pulse may not be visible, but the right hand pulse should be deep and concealed.
【Hua Shou said: Although the lung pulse does not show a jie pattern, the right hand pulse should show a deep and concealed pulse. A deep and concealed pulse is also characteristic of accumulation, and the right hand pulse is used to examine the interior.】
Are the diagnostic methods for external chronic diseases the same as for internal accumulation, or are they different?
【Hua Shou said: This is a further question asking whether the diagnostic method for external chronic diseases is the same as for internal accumulation.】
Yes. A jie pulse is one in which the pulse stops irregularly during its coming and going, and is called jie. A fu pulse runs beneath the tendons, and a fu pulse runs on the surface of the flesh. Whether on the left or right, the method for exterior and interior is the same.
【Hua Shou said: Jie is associated with accumulation. A fu pulse runs beneath the tendons and is associated with the interior; a fu pulse that runs on the surface of the flesh is associated with the exterior. This is why they are different.】
前举右胁为例,故此云左右同法。】
假令脉结伏者,内无积聚;脉浮结者,外无痼疾。有积聚,脉不结伏;有痼疾,脉不浮结:为脉不应病、病不应脉,是为死病也。 【滑寿曰:有是脉,无是病,有是病,无是脉,脉病不相应,故为死病也。】
十九难曰:经言脉有逆顺,男女有恒而反者,何谓也? 【滑寿曰:恒者,经常也。脉有逆顺,据男女相比而言也。男脉在关上,女脉在关下,男子尺脉恒弱,女子尺脉恒盛,此男女之脉有别也。逆顺云者,男之顺,女之逆也,女之顺,男不同也。虽然,在男女则各有常矣。反,谓反其常也。】
然。男子生于寅,寅为木,阳也;女子生于申,申为金,阴也。故男脉在关上,女脉在关下。是以男子尺脉恒弱,女子尺脉恒盛,是其常也。 【滑寿曰:此推本生物之初而言男女阴阳也。纪氏曰:生物之初,其本原皆始于子,子者万物之所以始也。自子推之,男左旋三十而至于巳,女右旋二十而至于巳,是男女婚嫁之数也。自巳而怀娠,男左旋十月而生于寅,寅为木阳也;女右旋十月而生于申,申为金阴也。谢氏曰:寅为木,木生火,又火生于寅而性炎上,故男脉在关上。申为金,金生水,又水生于申而性流下,故女脉在关下。愚谓阳之体轻清而升,天道也,故男脉在关上;阴之体重浊而降,地道也,故女脉在关下。此男女之常也。】
反者男得女脉,女得男脉也。
【滑寿曰:男女异常,是之谓反。】
其为病何如?
【滑寿曰:问反之为病也。】
Explanation
Taking the right side as an example, this is why it is said that the left and right are treated in the same manner.
If the pulse is constricted and deeply buried, there is no internal accumulation; if the pulse is floating and constricted, there is no external chronic disease. When there is internal accumulation, the pulse is not constricted and deeply buried; when there is a chronic disease, the pulse is not floating and constricted: this is when the pulse does not correspond to the disease, and the disease does not correspond to the pulse—this is called a fatal condition.
[Commentary by Hua Shou: When there is this pulse but no such disease, or when there is this disease but no such pulse, the pulse and disease do not correspond, hence it is called a fatal condition.]
The Nineteenth Difficulty says: The classics state that pulses have inverse and correct directions. When men and women are contrary to their usual patterns, what does this mean?
[Commentary by Hua Shou: "Constant" refers to the regular or customary state. The terms "inverse" and "correct" refer to pulse patterns in comparison between men and women. The male pulse is located above the guan position, while the female pulse is located below the guan position. The chi pulse in men is usually weak, while the chi pulse in women is usually strong—this shows that the male and female pulses differ. When we speak of "inverse" and "correct," it means that for men, the correct pulse is above the guan, while for women, the inverse is considered correct. Although this is the case, men and women each have their own regularities. "Contrary" refers to being contrary to these regularities.]
Indeed. Men are born in the year of Yin, which corresponds to the Wood element and is yang in nature; women are born in the year of Shen, which corresponds to the Metal element and is yin in nature. Therefore, the male pulse is located above the guan position, while the female pulse is located below the guan position. Thus, the chi pulse in men is always weak, while the chi pulse in women is always strong—this is the natural state.
[Commentary by Hua Shou: This passage traces the origin of life to explain the yin-yang distinctions between men and women. Ji says: At the beginning of life, all things originate from the Zi position, for Zi is the starting point of all things. From Zi, men rotate leftward thirty times to reach Si, and women rotate rightward twenty times to reach Si—this is the number for marriage and betrothal. From Si, pregnancy begins. Men rotate leftward for ten months and are born in the year of Yin, which is Wood and yang; women rotate rightward for ten months and are born in the year of Shen, which is Metal and yin. Xie says: Yin is Wood, which generates Fire, and Fire also originates in Yin with an upward, fiery nature, hence the male pulse is above the guan. Shen is Metal, which generates Water, and Water also originates in Shen with a downward, flowing nature, hence the female pulse is below the guan. I say that yang, being light and clear, rises—this is the way of heaven, hence the male pulse is above the guan; yin, being heavy and turbid, descends—this is the way of earth, hence the female pulse is below the guan. This is the natural state of men and women.]
The reverse condition is when a man has a female pulse and a woman has a male pulse.
[Commentary by Hua Shou: When men and women exhibit abnormal patterns, this is called "reverse."]
What kind of illness does this lead to?
[Commentary by Hua Shou: This is asking about the illness caused by the reverse condition.]
然。男得女脉为不足,病在内,左得之,病在左,右得之,病在右,随脉言之也。女得男脉为太过,病在四肢,左得之,病在左,右得之,病在右,随脉言之,此之谓也。 【滑寿曰:其反常,故太过不及,在内在外之病见焉。】
二十难曰:经言脉有伏匿,伏匿于何脏而言伏匿邪?然。谓阴阳更相乘更相伏也。脉居阴部而反阳脉见者,为阳乘阴也;脉虽时沉濇而短,此谓阳中伏阴也。脉居阳部而反阴脉见者,为阴乘阳也;脉虽时浮滑而长,此谓阴中伏阳也。 【滑寿曰:居,犹在也,当也。阴部尺,阳部寸也。乘犹乘车之乘,出于其上也。伏犹伏兵之伏隐于其中也。匿,藏也,丁氏曰:此非特言寸为阳,尺为阴,以上下言,则肌肉之上为阳部,肌肉之下为阴部,亦通。】
重阳者狂,重阴者癫。脱阳者见鬼,脱阴者目盲。 【滑寿曰:此五十九难之文,错简在此。】
二十一难曰:经言人形病脉不病曰生,脉病形不病曰死,何谓也?然。人形病脉不病,非有不病者也,谓息数不应脉数也,此大法。 【周仲立曰:形体之中觉见憔悴,精神昏愦,食不忺美,而脉得四时之从,无过不及之偏,是人病脉不病也。形体安和而脉息乍大乍小,或至或损,弦紧浮滑,沉濇不一,残贼冲和之气,是皆脉息不与形相应,乃脉病人不病也。仲景云:人病脉不病,名曰内虚,以无谷气,神虽困无苦。脉病人不病,名曰行尸,以无王气,卒眩仆不识人,短命则死。】 【谢氏曰:按本经答文词意不属,似有脱悞。】
Explanation
Yes. When a man has a female pulse, it indicates deficiency, and the disease is internal; if the left hand has it, the disease is on the left; if the right hand has it, the disease is on the right—this is determined by the pulse. When a woman has a male pulse, it indicates excess, and the disease is in the limbs; if the left hand has it, the disease is on the left; if the right hand has it, the disease is on the right—this is what is meant. 【Hua Shou said: Because it is abnormal, it is either excess or deficiency, and the diseases within and without become evident.】
The 20th difficulty says: The classics state that there are hidden pulses. In which organ are these hidden pulses found, and what is meant by "hidden"? Yes. This refers to Yin and Yang alternately overpowering and concealing each other. When the pulse is in the Yin position but a Yang pulse is seen, this is Yang overpowering Yin; although the pulse is sometimes deep,涩, and short, this is called Yin hidden within Yang. When the pulse is in the Yang position but a Yin pulse is seen, this is Yin overpowering Yang; although the pulse is sometimes floating, slippery, and long, this is called Yang hidden within Yin. 【Hua Shou said: "居" means "to be in" or "to be situated." The Yin portion is the Chi, the Yang portion is the Cun. "乘" is like riding in a carriage, emerging above. "伏" is like hidden troops concealing themselves within. "匿" means to conceal. Ding said: This is not only referring to Cun as Yang and Chi as Yin, but if we speak of it in terms of upper and lower, then the area above the muscles is the Yang portion, and the area below the muscles is the Yin portion, which is also acceptable.】
Excessive Yang leads to mania; excessive Yin leads to madness. Deficiency of Yang causes one to see ghosts; deficiency of Yin causes blindness. 【Hua Shou said: This passage from the 59th difficulty is misplaced here.】
The 21st difficulty says: The classics state that when the body is ill but the pulse is not, it is a sign of life; when the pulse is ill but the body is not, it is a sign of death. What does this mean? Yes. When the body is ill but the pulse is not, it is not that the pulse is not ill, but rather that the breath rate does not correspond to the pulse rate—this is the fundamental principle. 【Zhou Zhongli said: When one feels weary and emaciated, mentally confused, and has no appetite, yet the pulse follows the four seasons without excess or deficiency, this is the case of the body being ill but the pulse not being ill. When the body is in good condition but the pulse is irregular, fluctuating between large and small, or varying in strength, with wiry, tense, floating, slippery, deep, and涩 pulses that are inconsistent, this damages the harmonious qi, and these are all cases where the pulse does not correspond to the body, meaning the pulse is ill while the body is not. Zhang Zhongjing said: When the body is ill but the pulse is not, it is called internal deficiency, due to the absence of grain qi, and although the spirit is weary, there is no suffering. When the pulse is ill but the body is not, it is called a "walking corpse," due to the absence of royal qi, and one suddenly collapses, loses consciousness, and dies prematurely.】
【Xie said: According to the original text, the answer does not align with the question, and seems to have an omission or error.】
二十二难曰:经言脉有是动、有所生病,一脉变为二病者,何也?然。经言是动者气也;所生病者血也。邪在气,气为是动;邪在血,血为所生病。气主呴之,血主濡之。气留而不行者,为气先病也;血壅而不濡者,为血后病也。故先为是动、后所生也。 【滑寿曰:呴,煦也,气主呴之,谓人之真气呴嘘往来,熏蒸于皮肤分肉间也。血主濡之,谓人之血脉濡润筋骨,滑利关节,荣养脏腑者也。此脉字非尺寸之脉,乃十二经隧之脉也。此谓十二经隧之脉,每脉中辄有二病者,盖以有在气在血之分也。邪在气,气为是而动;邪在血,血为所生病。气留而不行为气病,血壅而不濡为血病,故先为是动后所生病也。先后云者,抑气在外,血在内,外先受邪则内亦从之而病欤?然邪亦有只在气,亦有径在血者,又不可以先后拘也。经者,《灵枢》第十篇也。】
二十三难曰:手足三阴三阳,脉之度数,可晓以不?然。手三阳之脉,从手至头长五尺,五六合三丈;手三阴之脉,从手至胸中长三尺五寸,三六一丈八尺,五六三尺,合二丈一尺;足三阳之脉,从足至头长八尺,六八四丈八尺;足三阴之脉,从足至胸长六尺五寸,六六三丈六尺,五六三尺,合三丈九尺;人两足蹺脉从足至目长七尺五寸,二七一丈四尺,二五一尺,合一丈五尺;督脉任脉各长四尺五寸,二四八尺,二五一尺,合九尺。凡脉长一十六丈二尺,此所谓十二经脉长短之数也。 【滑寿曰:此《灵枢》二十七篇全文。三阴三阳,《灵枢》皆作六阴六阳,义尤明白。
Explanation
Twenty-Second Difficulty: The classics say that a pulse has shidong (is moving) and suo sheng bing (diseases that arise from it). How can one pulse become two diseases? Indeed. The classics say that shidong refers to qi, and suo sheng bing refers to blood. When the pathogen is in the qi, the qi is what is moving; when the pathogen is in the blood, the blood is what causes the disease. Qi mainly warms, and blood mainly moistens. When qi stagnates and does not circulate, it is the first to become diseased; when blood stagnates and does not moisten, it is the later stage of the disease. Hence, it first manifests as shidong, then as suo sheng bing.
[Shua Shou said: Xu means to warm, and qi mainly warms, meaning the true qi of the human body warms and circulates,熏蒸 (steaming and nourishing) the skin and intermuscular spaces. Blood mainly moistens, meaning the blood vessels moisten the bones and tendons, lubricate the joints, and nourish the internal organs. This term pulse does not refer to the pulse at the cun and chi positions, but rather to the twelve meridians. This refers to the twelve meridians, each of which has two diseases, because there is a distinction between the qi and the blood. When the pathogen is in the qi, the qi is what moves; when the pathogen is in the blood, the blood is what causes the disease. When qi stagnates and does not circulate, it is a disease of the qi; when blood stagnates and does not moisten, it is a disease of the blood. Hence, it first manifests as shidong, then as suo sheng bing. The terms before and after refer to the fact that qi is external and blood is internal—when the external first receives the pathogen, the internal also follows and becomes diseased. However, the pathogen may also only affect the qi, or may directly affect the blood; thus, one should not be bound by the idea of before and after. The term Jing refers to the tenth chapter of the Ling Shu.]
Twenty-Third Difficulty: Concerning the hands and feet' three yin and three yang meridians, what are the measurements of the pulse? Indeed. The pulse of the three yang meridians of the hand runs from the hand to the head and is five chi long; five times six is thirty chi, or three zhang. The pulse of the three yin meridians of the hand runs from the hand to the chest and is three chi five cun long; three times six is eighteen chi, and five times six is thirty chi, totaling two zhang one chi. The pulse of the three yang meridians of the foot runs from the foot to the head and is eight chi long; six times eight is forty-eight chi, or four zhang eight chi. The pulse of the three yin meridians of the foot runs from the foot to the chest and is six chi five cun long; six times six is thirty-six chi, and five times six is thirty chi, totaling three zhang nine chi. The two qiao meridians of the human body run from the foot to the eyes and are seven chi five cun long; two times seven is fourteen chi, and two times five is ten chi, totaling one zhang five chi. The du mai and ren mai each measure four chi five cun; two times four is eight chi, and two times five is ten chi, totaling nine chi. Altogether, the length of all the pulses is sixteen zhang two chi, which is the total measure of the lengths of the twelve meridians.
[Shua Shou said: This is the full text of the twenty-seventh chapter of the Ling Shu. In the Ling Shu, the terms three yin and three yang are all rendered as six yin and six yang, which makes the meaning even clearer.]
按经脉之流注,则手之三阳从手走至头,手之三阴从腹走至手,足之三阳从头下走至足,足之三阴从足上走入腹。此举经脉之度数,故皆自手足言。人两足蹺脉指阴蹺也,阴蹺脉起于跟中,自然骨之后,上内踝之上直上,循阴股入阴,循腹上胸里,行缺盆,出人迎之前,入頄内廉属目内眦,合太阳脉为足少阴之别络也。足三阳之脉,从足至头长八尺,《考工记》亦云人身长八尺,盖以同身尺寸言之。】
经脉十二,络脉十五,何始何穷也?然。经脉者,行血气,通阴阳,以荣于身者也。其始从中焦注手太阴阳明,阳明注足阳明太阴,太阴注手少阴太阳,太阳注足太阳少阴,少阴注手心主少阳,少阳注足少阳厥阴,厥阴复还注手太阴。别络十五,皆因其原。如环无端,转相灌溉,朝于寸口人迎,以处百病而决死生也。 【滑寿曰:因者,随也。原者,始也。朝犹朝会之朝以用也。因上文经脉之尺度,而推言经络之行度也。直行者谓之经,旁出者谓之络。十二经有十二络,兼阳络、阴络,脾之大络,为十五络也。谢氏曰:始从中焦者,盖谓饮食入口藏于胃,其精微之化注手太阴阳明,以次相传至足厥阴,厥阴复还注手太阴也。络脉十五,皆随十二经脉之所始,转相灌溉,如环之无端,朝于寸口人迎,以之处百病而决死生也。寸口人迎,古法以侠喉两旁动脉为人迎,至晋 王叔和直以左手关前一分为人迎,右手关前一分为气口,后世宗之。
Explanation
According to the flow of the meridians, the three Yang meridians of the hand run from the hands to the head, while the three Yin meridians of the hand run from the abdomen to the hands. The three Yang meridians of the foot run downward from the head to the feet, and the three Yin meridians of the foot run upward from the feet into the abdomen. This discussion concerns the measurements of the meridians, hence the reference begins with the hands and feet. The two qiao meridians of the feet refer to the yin qiao meridian. The yin qiao meridian originates at the heel, behind the natural bone, ascends above the inner malleolus straight upward, follows the inner thigh into the genital region, continues along the abdomen upward into the chest, passes through the quepen, emerges before the renying, enters the inner side of the cheek, and connects to the inner corner of the eye, joining the Taiyang meridian to become a collateral of the Zu Shaoyin (kidney) meridian. The three Yang meridians of the foot, running from the feet to the head, measure eight chi in length. The Kaogong Ji also states that the human body is eight chi in length, referring to standard body measurements.
There are twelve main meridians and fifteen collaterals—where do they begin and where do they end? Indeed, the meridians carry blood and qi, connect yin and yang, and nourish the body. They begin in the middle jiao, flowing into the Shou Taiyin (lung) and Yangming (large intestine) meridians; the Yangming flows into the Zu Yangming (stomach) and Taiyin (spleen) meridians; the Taiyin flows into the Shou Shaoyin (heart) and Taiyang (small intestine) meridians; the Taiyang flows into the Zu Taiyang (bladder) and Shaoyin (kidney) meridians; the Shaoyin flows into the Shou Xinshu (pericardium) and Shaoyang (triple burner) meridians; the Shaoyang flows into the Zu Shaoyang (gallbladder) and Jueyin (liver) meridians; the Jueyin then returns to flow into the Shou Taiyin (lung). The fifteen collateral meridians all follow their original starting points, circulating and nourishing each other like a ring with no beginning or end, converging at the cunkou and renying to diagnose diseases and determine life and death.
[Shua Shou said: "因" means "to follow," and "原" means "origin." "朝" is like the "assembly" in a court meeting, used in the context of convergence. This is based on the measurements of the meridians discussed above, and it extends to the circulation of the meridians and collaterals. Straight pathways are called jing, and those that branch off are called luo. The twelve jing have twelve luo, including the yang and yin luo, and the large luo of the spleen, totaling fifteen luo. Xie said: "Beginning in the middle jiao" refers to the transformation of food essence in the stomach, which then flows into the Shou Taiyin and Yangming meridians, passing successively until reaching the Zu Jueyin (liver) meridian, which then returns to flow into the Shou Taiyin (lung) meridian. The fifteen collaterals all follow the starting points of the twelve meridians, circulating and nourishing each other like a ring with no beginning or end, converging at the cunkou and renying to diagnose diseases and determine life and death. The cunkou and renying—according to ancient methods, the renying was the artery on both sides of the throat. By the time of Jin dynasty’s Wang Shuhe, the renying was directly defined as the first cun before the guan on the left hand, and the cunkou as the first cun before the guan on the right hand, a method followed by later generations.]
愚谓昔人所以取人迎气口者,盖人迎为足阳明胃经,受谷气而养五脏者也,气口为手太阴肺经,朝百脉而平权衡者也。】
经云:明知终始,阴阳定矣,何谓也?然。终始者,脉之纪也。寸口人迎,阴阳之气通于朝使,如环无端,故曰始也。终者,三阴三阳之脉绝,绝则死,死各有形,故曰终也。 【滑寿曰:按谢氏云,《灵枢经》第九篇曰:凡刺之道,毕于终始。明知终始,五脏为纪,阴阳定矣。又曰:不病者,脉口人迎应四时也;少气者,脉口人迎俱少而不称尺寸也。此一节,因上文寸口人迎处百病决死生而推言之,谓欲晓知终始,于阴阳为能定之。盖以阳经取决于人迎,阴经取决于气口也。朝使者,朝为气血,如水潮应时而灌溉,使谓阴阳相为用也。始如生物之始,终如生物之穷。欲知生死,脉以候之。阴阳之气通于朝使,如环无端,则不病;一或不相朝使,则病矣。况三阴三阳之脉绝乎?绝必死矣。其死之形状,具如下篇,尤宜参看。】
二十四难曰:手足三阴三阳气已绝,何以为候?可知其吉凶不?然。足少阴气绝即骨枯。少阴者冬脉也,伏行而温于骨髓,故骨髓不温,即肉不着骨;骨肉不相亲,即肉濡而却;肉濡而却,故齿长而枯,发无润泽。无润泽者骨先死。戊日笃,己日死。【濡,读为软。】 【滑寿曰:此下六节,与《灵枢》第十篇文皆大同小异。肾其华在发,其充在骨。肾绝则不能充于骨,荣于发。肉濡而却,谓骨肉不相着而肉濡缩也。戊己,土也,土胜水,故以其所胜之日笃而死矣。】
Explanation
I say that the reason ancient physicians chose the renying and qikou pulse points is because renying belongs to the Foot Yangming Stomach Meridian, which receives grain qi and nourishes the five zang organs, while qikou belongs to the Hand Taiyin Lung Meridian, which gathers all the hundred vessels and balances the body’s harmony.
The Classic says: “To know the beginning and end, yin and yang are thus determined. What does this mean?” Yes. The beginning and end refer to the pattern of the pulse. The cunkou and renying allow yin and yang qi to communicate like the morning envoy, flowing in a circle without end, hence called the beginning. The end occurs when the pulses of the three yin and three yang meridians are cut off; when they are cut off, death occurs, and death takes on its own form, hence it is called the end.
[Commentary by Hua Shou: According to Xie, the Ling Shu (Spiritual Pivot), 9th chapter says: “All the principles of needling are completed in the beginning and end.” Knowing the beginning and end, the five zang organs are the foundation, and yin and yang are thus determined. It also says: “In those who are not ill, the pulse at qikou and renying corresponds to the four seasons; in those with weak qi, the pulse at qikou and renying is both weak and does not match the cun and zhi measurements.” This section is an extension of the previous discussion on determining life and death through the cunkou and renying pulse points, explaining that one must understand the beginning and end in order to determine yin and yang. It is because yang meridians are determined by renying, and yin meridians are determined by qikou. The term “morning envoy” refers to the qi and blood, which, like the tide, respond to the time and nourish the body. “Use” refers to the mutual action of yin and yang. The beginning is like the beginning of life, and the end is like the exhaustion of life. To know life and death, the pulse is used to observe it. When yin and yang qi communicate like the morning envoy, flowing in a circle without end, there is no illness; if even one of them fails to communicate, illness occurs. How much more so when the pulses of the three yin and three yang meridians are cut off? When they are cut off, death is certain. The forms of death are fully described in the next chapter, and it is especially advisable to refer to that.
The 24th difficulty says: When the qi of the hand and foot three yin and three yang meridians is cut off, what are the signs? Can we know the auspicious or inauspicious outcome? Yes. When the foot Shaoyin qi is cut off, the bones become dry. The Shaoyin is the winter pulse, running hidden and warming the bone marrow. Therefore, if the bone marrow is not warmed, the flesh does not adhere to the bone; when the bone and flesh are not united, the flesh becomes soft and recedes. When the flesh is soft and recedes, the teeth grow long and become dry, and the hair lacks luster. The lack of luster indicates that the bone dies first. On the day of Wu, the condition worsens; on the day of Ji, death occurs. [“Rú” is read as “ruǎn,” meaning soft.]
[Commentary by Hua Shou: The following six sections are largely the same as the tenth chapter of the Ling Shu. The kidney’s brilliance is in the hair, and its fullness is in the bone. When the kidney is cut off, it cannot nourish the bone or honor the hair. “Soft and receding flesh” refers to the flesh not adhering to the bone and becoming soft and contracted. Wu and Ji are the days of Earth. Earth overcomes Water, hence the condition worsens on the day of Wu and death occurs on the day of Ji.]
足太阴气绝,则脉不营其口唇。口唇者,肌肉之本也。脉不营则肌肉不滑泽,肌肉不滑泽则肉满,肉满则唇反,唇反则肉先死。甲日笃,乙日死。 【滑寿曰:脾其华在唇四白,其充在肌。脾绝则肉满唇反也。肉满,谓肌肉不滑泽而紧急(月真)膹也。】
足厥阴气绝,即筋缩引卵与舌卷。厥阴者,肝脉也。肝者,筋之合也。筋者,聚于阴器而络于舌本。故脉不营则筋缩急,筋缩急即引卵与舌。故舌卷卵缩,此筋先死。庚日笃,辛日死。 【滑寿曰:肝者,脉之合,其华在爪,其充在筋。筋者聚于阴器而络于舌本,肝绝则筋缩引卵与舌也。王充《论衡》云:甲乙病者,生死之期常之庚申。】
手太阴气绝,即皮毛焦。太阴者,肺也,行气温于皮毛者也。气弗营则皮毛焦,皮毛焦则津液去,津液去即皮节伤,皮节伤则皮枯毛折,毛折者则毛先死。丙日笃,丁日死。 【滑寿曰:肺者,气之本,其华在毛,其充在皮。肺绝则皮毛焦而津液去,皮节伤,以诸液皆会于节也。】
手少阴气绝则脉不通,脉不通则血不流,血不流则色泽去,故面色黑如黧,此血先死。壬日笃,癸日死。 【滑寿曰:心之合脉也。其荣色也,其华在面,其充在血脉。心绝则脉不通,血不流,色泽去也。】
三阴气俱绝者则目眩转目瞑,目瞑者为失志,失志者则志先死,死则目瞑也。 【滑寿曰:三阴通手足经而言也。《灵枢》十篇作五阴气俱绝,则以手厥阴与手少阴同心经也。目眩转目瞑者,即所谓脱阴者目盲,此又其甚者也。故云目瞑者失志,而志先死也。
Explanation
When the qi of the Foot Taiyin (Spleen) is severed, the pulse no longer nourishes the lips. The lips are the root of the muscles. When the pulse fails to nourish, the muscles lose their smoothness and luster; when the muscles lose their smoothness and luster, they become swollen and taut; when they become swollen and taut, the lips turn inward; when the lips turn inward, the muscles die first. On the day of Jia, the condition worsens; on the day of Yi, death occurs.
[Shua Shou said: The spleen's brilliance manifests in the four white areas around the lips, and its fullness is in the muscles. When the spleen is severed, the muscles become swollen and the lips turn inward. "Swollen" refers to the muscles becoming dry, tight, and distended.]
When the qi of the Foot Jueyin (Liver) is severed, the tendons contract, pulling the testes and causing the tongue to curl. The Jueyin is the Liver meridian. The Liver is the meeting place of the tendons. The tendons gather in the genital region and connect to the base of the tongue. Therefore, when the pulse fails to nourish, the tendons contract and tighten; when the tendons contract and tighten, they pull the testes and the tongue. Hence, the tongue curls and the testes contract—this is the first sign of death in the tendons. On the day of Geng, the condition worsens; on the day of Xin, death occurs.
[Shua Shou said: The Liver is the meridian of the tendons; its brilliance is in the nails, and its fullness is in the tendons. The tendons gather in the genital region and connect to the base of the tongue. When the Liver is severed, the tendons contract and pull the testes and the tongue. Wang Chong in Lunheng said: For those afflicted with illness on the days of Jia or Yi, the time of death is often on the days of Geng or Shen.]
When the qi of the Hand Taiyin (Lung) is severed, the skin and hair become scorched. The Taiyin is the Lung, which circulates warmth to the skin and hair. When the qi fails to nourish, the skin and hair become scorched; when the skin and hair become scorched, body fluids are lost; when body fluids are lost, the skin joints are injured; when the skin joints are injured, the skin becomes dry and the hair breaks; when the hair breaks, the hair dies first. On the day of Bing, the condition worsens; on the day of Ding, death occurs.
[Shua Shou said: The Lung is the source of qi; its brilliance is in the hair, and its fullness is in the skin. When the Lung is severed, the skin and hair become scorched and body fluids are lost, injuring the skin joints, for all fluids converge at the joints.]
When the qi of the Hand Shaoyin (Heart) is severed, the pulse becomes obstructed. When the pulse is obstructed, the blood does not flow; when the blood does not flow, the complexion loses its luster. Thus, the face becomes black as soot—this is the first sign of death in the blood. On the day of Ren, the condition worsens; on the day of Gui, death occurs.
[Shua Shou said: The Heart is the counterpart of the pulse; its radiance is in the complexion, its brilliance is on the face, and its fullness is in the blood vessels. When the Heart is severed, the pulse becomes obstructed, the blood does not flow, and the complexion loses its luster.]
When the qi of all three Yin meridians is severed, the eyes spin and then close. When the eyes close, it is a sign of loss of will; when will is lost, the spirit dies first; when the spirit dies, the eyes close.
[Shua Shou said: The reference to the three Yin is inclusive of both hand and foot meridians. In the Ling Shu’s tenth chapter, it is written as "five Yin qi severed," because the Hand Jueyin and Hand Shaoyin belong to the same channel. The condition of spinning vision and closed eyes is what is meant by "loss of Yin leads to blindness"—this is an even more severe case. Hence, it is said that when the eyes close, will is lost, and the spirit dies first.]
】 【四明陈氏曰:五脏阴气俱绝,则其志丧于内,故精气不注于目,不见人而死。】
六阳气俱绝者则阴与阳相离,阴阳相离则腠理泄,绝汗乃出,大如贯珠,转出不流,即气先死。旦占夕死,夕占旦死。 【滑寿曰:汗出而不流者,阳绝故也。】 【陈氏曰:六腑阳气俱绝,则气散于外,故津液脱而死。】
二十五难曰:有十二经,五脏六腑十一耳,其一经者何等经也?然,一经者手少阴与心主别脉也。心主与三焦为表里,俱有名而无形,故言经有十二也。 【滑寿曰:此篇问答,谓五脏六腑配手足之阴阳,但十一经耳,其一经者则以手少阴与心主各别为一脉。心主与三焦为表里,俱有名而无形,以此一经并五脏六腑,共十二经也。谢氏曰:《难经》言手少阴心主与三焦凡八篇。 三十一难分豁三焦经脉所始终。三十七难言肾有两,左曰肾,右曰命门,初不以左右肾分两手尺脉。三十八难言三焦者,原气之别,主持诸气,复申言其有名无形。三十九难言命门者,精神之所舍,男子藏精,女子系胞,其气与肾通。又云六腑正有五腑,三焦亦是一腑。八难、六十二、六十六三篇,言肾间动气者,人之生命,十二经之根本也,其名曰原,三焦则原气之别使也。通此篇参互观之,可见三焦列为六腑之义。唯其有名无形,故得与手心主合。心主为手厥阴,其经始于起胸中,终于循小指次指出其端。若手少阴则始于心中,终于循小指之内出其端,此手少阴与心主各别为一脉也。】 【或问手厥阴经曰心主,又曰心包络,何也?
Explanation
】 【Fourming Chen said: When the yin qi of the five zang organs is completely extinguished, the will is lost internally, so the essence and qi do not flow to the eyes, and the person dies without seeing others.】
When all six yang qi are extinguished, yin and yang separate; when yin and yang separate, the pores and skin become loose, and a profuse sweat emerges, large as beads on a string, turning out in discrete drops that do not flow. In this case, the qi dies first. If the condition is diagnosed in the morning, death occurs by evening; if diagnosed in the evening, death occurs by morning. 【Hua Shou said: When sweat emerges but does not flow, it is because yang has been extinguished.】 【Chen said: When the yang qi of the six fu organs is completely extinguished, the qi disperses outward, so the body fluids are lost and death occurs.】
The Twenty-Fifth Difficulty says: There are twelve meridians, but the five zang and six fu make up only eleven. What is the one remaining meridian? The answer is: This one meridian is the separate meridian of the hand shaoyin and the heart master. The heart master and the sanjiao are exterior and interior counterparts, both having names but no physical form, hence it is said that there are twelve meridians. 【Hua Shou said: This passage of question and answer refers to how the five zang and six fu are paired with the yin and yang of the hand and foot meridians. However, there are only eleven meridians in this pairing, and the one remaining meridian is the separate pulse of the hand shaoyin and the heart master. The heart master and the sanjiao are exterior and interior counterparts, both having names but no physical form. Thus, by combining this one meridian with the five zang and six fu, there are twelve meridians in total. Xie said: The Nanjing discusses the hand shaoyin, heart master, and sanjiao in eight chapters. The Thirty-First Difficulty clarifies the beginning and end of the sanjiao meridian. The Thirty-Seventh Difficulty states that the kidney has two parts: the left is called the kidney, and the right is called the life gate (mingmen). Originally, the left and right kidneys are not associated with the left and right hand pulses. The Thirty-Eighth Difficulty says the sanjiao is a branch of the original qi, and it governs all the qi, further explaining that it has a name but no form. The Thirty-Ninth Difficulty says the life gate is the dwelling place of the spirit and mind; in men it stores essence, and in women it connects the womb. Its qi communicates with the kidney. It also states that the six fu actually consist of five fu, with the sanjiao being one of them. The Eighth, Sixty-Second, and Sixty-Sixth Difficulties discuss the moving qi between the kidneys, which is the human life force, the root of the twelve meridians, known as yuan. The sanjiao is the messenger of the original qi. By examining this passage alongside others, one can understand why the sanjiao is included among the six fu. Only because it has a name but no form can it be combined with the hand heart master. The heart master is the hand jueyin meridian, whose meridian begins in the chest and ends at the tip of the second finger of the little finger. If the hand shaoyin meridian begins in the heart and ends at the inner side of the little finger, then the hand shaoyin and heart master are each a separate meridian.】 【Someone asked: The hand jueyin meridian is called the heart master, and also the heart envelope—why is that?】
曰:君火以名,相火以位。手厥阴代君火行事,以用而言,故曰手心主;以经而言,则曰心包络。一经而二名,实相火也。】 【虞庶云:诸家言命门为相火,与三焦相表里。按《难经》止言手心主与三焦为表里,无命门三焦表裹之说。夫左寸火,右寸金,左关木,右关土,左尺水,右尺火,职之部位,其义灼然于乎!如虞氏此说,则手心主与三焦相为表里而摄行君火明矣。三十六难谓命门其气与肾通,则亦不离乎肾也,其习坎之谓欤?手心主为火之闰位,命门则水之同气欤?命门不得为相火,三焦不与命门配亦明矣。虞氏之说,良有旨哉!诸家所以纷纷不决者,盖有惑于金匮真言篇王注引《正理论》谓三焦者,有名无形,上合手心主,下合右肾,遂有命门三焦表里之说。夫人之脏腑,一阴一阳,自有定耦,岂有一经两配之理哉?夫所谓上合手心主者,正言其为表里;下合右肾者,则以三焦为原气之别使而言之尔。知此,则知命门与肾通,三焦无两配,而诸家之言可不辨而自明矣。若夫诊脉部位,则手厥阴相火,居右尺之分,而三焦同之。命门既与肾通,只当居左尺,而谢氏据《脉经》谓手厥阴即手少阴心脉同部,三焦脉上见寸口,中见于关,下焦与肾同也。前既云初不以左右肾分两手足脉矣,今如《脉经》所云,则右尺当何所候耶?】
二十六难曰:经有十二,络有十五,余三络者,是何等络也?然。有阳络,有阴络,有脾之大络。阳络者,阳蹺之络也。阴络者,阴蹺之络也。故络有十五焉。
Explanation
It is said: the emperor fire is named by its designation, while the assistant fire is named by its position. The hand jueyin meridian acts on behalf of the emperor fire; in terms of function, it is called the hand heart master, and in terms of meridian, it is called the pericardium. One meridian with two names, in fact it is the assistant fire.
虞 Shu said: various scholars say that the mingmen is the assistant fire, and is paired with the sanjiao as exterior-interior partners. According to the Nanjing, it only says that the hand jueyin and the sanjiao are exterior-interior partners, and there is no mention of the mingmen and the sanjiao being paired. The left cun is fire, the right cun is metal, the left guan is wood, the right guan is earth, the left chi is water, the right chi is fire. According to their positions, the meaning is clearly evident. If we accept Shu's view, then it is clear that the hand jueyin and the sanjiao are paired as exterior-interior partners and jointly manage the emperor fire. The thirty-sixth difficulty says that the mingmen's qi connects with the kidney, so it is also not separate from the kidney; could this be referring to the repeated encounter with water, as in the hexagram Xik'an? Is the hand jueyin the supplementary position of fire, and the mingmen the same qi as water? If the mingmen is not the assistant fire, then it is clear that the sanjiao does not pair with the mingmen. Shu's view is indeed wise and meaningful! The reason why scholars are divided is because they are confused by the commentary of Wang Shuhe in the Jinkui Zhenyan passage, which quotes the Zhenglun saying that the sanjiao has a name but no form, connects with the hand jueyin above and with the right kidney below, thus giving rise to the idea that the mingmen and the sanjiao are paired as exterior-interior partners. The human internal organs and腑 are each paired with one yin and one yang, and have fixed pairings; how could one meridian have two pairings? What is meant by "connecting with the hand jueyin above" is precisely that it is an exterior-interior pair; as for "connecting with the right kidney below," this is said in reference to the sanjiao as the deputy messenger of the primordial qi. Knowing this, one understands that the mingmen connects with the kidney, and the sanjiao has no second pairing, and thus the views of various scholars can be understood without needing to be debated. As for the positions of pulse diagnosis, the hand jueyin, which is the assistant fire, resides in the right chi section, and the sanjiao shares this position. Since the mingmen connects with the kidney, it should only reside in the left chi. However, Xie, citing the Maijing, says that the hand jueyin is in the same position as the hand shaoyin heart meridian, and that the sanjiao pulse appears in the cun, is seen in the guan, and is associated with the lower jiao and the kidney. Earlier it was said that the left and right kidneys are not used to distinguish between hand and foot pulses; if we follow what is said in the Maijing, then what does the right chi section examine?
The twenty-sixth difficulty says: there are twelve meridians and fifteen collateral vessels; the remaining three collaterals, what kind of collaterals are they? The answer is: there are yang collaterals, yin collaterals, and the great collateral of the spleen. The yang collateral is the collateral of the yang qiao meridian; the yin collateral is the collateral of the yin qiao meridian. Thus, there are fifteen collaterals in total.
【滑寿曰:直行者谓之经,旁出者谓之络。经犹江汉之正流,络则沱潜之支派。每经皆有络,十二经有十二络,如手太阴属肺络大肠,手阳明属大肠络肺之类。今云络有十五者,以其有阳蹺之络、阴蹺之络及脾之大络也。阳蹺,阴蹺,见二十八难。谓之络者,盖奇经既不拘于十二经,直谓之络亦可也。脾之大络,名曰大包,出渊液三寸,布胸胁,其动应衣宗气也。】 【四明陈氏曰:阳蹺之络,统诸阳络;阴蹺之络,统诸阴络;脾之大络,又总统阴阳诸络,犹脾之能溉养五脏也。】
二十七难曰:脉有奇经八脉者,不拘于十二经,何也?然。有阳维,有阴维,有阳蹺,有阴蹺,有冲,有督,有任,有带之脉,凡此八脉者,皆不拘于经,故曰奇经八脉也。 【滑寿曰:脉有奇常。十二经者,常脉也。奇经八脉,则不拘于十二经,故曰奇经。奇对正而言,犹兵家之云奇正也。】 【虞氏曰:奇者奇零之奇,不偶之义,谓此八脉不系正经阴阳,无表里配合,别道奇行,故曰奇经也。此八脉者,督脉督于后,任脉任于前,冲脉为诸阳之海,阴阳维则维络于身,带脉束之如带,阳蹺得之太阳之别,阴蹺本诸少阴之别云。】
经有十二,络有十五,凡二十七气相随上下,何独不拘于经也?然。圣人图设沟渠,通利水道,以备不然。天雨降下,沟渠溢满,当此之时,霶霈妄作,圣人不能复图也。此络脉满溢,诸经不能复拘也。 【滑寿曰:经络之行,有常度矣,奇经八脉则不能相从也,故以圣人图设沟渠为譬。
Explanation
Hua Shou said: Those that run straight are called meridians, and those that branch off are called collaterals. Meridians are like the main currents of the Yangtze and Han rivers, while collaterals are like the tributaries of the Tuo and Qian rivers. Each meridian has its collateral; the twelve meridians have twelve collaterals, such as the Hand Taiyin meridian, which belongs to the lung and connects to the large intestine, and the Hand Yangming meridian, which belongs to the large intestine and connects to the lung. Now it is said that there are fifteen collaterals, because they include the collateral of the Yang Qiao Vessel, the collateral of the Yin Qiao Vessel, and the major collateral of the Spleen. The Yang Qiao and Yin Qiao Vessels are mentioned in the 28th Difficulty. They are called collaterals because the Extraordinary Vessels are not bound to the twelve meridians, and thus can also be called collaterals. The major collateral of the Spleen is named Da Bao, emerging three cun below the Yuanli point, spreading over the chest and flanks, and its movement corresponds to the vital energy that reaches the skin and clothing.
Fourming Chen said: The collateral of the Yang Qiao Vessel governs all yang collaterals; the collateral of the Yin Qiao Vessel governs all yin collaterals; the major collateral of the Spleen governs both the yin and yang collaterals, just as the Spleen is able to nourish the five zang organs.
The 27th Difficulty says: Why do the Eight Extraordinary Vessels not conform to the twelve meridians? The answer is: There is the Yang Wei Vessel, the Yin Wei Vessel, the Yang Qiao Vessel, the Yin Qiao Vessel, the Chong Vessel, the Du Vessel, the Ren Vessel, and the Dai Vessel. All these eight vessels do not conform to the meridians, hence they are called the Eight Extraordinary Vessels.
Hua Shou said: There are both ordinary and extraordinary meridians. The twelve meridians are the ordinary ones. The Eight Extraordinary Vessels are not bound to the twelve meridians, hence they are called extraordinary. The term "extraordinary" is in contrast to the "ordinary," just as in military strategy, there is the concept of "odd" and "even" formations.
Yu said: "Extraordinary" means odd or singular, not even, indicating that these eight vessels are not linked to the yin and yang of the main meridians, have no exterior-interior pairings, and travel along separate, unusual paths, hence they are called the Eight Extraordinary Vessels. These eight vessels are: the Du Vessel oversees the back, the Ren Vessel oversees the front, the Chong Vessel is the sea of all yang, the Yin and Yang Wei Vessels encircle and connect the body, the Dai Vessel binds the body like a belt, the Yang Qiao Vessel originates from the collateral of the Bladder meridian, and the Yin Qiao Vessel originates from the collateral of the Kidney meridian.
There are twelve meridians and fifteen collaterals, a total of twenty-seven qi that move up and down together. Why then are they not bound to the meridians? The answer is: The sage set up ditches and channels to ensure the smooth flow of water, in preparation for unexpected circumstances. When it rains heavily, the ditches overflow, and at such a time, the rain falls in excess and unpredictably, beyond the sage’s ability to plan for. In the same way, when the collateral vessels overflow, the main meridians can no longer contain them.
Hua Shou said: The meridians and collaterals have their regular patterns of movement, but the Eight Extraordinary Vessels do not follow them, hence the analogy is made to the sage setting up ditches and channels.
以见络脉满溢,诸经不能复拘,而为此奇经也。然则奇经盖络脉之满溢而为之者欤?或曰:此络脉三字,越人正指奇经而言也,既不拘于经,直谓之络脉亦可也。】 【此篇两节,举八脉之名及所以为奇经之义。】
二十八难曰:其奇经八脉者,既不拘于十二经,皆何起何继也?然。督脉者,起于下极之俞,并于脊里,上至风府,入属于脑。任脉者,起于中极之下,以上毛际,循腹里,上关元,至咽喉。冲脉者,起于气冲,并足阳明之经,侠脐上行,至胸中而散也。带脉者,起于季胁,回身一周。阳蹺脉者,起于跟中,循外踝上行入风池。阴蹺脉者,亦起于跟中,循内踝上行至咽喉,交贯冲脉。阳维阴维者,维络于身,溢蓄不能环流灌溉诸经者也。故阳维起于诸阳会也,阴维起于诸阴交也。比于圣人图设沟渠,沟渠满溢,流于深湖,故圣人不能拘通也。而人脉隆盛,入于八脉而不环周,故十二经亦不能拘之。其受邪气,蓄则肿热,砭射之也。 【滑寿曰:继,《脉经》作系。督之为言都也,为阳脉之海,所以都纲乎阳脉也。其脉起下极之俞,由会阴历长强,循脊中行至大椎穴,与手足三阳脉交会,上至喑门与阳维会,至百会与太阳交会,上至鼻柱人中与阳明交会。任脉起于中极之下曲骨穴。任者妊也,为人生养之本。冲脉起于气冲穴,至胸中而散,为阴脉之海。《内经》作并足少阴之经。按冲脉行幽门、通谷而上,皆少阴也,当从《内经》。此督、任、冲三脉皆起于会阴,盖一源而分三岐也。
Explanation
To see that the collateral vessels overflow, such that the various meridians can no longer contain them, and thus these extraordinary vessels are formed. Then, might it be said that the extraordinary vessels are formed precisely from the overflow of the collateral vessels? Some say: these three characters "络脉" refer directly to the extraordinary vessels, as spoken of by Yueman (越人), and since they are not bound by the regular meridians, they may be directly called collateral vessels as well.
[This section consists of two parts, listing the names of the eight vessels and explaining the rationale for calling them extraordinary.]
The Twenty-Eighth Difficulty states: these eight extraordinary vessels, not being bound by the twelve main meridians, where do they all originate and where do they continue? The answer is as follows: the Du Meridian originates at the俞 of the lower extremity, runs alongside the spine, ascends to the Fengfu point, and enters to belong to the brain. The Ren Meridian originates below the Zhongji point, ascends along the pubic region, follows the abdomen, goes up to Guanyuan, and reaches the throat. The Chong Meridian originates at Qichong, runs alongside the Yangming meridian of the foot, flanks the umbilicus and ascends to the chest, where it disperses. The Dai Meridian originates at the lateral ribs, encircling the body once. The Yang Qiao Meridian originates at the heel, follows the outer ankle upward, and enters the Fengchi point. The Yin Qiao Meridian also originates at the heel, follows the inner ankle upward to the throat, intersecting the Chong Meridian. The Yang Wei and Yin Wei meridians weave throughout the body, overflowing and accumulating, unable to circulate and nourish the various meridians in a continuous loop. Therefore, the Yang Wei meridian originates at the convergence of all yang channels, and the Yin Wei meridian originates at the intersection of all yin channels. Comparing this to the wise ones who planned channels and ditches, when the ditches overflow, the water flows into deep lakes—thus even the wise cannot control it. Likewise, when the human pulse is full and vigorous, it enters the eight vessels but does not circulate completely around the body, hence the twelve main meridians cannot contain it. When these vessels receive pathogenic factors, if they accumulate, they cause swelling and heat, which are treated by needling or砭 therapy.
[Commentary by Hua Shou: "继" in the Pulse Classic is rendered as "系." The term "Du" means "capital" or "central," and it is called the "sea of yang meridians," for it governs and unifies all yang meridians. Its course begins at the俞 of the lower extremity, passing through the perineum, then through Changqiang, running along the spine to the Dazhui point, where it intersects with the hand and foot yang meridians. It ascends to Yinmen, where it meets the Yang Wei meridian, and to Baihui, where it intersects with the Taiyang meridian, continuing up to the philtrum (Renzhong), where it intersects with the Yangming meridian. The Ren Meridian originates below the Zhongji point at the Qugu point. The term "Ren" means "to bear" or "to carry," and it is the basis for human reproduction. The Chong Meridian originates at the Qichong point, dispersing in the chest, and is called the "sea of yin meridians." According to the Huangdi Neijing, it runs alongside the Shaoyin meridian of the foot. Considering that the Chong Meridian passes through Youmen and Tonggu, both of which belong to Shaoyin, it should be followed as per the Huangdi Neijing. These three meridians—Du, Ren, and Chong—all originate at the perineum, thus emerging from a single source and diverging into three branches.
带脉起季胁下一寸八分,回身一周,犹束带然。阳蹺脉起于足跟中申脉穴,循外踝而行。阴蹺脉亦起于跟中照海穴,循内踝而行。蹻者,捷也。以二脉皆起于足,故取蹺捷超越之义。阳维阴维,维络于身,为阴阳之纲维也。阳维所发,别于金门,以阳交为郄,与手足太阳及蹺脉会于臑俞,与手足少阳会于天髎及会肩井,与足少阳会于阳白,上本神、临泣、正营、脑空,下至风池,与督脉会于风府、痖门,此阳维之起于诸阳之会也。阴维之郄曰筑宾,与足太阴会于腹哀、大横,又与足太阴厥阴会于府舍、期门,又与任脉会于天突、廉泉,此阴维起于诸阴之交也。溢蓄不能环流灌溉诸经者也十二字,当在十二经亦不能拘之之下,则于此无所间,而于彼得相从矣。其受邪气蓄云云十二字,谢氏则以为于本文上下当有缺文,然经脉无此,疑衍文也。或云当在三十七难关格不能尽其命而死矣之下,因邪在六腑而言也。】
二十九难曰:奇经之为病何如?然。阳维维于阳,阴维维于阴,阴阳不能自相维,则怅然失志,溶溶不能自收持。阳维为病,苦寒热。阴维为病苦心痛。阴蹺为病,阳缓而阴急。阳蹺为病,阴缓而阳急。冲之为病,逆气而里急。督之为病,脊强而厥。任之为病,其内苦结,男子为七疝,女子为瘕聚。带之为病,腹满,腰溶溶若坐水中。此奇经八脉之为病也。【阳维为病云云十四字,说见缺误总类。】 【滑寿曰:此言奇经之病也。阴不能维于阴,则怅然失志。阳不能维于阳,则溶溶不能自收持。
Explanation
The Girdle Vessel originates 1.8 cun below the lower flank, encircling the body once, like a belt wrapped around it. The Yang Qiao Vessel originates at the Shenmai point in the center of the heel, running along the outer ankle. The Yin Qiao Vessel also originates at the Zhaohai point in the center of the heel, running along the inner ankle. Qiao means "quick" or "nimble." Since both vessels originate from the foot, the term qiao is used to signify their swift and transcendent nature. The Yang Wei and Yin Wei Vessels connect and link throughout the body, serving as the framework for Yin and Yang. The Yang Wei Vessel, upon its origin, branches off from the Jinmen point, with the Yangjiao point as its郄穴, and converges with the hand and foot Taiyang meridians and the Qiao Vessels at the Naoshu point. It also converges with the hand and foot Shaoyang meridians at the Tianliao and Jianjing points, and with the foot Shaoyang meridian at the Yangbai point, ascending through the Benshen, Linqi, Zhengying, and Naokong points, descending to the Fengchi point, where it converges with the Du Vessel at the Fengfu and Yamen points. This is how the Yang Wei Vessel originates from the convergence of all Yang meridians. The郄穴 of the Yin Wei Vessel is called Zhubin, where it converges with the foot Taiyin meridian at the Fu'ai and Dahan points, and further with the foot Taiyin and Jueyin meridians at the Fusha and Qimen points, and with the Ren Vessel at the Tianchu and Lianquan points. This is how the Yin Wei Vessel originates from the intersection of all Yin meridians. The twelve characters "overflowing and accumulating, unable to circulate and irrigate the various meridians" should be placed beneath the statement "the twelve meridians cannot be confined to this," in which case there would be no separation, and they would align accordingly. The twelve characters "its receiving of pathogenic factors and accumulation" are thought by Xie to indicate a missing passage in the original text, yet the meridians do not mention this, leading to the suspicion that these words are superfluous. Some say that these words should be placed beneath the passage "the thirty-seventh difficulty: when the gate is obstructed and life cannot be sustained, death results," as it refers to pathogenic factors affecting the six fu organs.
The Twenty-Ninth Difficulty asks: What are the diseases associated with the Extraordinary Vessels? The answer is as follows: The Yang Wei Vessel links with Yang, and the Yin Wei Vessel links with Yin. When Yin and Yang cannot support each other, the person becomes despondent and loses their will, feeling dispersed and unable to control themselves. Diseases of the Yang Wei Vessel manifest as alternating chills and fever. Diseases of the Yin Wei Vessel manifest as heart pain. Diseases of the Yin Qiao Vessel manifest as relaxation of the Yang side and tension of the Yin side. Diseases of the Yang Qiao Vessel manifest as relaxation of the Yin side and tension of the Yang side. Diseases of the Chong Vessel manifest as upward rushing of Qi and internal urgency. Diseases of the Du Vessel manifest as stiffness in the spine and fainting. Diseases of the Ren Vessel manifest as internal stagnation; in men, this leads to seven types of hernia; in women, it leads to masses or tumors in the abdomen. Diseases of the Girdle Vessel manifest as abdominal distension and a feeling of heaviness in the lower back, as if sitting in water. These are the diseases associated with the Eight Extraordinary Vessels. [The fourteen characters concerning the diseases of the Yang Wei Vessel are discussed in the section on missing or erroneous text.] [Hua Shou said: This refers to the diseases of the Extraordinary Vessels. When Yin cannot support Yin, the person becomes despondent and loses their will. When Yang cannot support Yang, the person feels dispersed and unable to control themselves.]
阳维行诸阳而主卫,卫为气,气居表,故苦寒热。阴维行诸阴而主荣,荣为血,血属心,故苦心痛。两蹺脉病在阳则阳结急,在阴则阴结急,受病者急,不病者自和缓也。冲脉从关元至咽喉,故逆气里急。督脉行背,故脊强而厥。任脉起胞门行腹,故病苦内结,男为七疝,女为瘕聚也。引之回身一周,故病状如是。溶溶,无力貌。此各以其经脉所过而言之。自二十七难至此,义实相因,最宜通玩。】
三十难曰:荣气之行,常与卫气相随不?然。经言人受气于谷,谷入于胃,乃传于五脏六腑,五脏六腑皆受于气,其清者为荣,浊者为卫,荣行脉中,卫行脉外,营周不息,五十而复大会,阴阳相贯,如环之无端,故知荣卫相随也。 【滑寿曰:此篇与《灵枢》第十八篇之言同。但谷入于胃,乃传于五脏六腑,五脏六腑皆受于气。《灵枢》作谷入于胃,以传于肺,五脏六腑皆以受气,为少殊尔。皆受于气之气,指水谷之气言。五十而复大会,说见一难中。 四明陈氏曰:荣,阴也,其行本迟;卫,阳也,其行本速。然而清者滑利,浊者慓悍,皆非濇滞之体,故凡卫行于外,荣即从行于中,是知其行常得相随,共周其度。 滹南王氏曰:清者体之上也、阳也、火也,离中之一阴降,故午后一阴生,即心之生血也,故曰清气为荣。 〔 天之清不降,地之浊能降为六阴驱而使之下也。云清气者,总离之体言之。〕 浊者,体之下也、阴也、水也,坎中之一阳升,故子后一阳生,即肾之生气也,故曰浊气为卫。
Explanation
The Yang Wei Vessel runs through all the Yang channels and governs Wei qi. Wei is qi, which resides on the surface, hence the person suffers from chills and fever. The Yin Wei Vessel runs through all the Yin channels and governs Ying qi. Ying is blood, which belongs to the heart, hence the person suffers from heart pain. When the two Qiao vessels are diseased, if the disease is in the Yang aspect, the Yang becomes constricted and tense; if in the Yin aspect, the Yin becomes constricted and tense. The part that is affected becomes tense, while the part that is not affected remains naturally relaxed. The Chong Vessel runs from Guanyuan to the throat, hence internal qi rises upward and there is tension in the interior. The Du Vessel runs along the back, hence the spine becomes stiff and there is collapse or fainting. The Ren Vessel originates at the Cao Men and runs through the abdomen, hence the disease causes internal congestion; in men, it manifests as seven types of hernia; in women, it manifests as masses or tumors. By tracing it around the body once, hence the symptoms are as such. "Solong" describes a state of weakness or lack of strength. This is explained according to the meridians that pass through these areas. From the 27th difficulty to this one, the meaning is closely connected; it is most suitable to read through and understand in context.
Thirty Difficulties: Does the Ying qi always move in company with Wei qi? Yes. The classics state that a person receives qi from food, which enters the stomach and is then transmitted to the five zang and six fu organs. All the five zang and six fu organs receive qi. The clear portion becomes Ying, and the turbid portion becomes Wei. Ying flows within the vessels, while Wei flows outside the vessels. Ying circulates ceaselessly, and after fifty cycles it reunites with Wei. Yin and Yang are connected, like a ring with no beginning or end, hence we know that Ying and Wei move in company.
[Comment by Hua Shou: This passage is the same as the discussion in the eighteenth chapter of the Ling Shu. However, the Ling Shu says that food enters the stomach and is transmitted to the lungs, from which the five zang and six fu organs receive qi. This is a slight difference. The "qi that receives qi" refers to the qi of food and drink. The phrase "fifty cycles and then reunite" is explained in the first difficulty.]
[Comment by Master Chen of Siming: Ying is Yin, and its movement is naturally slow; Wei is Yang, and its movement is naturally swift. However, the clear is slippery and smooth, and the turbid is swift and powerful. Neither is obstructed or stagnant. Hence, whenever Wei moves on the exterior, Ying follows it within the vessels. Thus we know that their movement is always in company, completing their cycle together.]
[Comment by Master Wang of Hushan: The clear is the upper part of the body, Yang, and fire. The one Yin descending from the Li (Fire) element, hence after noon one Yin is born, which is the heart's production of blood. Hence it is said that clear qi is Ying.
[The clear of heaven does not descend, but the turbid of earth can descend, being driven downward by the six Yin. When we speak of clear qi, we refer in general to the nature of the Li element.]
The turbid is the lower part of the body, Yin, and water. The one Yang ascending from the Kan (Water) element, hence after midnight one Yang is born, which is the kidney's production of qi. Hence it is said that turbid qi is Wei.
〔 地之浊不升,地之清能升为六阳,举而使之上也。云浊气者,总坎之体言之。〕 经云:地气上为云,大气下为雨,雨出地气,云出天气,此之谓也。愚谓以用而言,则清气为荣者,浊中之清者也;浊气为卫者,清中之浊者也。以体而言,则清之用不离乎浊之体,浊之用不离乎清之体,故谓清气为荣,浊气为卫亦可也,谓荣浊卫清亦可也。纪氏亦云:《素问》曰,荣者水谷之精气,则清;卫者水谷之悍气,则浊。精气入于脉中则浊,悍气行于脉外则清。或问三十二难云:血为荣,气为卫,此则荣卫皆以气言者,何也?曰:经云:荣者水谷之精气,卫者水谷之悍气。又云清气为荣,浊气为卫。盖统而言之,则荣卫皆水谷之气所为,故悉以气言可也,析而言之,则荣为血而卫为气,固自有分矣。是故荣行脉中,卫行脉外。犹水泽之于川浍,风云之于太虚也。】古今图书集成医部全录卷七十
Explanation
〔The turbid aspect of earth does not rise, but the clear aspect of earth can rise and become the six yang energies, being raised upward. When we speak of turbid qi, we are speaking generally of the nature of the Kidney.〕 The classics say: "Earth qi rises to become clouds, and great qi descends to become rain; rain originates from earth qi, and clouds originate from heaven qi"—this is what is meant. I say that in terms of function, clear qi is called ying (nutritive qi), which is the clear aspect within the turbid; turbid qi is called wei (defensive qi), which is the turbid aspect within the clear. In terms of substance, the function of the clear does not separate from the body of the turbid, and the function of the turbid does not separate from the body of the clear. Therefore, it is also acceptable to say that clear qi is ying and turbid qi is wei, or alternatively, that ying is turbid and wei is clear. Ji Shi also says: Suwen states that ying is the refined essence of water and grain, hence clear; wei is the vigorous qi of water and grain, hence turbid. When refined essence enters the vessels, it becomes turbid; when vigorous qi circulates outside the vessels, it becomes clear. Someone may ask, as stated in the 32nd difficulty of the Nan Jing: "Blood is ying, and qi is wei—then why are both ying and wei referred to in terms of qi?" The answer is: the classics say that ying is the refined essence of water and grain, and wei is the vigorous qi of water and grain. It is also said that clear qi is ying and turbid qi is wei. In general terms, both ying and wei are formed from the qi of water and grain, so it is acceptable to refer to them both as qi. In specific terms, however, ying is blood and wei is qi, and thus they naturally have their own distinctions. Therefore, ying flows within the vessels, and wei flows outside the vessels. It is like water and moisture in rivers and ditches, and clouds and winds in the vast void.】 Comprehensive Compilation of Ancient Books: Medical Department, Volume Seventy
三十一难曰:三焦者,何禀何生?何始何终?其治常在何许?可晓以不?然。三焦者,水谷之道路,气之所终始也。上焦者在心下,下膈,在胃上口,主内而不出,其治在膻中,玉堂下一寸六分直两乳间陷者是。中焦者在胃中脘,不上不下,主腐熟水谷,其治在脐旁。下焦者当膀胱上口,主分别清浊,主出而不内以传道也,其治在脐下一寸。故名曰三焦,其腑在气街。【街,一作冲。】 【滑寿曰:人身之腑脏,有形有状,有禀有生,如肝禀气于木生于水,心禀气于火生于木之类,莫不皆然。唯三焦既无形状,而所禀所生,则元气与胃气而已,故云水谷之道路,气之所终始也。上焦其治在膻中,中焦其治在脐旁天枢穴,下焦其治在脐下一寸阴交穴。治,犹司也,犹郡县治之治,谓三焦处所也。或云治作平声读,谓三焦有病,当各治其处,盖刺法也。三焦,相火也,火能腐熟万物,焦从火,亦腐物之气,命名取义,或在于此。《灵枢》第十八篇曰:上焦出于胃上口,并咽以上,贯膈而布胸中,走腋,循太阴之分而行,还至阳明上至舌下足阳明,常与荣卫俱行于阳二十五度,行于阴亦二十五度,一周也,故五十度而复大会于手太阴。中焦亦傍胃口,出上焦之后,此所受气者,泌糟粕,蒸津液,化其精微,上注于肺脉,乃化而为血,以养生身,莫贵于此,故独得行于经隧,命曰营气。下焦者,别回肠注于膀胱而渗入焉。故水谷者,常并居于胃中,成糟粕而俱下于大小肠而成下焦,渗而俱下,济泌别汁,循下焦而渗入膀胱焉。
Explanation
The Thirty-First Difficulty says: What is the origin and source of the Sanjiao? What is its beginning and end? Where is its function usually located? Can you explain it to me? Yes. The Sanjiao is the pathway of water and grain, the beginning and end of Qi. The upper Sanjiao is located below the heart, beneath the diaphragm, at the upper opening of the stomach, receiving but not expelling; its site of regulation is in the膻中, one inch and six fen below the Yutang, directly between the two breasts where there is a depression. The middle Sanjiao is located in the middle of the stomach, neither ascending nor descending, responsible for ripening water and grain; its site of regulation is at the side of the navel. The lower Sanjiao is located at the upper opening of the bladder, responsible for separating the clear from the turbid, expelling but not receiving, serving as the channel for transmission; its site of regulation is one inch below the navel. Hence it is called the Sanjiao, and its organ is located at the Qiqie (vital channel). [The character 街 may also be read as 冲.]
[Slu Shou said: The organs and腑 of the human body have form and shape, have origin and source, such as the liver receiving Qi from wood and born from water, the heart receiving Qi from fire and born from wood, and so on — all are alike in this regard. Only the Sanjiao has no form or shape, and its origin and source are merely the Yuan Qi and the stomach Qi. Hence it is said to be the "pathway of water and grain," the "beginning and end of Qi." The site of regulation of the upper Sanjiao is in the膻中, that of the middle Sanjiao is at the Tianshu (Celestial Pivot) acupoint at the side of the navel, and that of the lower Sanjiao is at the Yinjiao (Yin Intersection) acupoint one inch below the navel. 治 means "to govern," like the governance of a county or province, referring to the location of the Sanjiao. Some say 治 should be read in the level tone, meaning that if the Sanjiao is afflicted, one should treat each of its respective locations, which is a method of acupuncture. The Sanjiao is the Xianghuo (associated fire), for fire can ripen all things; the character 焦 is derived from 火, also the qi of transformation, and the naming of the Sanjiao may be derived from this meaning. The eighteenth chapter of the Ling Shu says: The upper Sanjiao originates at the upper opening of the stomach, ascends through the throat, passes through the diaphragm and spreads throughout the chest, moves toward the armpit, follows the course of the Taiyin meridian, and returns to the Yangming meridian, reaching the base of the tongue. It constantly travels with the Ying Wei (nutritive and defensive) Qi, making twenty-five circuits on the yang channels and twenty-five on the yin channels — one full cycle — and thus returns to the Shoutaiyin (Hand Taiyin) meridian after fifty circuits. The middle Sanjiao is also adjacent to the Weiguan (stomach gate), following after the upper Sanjiao. The Qi it receives is processed to separate dregs from essence, to distill fluids, to refine the subtle substances, which are then transmitted upward to the lung meridian, where they are transformed into blood, essential for sustaining life, and thus it is called Ying Qi (nutritive qi). The lower Sanjiao separates from the large intestine and channels into the bladder, allowing fluids to seep in. Therefore, water and grain are usually together in the stomach, forming dregs, and then descend together into the large and small intestines, forming the lower Sanjiao. They are filtered and descend together, the refined fluids passing through the lower Sanjiao and seeping into the bladder.
谢氏曰:详《灵枢》本文,则三焦有名无形尤可见矣。】 【古益袁氏曰:所谓三焦者,于膈膜脂膏之内,五脏六腑之隙,水谷流化之关,其气融会于其间,熏蒸膈膜,发达皮肤分肉,运行四旁,曰上、中、下,各随所属部分而名之,实元气之别使也。是故虽无其形,倚内外之形而得名;虽无其实,合内外之实而为位者也。愚按其腑在气街一句,疑错简或衍。三焦自属诸腑,其经为手少阳,与手心主配,且各有治所,不应又有腑也。】
三十二难曰:五脏俱等,而心肺独在膈上者,何也?然。心者血,肺者气,血为荣,气为卫,相随上下,谓之荣卫。通行经络,营周于外,故令心肺在膈上也。 【滑寿曰:心荣肺卫,通行经络,营周于外,犹天道之运于上也。膈者,隔也。凡人心下有膈膜,与脊胁周回相着,所以遮隔浊气,不使上熏于心肺也。】 【四明陈氏曰:此特言其位之高下耳。若以五脏德化论之,则尤有说焉。心肺既能以血气生育人身,则此身之父母也,以父母之尊,亦自然居于上矣。《内经》曰:膈肓之上,中有父母。此之谓也。】
三十三难曰:肝青象木,肺白象金;肝得水而沉,木得水而浮;肺得水而浮,金得水而沉。其意何也?然。肝者非为纯木也。乙角也。庚之柔,大言阴与阳,小言夫与妇,释其微阳而吸其微阴之气。其意乐金,又行阴道多,故令肝得水而沉也。肺者非为纯金也,辛商也。丙之柔,大言阴与阳,小言夫与妇,释其微阴婚而就火。其意乐火,又行阳道多,故令肺得水而浮也。
Explanation
Xie said: By examining the original text of the Ling Shu, it becomes especially evident that the Sanjiao has a name but no form.
[Gu Yi Yuan said: What is called the Sanjiao lies within the diaphragm and fatty tissue, in the spaces between the five zang and six fu organs, at the gateway where water and grain are transformed and transported. Its qi merges within this region, steaming the diaphragm, developing the skin and intermuscular spaces, and circulating throughout the body. It is called upper, middle, and lower according to the parts it belongs to, and in reality it is the deputy envoy of the primordial qi. Therefore, although it has no form, it gains its name by relying on the forms of the internal and external; although it has no actual substance, it becomes a position by combining the actual substances of the internal and external. I consider the phrase "its fu is in the qi street" to be possibly misplaced or a duplication. The Sanjiao naturally belongs among the fu organs, its meridian is the Hand Shaoyang, and it pairs with the Hand Jueyin, and each has its own site of treatment; therefore, it should not have another fu as well.]
The 32nd difficulty says: The five zang organs are all equal, yet the heart and lungs are uniquely located above the diaphragm. Why is this so? The answer is: The heart is blood, the lung is qi. Blood is ying, qi is wei. They move together up and down, and are called ying and wei. They circulate through the meridians and nourish the exterior, hence the heart and lungs are located above the diaphragm.
[Guangshou said: The heart is ying, the lung is wei. They circulate through the meridians and nourish the exterior, just as the heavenly way operates above. The diaphragm is a separator. In all people, there is a diaphragm beneath the heart, which connects with the spine and ribs, thus blocking impure qi and preventing it from rising to affect the heart and lungs.]
[Chen of Siming said: This merely refers to the high and low positions. If we consider the virtue and transformation of the five zang organs, there is even more to say. Since the heart and lungs can generate the human body through blood and qi, they are the parents of this body. Given the respect due to parents, they naturally reside above. The Neijing says: "Above the diaphragm and肓, there are the parents." This is precisely what it means.]
The 33rd difficulty says: The liver is green and corresponds to wood; the lung is white and corresponds to metal. The liver sinks when it meets water, while wood floats when it meets water; the lung floats when it meets water, while metal sinks when it meets water. What is the meaning of this? The answer is: The liver is not purely wood. It is the Jiao tone, the soft aspect of Geng. In general terms, it speaks of yin and yang; in specific terms, it speaks of husband and wife. It releases its slight yang and absorbs its slight yin qi. Its nature delights in metal, and it moves more in the yin channel, hence it sinks when it meets water. The lung is not purely metal. It is the Shang tone, the soft aspect of Bing. In general terms, it speaks of yin and yang; in specific terms, it speaks of husband and wife. It releases its slight yin and marries fire. Its nature delights in fire, and it moves more in the yang channel, hence it floats when it meets water.
肺熟而复沉,肝熟而复浮者,何也?故知辛当归庚,乙当归甲也。 【滑寿曰:四明陈氏云,肝属甲乙木,应角音而重浊。析而言之,则甲为木之阳,乙为木之阴;合而言之,则皆阳也。以其属少阳而位于人身之阴分,故为阴中之阳。夫阳者必合阴,甲乙之阴阳,本自为配合,而乙与庚通,刚柔之道,乙乃合甲之微阳而反乐金,故吸受庚金微阴之气,为之夫妇。木之性本浮,以其受金之气而居阴道,故得水而沉也。及熟之,则所受金之气去,乙复归之甲,而木之本体自然还浮也。肺属庚辛金,应商音而轻清。析而言之,则庚为金之阳,辛为金之阴;合而言之,则皆阴也。以其属太阴而位于人身之阳分,故为阳中之阴。夫阴者必合阳,庚辛之阴阳,本自为配合,而辛与丙通刚柔之道,辛乃合庚之微阴。而反乐夫火,故就丙火之阳为之夫妇。金之性本沉,以其受火之气炎上而居阳道,故得水而浮也。及熟之,则所受火之气去,辛复归之庚,而金之本体自然还沉也。】 【古益袁氏曰:肝为阴木乙也,肺为阴金辛也,角商各其音也。乙与庚合,丙与辛合,犹夫妇也。故皆暂舍其本性,而随夫之气习,以见阴阳相感之义焉。况肝位膈下,肺居膈上,上阳下阴,所行之道,性随而分,故木浮而反肖金之沉,金沉而反肖火之上行而浮也。凡物极则反,及其经制化变革则归根复命焉,是以肝肺熟而各肖其木金之本性矣。纪氏曰:肝为阴中之阳,阴性尚多,不随于木,故得水而沉也。肺为阳中之阴,阳性尚多,不随于金,故得水而浮也。
Explanation
Why is it that when matured, the lungs become more sinking, and the liver more floating? Therefore, we understand that xīn returns to gēng, and yǐ returns to jiǎ.
[Slu Shou said: According to the scholar from Simuming, the liver belongs to jiǎ and yǐ wood, corresponding to the tone jiǎo and is heavy and dense. When analyzed separately, jiǎ is the yang aspect of wood, and yǐ is the yin aspect of wood; when considered together, both are yang. Because it belongs to the lesser yang and is located in the yin part of the body, it is thus yang within yin. Yang must always be paired with yin. The yin and yang of jiǎ and yǐ naturally form a pairing, yet yǐ connects with gēng through the principle of hardness and softness. Thus, yǐ combines with the subtle yang of jiǎ and instead finds pleasure in metal, hence it absorbs the subtle yin of gēng metal, forming a metaphorical husband and wife. By nature, wood floats, but because it has received the qi of metal and resides in the yin aspect, it becomes sinking when it meets water. When matured, the influence of metal's qi departs, and yǐ returns to jiǎ, so the natural nature of wood once again rises to the surface.
The lungs belong to gēng and xīn metal, corresponding to the tone shāng and are light and clear. When analyzed separately, gēng is the yang aspect of metal, and xīn is the yin aspect of metal; when considered together, both are yin. Because it belongs to the greater yin and is located in the yang part of the body, it is thus yin within yang. Yin must always be paired with yang. The yin and yang of gēng and xīn naturally form a pairing, yet xīn connects with bǐng through the principle of hardness and softness. Thus, xīn combines with the subtle yin of gēng and instead finds pleasure in fire, hence it aligns with the yang of bǐng fire, forming a metaphorical husband and wife. By nature, metal sinks, but because it has received the fire's upward-moving qi and resides in the yang aspect, it becomes buoyant when it meets water. When matured, the influence of fire's qi departs, and xīn returns to gēng, so the natural nature of metal once again sinks.]
[The ancient scholar from Yizhou said: The liver is yǐ, the yin wood; the lungs are xīn, the yin metal. Each corresponds to its own tone—jiǎo for the liver, shāng for the lungs. Yǐ unites with gēng, and bǐng unites with xīn, just as husband and wife. Therefore, they temporarily set aside their original nature and follow the qi of their partner, illustrating the principle of yin and yang interacting. Moreover, the liver is located below the diaphragm, while the lungs are above it. The upper part is yang, the lower part is yin, and their paths accordingly divide in nature. Hence, wood, which naturally floats, instead resembles the sinking nature of metal, and metal, which naturally sinks, instead resembles the upward movement of fire, thus floating. When any thing reaches its extreme, it reverses; when it undergoes transformation and change, it returns to its root and original nature. Therefore, when the liver and lungs are matured, they each return to their original nature as wood and metal.
Ji Shi said: The liver is yang within yin, and because its yin nature is still predominant, it does not follow the nature of wood, hence it sinks when it meets water. The lungs are yin within yang, and because its yang nature is still predominant, it does not follow the nature of metal, hence it floats when it meets water.]
此乃言其大者耳。若言其小,则乙庚丙辛,夫妇之道也。及其熟而沉浮反者,各归所属,见其本性故也。周氏曰:肝蓄血,血阴也,多血少气,体凝中窒,虽有脉络内经,非玲珑空虚之比,故得水而沉也。及其熟也,濡而润者转为干燥,凝而窒者变为通虚,宜其浮也。肺主气,气阳也,多气少血,体四垂而轻泛,孔窍玲珑,脉络旁达,故得水而浮也。熟则体皆揪敛,孔窍窒实,轻舒者变而紧缩,宜其沉也。斯物理之当然,与五行造化默相符合耳。谢氏曰:此因物之性而推其理也。愚谓肝为阳,阴中之阳也,阴性尚多,故曰微阳,其居在下,行阴道也;肺为阴,阳中之阴也,阳性尚多,故曰微阴,其居在上,行阳道也。熟则无所乐而反其本矣,何也?物熟而相交之气散也。】
三十四难曰:五脏各有声色臭味,皆可晓知以不?然。十变言:肝色青,其臭臊,其味酸,其声呼,其液泣。心色赤,其臭焦,其味苦,其声言,其液汗。脾色黄,其臭香,其味甘,其声歌,其液涎。肺色白,其臭腥,其味辛,其声哭,其液涕。肾色黑,其臭腐,其味咸,其声呻,其液唾。是五脏声色臭味也。 【滑寿曰:此五脏之用也;声色臭味下欠液字。肝色青,臭臊,木化也;呼,出木也;味酸,曲直作酸也;液泣,通乎目也。心色赤臭焦,火化也;言,扬火也;味苦,炎上作苦也;液汗,心主血,汗为血之属也。脾色黄臭香,土化也;歌,缓土也,一云脾神好乐,故其声主歌;味甘,稼穑作甘也;液涎,通乎口也。肺色白臭腥,金化也;哭,惨金也;
Explanation
This is merely speaking of the general case. If we were to speak of the finer details, it would be like the relationship between the heavenly stems Yi, Geng, Bing, and Xin — a matter of the way of husband and wife. When they mature and their tendencies to sink or float reverse, each returns to its own category, revealing its inherent nature. Zhou said: The liver stores blood; blood is yin, having much blood but little qi. Its body is congealed and obstructed internally. Although it has internal meridians and channels, it is not comparable to something hollow and open, hence it sinks when placed in water. When it matures, what was moist and lubricating turns to dryness, and what was congealed and obstructed becomes open and empty — thus it floats. The lung governs qi; qi is yang, having much qi and little blood. Its body is spread out and light, its orifices hollow and open, its meridians extending outward, hence it floats when placed in water. When matured, its body contracts and tightens, its orifices become obstructed and solid, what was light and relaxed turns to tight and constricted — thus it sinks. This is the natural law of things, quietly aligning with the principles of the Five Elements.
Xie said: This is deducing the principle from the nature of the object. I say the liver is yang, the yang within the yin; it still has more yin, hence it is called "subtle yang," residing below and following the yin path. The lung is yin, the yin within the yang; it still has more yang, hence it is called "subtle yin," residing above and following the yang path. When matured, it no longer finds pleasure and returns to its original nature — why? Because when things mature, the mingling qi disperses.
The 34th difficulty says: Each of the five organs has its own sound, color, odor, and taste — can these all be understood? Yes. The Shi Bian (Ten Transformations) says: The liver is green in color, its odor is pungent, its taste is sour, its sound is a call, and its fluid is tears. The heart is red in color, its odor is scorched, its taste is bitter, its sound is speech, and its fluid is sweat. The spleen is yellow in color, its odor is fragrant, its taste is sweet, its sound is song, and its fluid is saliva. The lung is white in color, its odor is fishy, its taste is pungent, its sound is weeping, and its fluid is nasal mucus. The kidney is black in color, its odor is rotten, its taste is salty, its sound is groaning, and its fluid is saliva. These are the sounds, colors, odors, and fluids of the five organs.
[Slip寿 said: This refers to the functions of the five organs; the characters for "fluid" are missing after sound, color, odor, and taste. The liver is green in color, has a pungent odor, and is the transformation of wood; its sound is "call," emerging from wood; its sour taste is due to the bending and straightness of wood; its fluid is tears, connecting with the eyes. The heart is red in color and has a scorched odor, being the transformation of fire; its sound is "speech," elevating fire; its bitter taste is due to fire blazing upward; its fluid is sweat, since the heart governs blood, and sweat is a derivative of blood. The spleen is yellow in color and has a fragrant odor, being the transformation of earth; its sound is song, representing the softness of earth; one says the spleen deity enjoys joy, hence its sound is song; its sweet taste is due to the cultivation and harvesting of earth; its fluid is saliva, connecting with the mouth. The lung is white in color and has a fishy odor, being the transformation of metal; its sound is weeping, representing the sorrowful nature of metal;]
味辛,从革作辛也;液涕,通乎鼻也。肾色黑臭腐,水化也;呻,吟诵也,象水之声;味咸,润下作咸也;液唾,水之属也;】 【四明陈氏曰:肾位远,非伸之则气不得及于息,故声之呻者自肾出也。然肺主声,肝主色,心主臭,脾主味,肾主液,五脏错综,互相有之,故云十变也。】
五脏有七神,各何所藏耶?然。脏者人之神气所舍藏也,故肝藏魂,肺藏魄,心藏神,脾藏意与智,肾藏精与志也。 【滑寿曰:脏者藏也,人之神气藏于内焉。魂者,神明之辅弼也,随神往来谓之魂。魄者,精气之匡佐也,并精而出入者谓之魄。神者,精气之化成也,两精相薄谓之神。脾主思,故藏意与智。肾者作强之官,伎巧出焉,故藏精与志也。此因五脏之用而言五脏之神,是故五用着于外,七神蕴于内也。】
三十五难曰:五脏各有所,腑皆相近,而心肺独去大肠小肠远者,何也?然。经言心荣肺卫,通行阳气,故居在上;大肠小肠传阴气而下,故居在下,所以相去而远也。 【滑寿曰:心荣肺卫,行阳气而居上;大肠小肠,传阴气而居下,不得不相远也。】
又诸腑者皆阳也,清净之处,今大肠、小肠、胃与膀胱,皆受不净,其意何也? 【滑寿曰:又问诸腑既皆阳也,则当为清净之处,何故大肠小肠胃与膀胱,皆受不净耶?】
然。诸腑者谓是,非也。经言小肠者,受盛之腑也;大肠者,传泻行道之腑也;胆者,清净之腑也;胃者,水谷之腑也;膀胱者,津液之腑也。一腑犹无两名,故知非也。
Explanation
The taste is pungent, arising from the transformation of the leather-like element; nasal secretions connect to the nose. The kidney has a black color, a rotten odor, and its transformation is water; the sound of groaning is like the sound of water; the taste is salty, arising from the moistening downward movement; saliva belongs to the element of water. 【Four-Ming Chen said: The kidney is located far away; unless it is reached, the qi cannot reach the breath, hence the sound of groaning comes from the kidney. However, the lung governs sound, the liver governs color, the heart governs odor, the spleen governs taste, and the kidney governs bodily fluids. The five zang organs are interwoven and mutually possess these functions, hence the term "ten transformations."】
The five zang organs each house seven spirits, where are they stored? Yes. The zang organs are the dwelling place of the spirit and vital energy of a person, hence the liver stores the hun, the lung stores the po, the heart stores the shen, the spleen stores intention and wisdom, and the kidney stores essence and will. 【Hua Shou said: The term "zang" means to store; the spirit and vital energy of a person are stored internally. The hun is the assistant to the spiritual consciousness, and is called the hun as it follows the spirit in its movements. The po is the helper of the refined vital energy, and is called the po as it enters and exits with the essence. The shen is the transformation of the essence and vital energy, and is called the shen when two essences meet. The spleen governs thought, hence it stores intention and wisdom. The kidney is the organ of strength and vigor, from which skill and dexterity arise, hence it stores essence and will. This is speaking of the spirit of the five zang organs based on their functions, hence the five functions are expressed externally, while the seven spirits are concealed internally.】
Difficulties of the Thirty-Fifth Question: Each of the five zang organs has its own function, and the fu organs are all close to them, yet the heart and lungs are far from the large and small intestines, why is this so? Yes. The classics state that the heart nourishes and the lung defends, passing through yang energy, hence they are located above; the large and small intestines transmit yin energy downward, hence they are located below, so they are far apart. 【Hua Shou said: The heart nourishes and the lung defends, moving yang energy and residing above; the large and small intestines transmit yin energy and reside below, hence they cannot be close.】
Again, the fu organs are all yang, and are places of purity, yet the large intestine, small intestine, stomach, and bladder all receive impurities, what is the meaning of this? 【Hua Shou said: Another question: if all the fu organs are yang, then they should be places of purity, why then do the large intestine, small intestine, stomach, and bladder all receive impurities?】
Yes. The statement that all the fu organs are so is incorrect. The classics state that the small intestine is the fu organ that receives and holds; the large intestine is the fu organ that transmits and expels; the gallbladder is the pure fu organ; the stomach is the fu organ of water and grain; the bladder is the fu organ of body fluids. One fu organ has only one name, hence it is not correct.
小肠者心之腑,大肠者肺之腑,胆者肝之腑,胃者脾之腑,膀胱者肾之腑。 【滑寿曰:谓诸腑为清净之处者,其说非也。今大肠、小肠、胃与膀胱,各有受任,则非阳之清净矣。各为五脏之腑,固不得而两名也。盖诸腑体为阳而用则阴,经所谓浊阴归六腑是也。云诸腑皆阳,清净之处,唯胆足以当之。】
小肠谓赤肠,大肠谓白肠,胆者谓青肠,胃者谓黄肠,膀胱者谓黑肠,下焦之所治也。 【滑寿曰:此以五脏之色分别五腑,而皆以肠名之也。下焦所治一句,属膀胱,谓膀胱当下焦所治,主分别清浊也。】
三十六难曰:脏各有一耳,肾独有两者,何也?然。肾两者,非皆肾也,其左者为肾,右者为命门。命门者,诸神精之所舍,原气之所系也,男子以藏精,女子以系胞,故知肾有一也。 【滑寿曰:肾有两者,以左为肾。右为命门也。男子于此而藏精,受五脏六腑之精而藏之也;女子于此而系胞,是得精而能施化,胞则受胎之所也。原气谓脐下肾间动气,人之生命,十二经之根本也。此篇言非皆肾也,三十九难亦言左为肾,右为命门,而又云其气与肾通,是肾之两者,其实则一耳。故《项氏家说》引沙随程可久曰:北方常配二物,故惟坎加习于物为龟、为蛇,于方为朔、为北,于大元为罔、为冥。《难经》曰:脏有一而肾独两,此之谓也。】 【此通三十八、三十九难诸篇,前后参考,其义乃尽。】
三十七难曰:五脏之气,于何发起?通于何许?可晓以不?然。五脏者当上关于九窍也。故肺气通于鼻,鼻和则知香臭矣;
Explanation
The Small Intestine is the腑 of the Heart, the Large Intestine is the腑 of the Lungs, the Gallbladder is the腑 of the Liver, the Stomach is the腑 of the Spleen, and the Bladder is the腑 of the Kidneys.
【Hua Shou said: To call the six腑 "pure and clean places" is incorrect. Today, the Large Intestine, Small Intestine, Stomach, and Bladder each have their own functions, and thus are not purely yang and pure. Each is a腑 corresponding to one of the five zang organs, and therefore cannot be given two names. Indeed, the bodies of the腑 are yang in nature, but their functions are yin. This is what the classics say: "the turbid yin returns to the six腑." If it is said that all the腑 are yang and pure, then only the Gallbladder is sufficient to bear this title.】
The Small Intestine is called the Red Intestine, the Large Intestine the White Intestine, the Gallbladder the Green Intestine, the Stomach the Yellow Intestine, and the Bladder the Black Intestine; these are all under the domain of the Lower Jiao.
【Hua Shou said: This is the classification of the five腑 according to the colors of the five zang organs, and all are named "intestine." The phrase "under the domain of the Lower Jiao" refers to the Bladder, meaning that the Bladder is responsible for the function of separating clear from turbid.】
The 36th Difficulty says: Each of the zang organs has one, but the Kidneys have two. Why is this so?
Indeed. Though there are two Kidneys, they are not both the Kidney. The left one is the Kidney, and the right one is the Mingmen. The Mingmen is the dwelling place of the divine essences, and the place where the primordial qi is connected. In men, it stores essence; in women, it connects the womb. Hence, we know that the Kidneys are essentially one.
【Hua Shou said: There are two Kidneys, with the left being the Kidney and the right being the Mingmen. In men, this is where essence is stored, receiving the essence from the five zang and six腑 and storing it; in women, this is where the womb is connected, allowing essence to be received and transformed, and the womb is the place where conception occurs. The term "primordial qi" refers to the dynamic qi beneath the navel, between the kidneys, which is the source of human life and the root of the twelve meridians. This passage says they are not both Kidneys. The 39th Difficulty also says the left is the Kidney and the right is the Mingmen, and further says that its qi communicates with the Kidney, thus the two Kidneys are in fact one. Hence, Xiang Shi Jia Shuo quotes Cheng Kejiu of Sha Sui: "The North is usually paired with two things, so only Kan is associated with the turtle and the snake, with the direction of the beginning and the north, and with the Great Primordial as Wang and Ming. The Nan Jing says: 'Each zang has one, but the Kidneys have two' — this is what is meant.】
【This passage should be read together with the 38th and 39th Difficulties, referring back and forth to fully understand its meaning.】
The 37th Difficulty says: From where does the qi of the five zang organs originate? Through which channels does it pass? Can this be explained?
Indeed. The five zang organs correspond upward to the nine orifices. Thus, the Lung qi communicates with the nose; when the nose is in harmony, one can discern fragrance and odor.
肝气通于目,目和则知黑白矣;脾气通于口,口和则知谷味矣;心气通于舌,舌和则知五味矣;肾气通于耳,耳和则知五音矣。 【滑寿曰:谢氏云,本篇问五脏之气,于何发起?通于何许?答文止言五脏通九窍之义,而不及五脏之发起,恐有缺文。愚按五脏发起,当如二十三难流注之说。上关九窍,《灵枢》作七窍者是。下同。】
五脏不和,则九窍不通;六腑不和,则留结为痈。 【滑寿曰:此二句是结上起下之辞。五脏,阴也,阴不和则病于内;六腑阳也,阳不和,则病于外。】
邪在六腑,则阳脉不和,阳脉不和则气留之,气留之则阳脉盛矣。邪在五脏,则阴脉不和,阴脉不和则血留之,血留之则阴脉盛矣。阴气太盛,则阳气不得相营也,故曰格。阳气太盛,则阴气不得相营也,故曰关。阴阳俱盛,不得相营也,故曰关格。关格者,不得尽其命而死矣。 【滑寿曰:此与《灵枢》十七篇文大同小异。或云二十八难其受邪气蓄则肿热砭射之也十二字,当为此章之结语。盖阴阳之气太盛,而至于关格者,必死。若但受邪气,蓄则宜砭射之。其者指物之辞,因上文六腑不和,及邪在六腑而言之也。】
经言气独行于五脏,不营于六腑者,何也?然。夫气之所行也,如水之流不得息也,故阴脉行于五脏,阳脉营于六腑,如环无端,莫知其纪,终而复始,其不覆溢,人气内温于脏腑,外濡于腠理。 【滑寿曰:此因上章营字而推及之也。与《灵枢》十七篇文大同小异。
Explanation
The Liver qi communicates with the eyes; when the eyes are harmonious, one can distinguish between black and white. The Spleen qi communicates with the mouth; when the mouth is harmonious, one can discern the taste of grains. The Heart qi communicates with the tongue; when the tongue is harmonious, one can distinguish the five flavors. The Kidney qi communicates with the ears; when the ears are harmonious, one can discern the five musical tones.
【Hua Shou said: Xie said, this chapter asks about the origin of the five zang qi, and where they communicate. The answer only speaks of the five zang communicating with the nine orifices, but does not address the origin of the five zang, suggesting there may be missing text. I believe the origin of the five zang should be understood according to the theory of circulation found in the 23rd difficulty. In the Ling Shu, it refers to seven orifices, which is correct. The same applies below.】
When the five zang are not in harmony, the nine orifices become obstructed; when the six fu are not in harmony, stagnation occurs and results in abscesses.
【Hua Shou said: These two sentences serve as a conclusion to the previous and an introduction to the following. The five zang belong to yin; when yin is unharmonious, disease occurs internally. The six fu belong to yang; when yang is unharmonious, disease occurs externally.】
When pathogenic factors reside in the six fu, the yang pulse becomes unharmonious; when the yang pulse is unharmonious, qi stagnates; when qi stagnates, the yang pulse becomes excessive. When pathogenic factors reside in the five zang, the yin pulse becomes unharmonious; when the yin pulse is unharmonious, blood stagnates; when blood stagnates, the yin pulse becomes excessive. When yin qi is excessively strong, yang qi cannot nourish it, hence it is called ge (obstruction). When yang qi is excessively strong, yin qi cannot nourish it, hence it is called guan (blockage). When both yin and yang are excessively strong and cannot nourish each other, it is called guan ge (obstruction and blockage). Those who suffer from guan ge will not live out their full lifespan and will die.
【Hua Shou said: This passage is largely similar to the 17th chapter of the Ling Shu. Some say that the twelve characters from the 28th difficulty—“its reception of pathogenic qi, accumulation leading to swelling and heat, and treatment by acupuncture and bloodletting”—should serve as the concluding statement of this chapter. For when yin and yang qi are excessively strong and lead to guan ge, death is inevitable. If it is merely due to the reception of pathogenic qi, and accumulation occurs, then acupuncture and bloodletting should be used. The word “its” is a demonstrative pronoun referring to the previous discussion of the six fu organs.】
The classics state: “Qi flows exclusively through the five zang and does not circulate through the six fu. Why is this so?” The answer is: The movement of qi is like the flow of water, unceasing. Therefore, the yin pulse circulates through the five zang, and the yang pulse circulates through the six fu, like a ring with no beginning or end, its cycle unknowable, yet it ends and begins again. It does not overflow or spill over; human qi warms the zang-fu internally and moistens the skin and muscles externally.
【Hua Shou said: This passage is an extension of the term ying (nutritive qi) from the previous chapter. It is largely similar to the 17th chapter of the Ling Shu.】